ATProto -> ActivityPub images are not transmitted.

[KDederichs]

It seems that Bluesky posts that have images attached do not transmit them to Mastodon. All the image posts in my feed are just text :)

[snarfed]

Hmm, that's definitely worked before, and it worked in my tests. Here's an example: Bluesky post, bridged fediverse post with image is visible on @snarfed.bsky.social@atproto.brid.gy 's timeline if you scroll down.

What's your Bluesky handle?

[KDederichs]

Well I'm following that profile for example via Bridgy on Mastodon:
https://bsky.app/profile/shrimposaurus.bsky.social

The Posts are basically all with image but none of them show up (it's backfilling just the text)

[snarfed]

Understood. Which instance are you viewing your profile on? Ie where is this screenshot from?

[KDederichs]

It's my own one man instance (screenshot taken using Ivory).
You're right though, images used to work at some point:

That's the one you posted a while ago.

So probably something broke between then and now

[KDederichs]

Just FYI:
It also doesn't import new posts with images, I was digging through the logs to see if it actually processed stuff but nope:

nginx/access.log: [06/May/2024:20:03:16 +0000] "POST /inbox HTTP/2.0" 202 0 "-" "Bridgy Fed (https://fed.brid.gy/)"

journalctl:

May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512218]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:16.426814 #1512218]  INFO -- : [be8e8ebe-b0d4-4209-8128-ed72c59b6f32] method=POST path=/inbox format=*/* controller=ActivityPub::InboxesController action=create status=202 allocations=11672 duration=16.05 view=0.00 db=1.91 key=https://bsky.brid.gy/ap/did:plc:jaes5qxvg6ffn62rsqrrrtuc#key
May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:16.460Z pid=1512185 tid=2hc4ht class=DistributionWorker jid=8f788cdff35b85ed3e2e5e8c INFO: start
May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:16.461Z pid=1512185 tid=2fsnwd class=ActivityPub::ProcessingWorker jid=e0da406425e0e6556cfdbb5d elapsed=0.035 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:16.483Z pid=1512185 tid=2fz06l class=FeedInsertWorker jid=5a7403d5069678bc96f5c1f4 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:16.495Z pid=1512185 tid=2hc4ht class=DistributionWorker jid=8f788cdff35b85ed3e2e5e8c elapsed=0.035 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:16 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:16.504Z pid=1512185 tid=2fz06l class=FeedInsertWorker jid=5a7403d5069678bc96f5c1f4 elapsed=0.021 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:28 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:28.810Z pid=1512185 tid=2hh9ah class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=cf66c839d60ee8b9961498bf INFO: start
May 06 20:03:28 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:28.815Z pid=1512185 tid=2hh9ah class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=cf66c839d60ee8b9961498bf elapsed=0.005 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.262Z pid=1512185 tid=2fobkl class=ActivityPub::ProcessingWorker jid=1ec10e54264620be44a0336b INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512210]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:30.262545 #1512210]  INFO -- : [1695d8cf-7c25-4cb5-8767-3e164dafedfc] method=POST path=/inbox format=html controller=ActivityPub::InboxesController action=create status=202 allocations=11700 duration=16.06 view=0.00 db=1.77 key=https://infosec.exchange/users/briankrebs#main-key
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.742Z pid=1512185 tid=2hh9ah class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedCollectionWorker jid=b91c07d0f56081ea8a6c8d9e INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.744Z pid=1512185 tid=2hby35 class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedTagsCollectionWorker jid=b7f58a733b3d07cd7089d7b5 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.754Z pid=1512185 tid=2hc5e1 class=VerifyAccountLinksWorker jid=22e2deb05ad2bfb2d4d3d2a1 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.823Z pid=1512185 tid=2fupup class=DistributionWorker jid=6498bece775d619e470d78ec INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.879Z pid=1512185 tid=2hby35 class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedTagsCollectionWorker jid=b7f58a733b3d07cd7089d7b5 elapsed=0.135 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.886Z pid=1512185 tid=2fupup class=DistributionWorker jid=6498bece775d619e470d78ec elapsed=0.063 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.887Z pid=1512185 tid=2ht3cx class=DistributionWorker jid=02ceb210b0558a0ad72d2b2f INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.889Z pid=1512185 tid=2fobkl class=ActivityPub::ProcessingWorker jid=1ec10e54264620be44a0336b elapsed=0.627 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.990Z pid=1512185 tid=2hiu1x class=FeedInsertWorker jid=d75e3978a9410a1d0ad8b3d0 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:30 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:30.998Z pid=1512185 tid=2ht3cx class=DistributionWorker jid=02ceb210b0558a0ad72d2b2f elapsed=0.111 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:31 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:31.018Z pid=1512185 tid=2hiu1x class=FeedInsertWorker jid=d75e3978a9410a1d0ad8b3d0 elapsed=0.028 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:31 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:31.210Z pid=1512185 tid=2hh9ah class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedCollectionWorker jid=b91c07d0f56081ea8a6c8d9e elapsed=0.468 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:34 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:34.609Z pid=1512185 tid=2fejwp class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=aa47e6820bb8bc2a09a49488 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:34 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:34.613Z pid=1512185 tid=2fejwp class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=aa47e6820bb8bc2a09a49488 elapsed=0.004 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:35 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:35.665Z pid=1512185 tid=vzlx INFO: queueing Scheduler::IndexingScheduler (indexing_scheduler)
May 06 20:03:35 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:35.665Z pid=1512185 tid=3gcmd INFO: queueing Scheduler::SuspendedUserCleanupScheduler (suspended_user_cleanup_scheduler)
May 06 20:03:35 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:35.668Z pid=1512185 tid=2fevgt class=Scheduler::IndexingScheduler jid=dc84a213aff3f795e916486e INFO: start
May 06 20:03:35 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:35.669Z pid=1512185 tid=2fyumh class=Scheduler::SuspendedUserCleanupScheduler jid=3cdf71d2ad5c7c119fd0a570 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:35 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:35.807Z pid=1512185 tid=2fevgt class=Scheduler::IndexingScheduler jid=dc84a213aff3f795e916486e elapsed=0.139 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:37 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:37.679Z pid=1512185 tid=2hc5e1 class=VerifyAccountLinksWorker jid=22e2deb05ad2bfb2d4d3d2a1 elapsed=6.925 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:43 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:43.795Z pid=1512185 tid=2fyyyh class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=621bd9e4fd39b33b717e3af7 INFO: start
May 06 20:03:43 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:03:43.799Z pid=1512185 tid=2fyyyh class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=621bd9e4fd39b33b717e3af7 elapsed=0.004 INFO: done
May 06 20:03:46 mastodon bundle[1512210]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:46.106019 #1512210]  INFO -- : [85a256b4-2214-4a12-8956-15b6e08efa32] method=GET path=/api/v1/statuses/112395928317336783 format=*/* controller=Api::V1::StatusesController action=show status=200 allocations=15474 duration=34.93 view=17.96 db=5.78
May 06 20:03:46 mastodon bundle[1512218]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:46.463740 #1512218]  INFO -- : [d66dafdb-46e9-463c-bb7e-9de6a3f834b3] method=GET path=/api/v1/notifications format=*/* controller=Api::V1::NotificationsController action=index status=200 allocations=3568 duration=11.84 view=0.41 db=2.92
May 06 20:03:46 mastodon bundle[1512210]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:46.485220 #1512210]  INFO -- : [6b66f33a-0f15-41d2-b9b8-9f793a4afbe7] method=GET path=/api/v1/notifications format=*/* controller=Api::V1::NotificationsController action=index status=200 allocations=7697 duration=15.89 view=0.50 db=4.08
May 06 20:03:46 mastodon bundle[1512218]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:46.599302 #1512218]  INFO -- : [e82ae822-320e-4bee-bcb7-83c95c26d9fb] method=GET path=/api/v1/timelines/home format=*/* controller=Api::V1::Timelines::HomeController action=show status=200 allocations=57077 duration=132.74 view=91.84 db=10.04
May 06 20:03:46 mastodon bundle[1512210]: I, [2024-05-06T20:03:46.700306 #1512210]  INFO -- : [48d95a4a-2203-4d6f-9200-726ce073ac1d] method=GET path=/api/v1/accounts/109298785969056377/statuses format=*/* controller=Api::V1::Accounts::StatusesController action=index status=200 allocations=194531 duration=247.42 view=164.09 db=9.76
May 06 20:04:01 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:04:01.642Z pid=1512185 tid=2hvp75 class=ActivityPub::ProcessingWorker jid=8a926420a65a12204a99a96c INFO: start
May 06 20:04:01 mastodon bundle[1512218]: I, [2024-05-06T20:04:01.642481 #1512218]  INFO -- : [401fda6b-4129-40e6-b6ad-e5b20610c53d] method=POST path=/actor/inbox format=*/* controller=ActivityPub::InboxesController action=create status=202 allocations=17599 duration=56.60 view=0.00 db=1.12 key=https://relay.fedi.buzz/tag/furry#key
May 06 20:04:02 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:04:02.149Z pid=1512185 tid=2fyxe5 class=LinkCrawlWorker jid=226e30051bc0166ad6b9bfe1 INFO: start
May 06 20:04:02 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:04:02.743Z pid=1512185 tid=2fejwp class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedCollectionWorker jid=ce96cb2d39dae04a442da830 INFO: start
May 06 20:04:02 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:04:02.749Z pid=1512185 tid=2fupup class=ActivityPub::SynchronizeFeaturedTagsCollectionWorker jid=361b5bee4fc7ea482b367043 INFO: start
May 06 20:04:02 mastodon bundle[1512185]: 2024-05-06T20:04:02.759Z pid=1512185 tid=2fobkl class=VerifyAccountLinksWorker jid=284517dde588e0fdba092e07 INFO: start

As you can see there's no image processing of any kind going on here

[snarfed]

Fixed! Example: https://bsky.app/profile/snarfed.bsky.social/post/3ksle7ylzr32y => https://indieweb.social/@snarfed.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gy/112448844896914755

[snarfed]

This was https://console.cloud.google.com/errors/detail/CL6Jzu_r-6aThQE;time=P30D?project=bridgy-federated .

[KDederichs]

You sure it's fixed?
The account from above just posted 3 posts with images in them but now not even the posts are getting bridged.
Might be some unrelated new error though.

[snarfed]

Unrelated new error indeed. Catching up now, sorry!

[vyv03354]

Some Bluesky posts say that images are bridged only if they have ALT.
https://bsky.app/search?q=Bridgy+Fed+ALT

[vyv03354]

Example:
Original Bsky post => Bridged post: only an image with ALT is bridged.

[snarfed]

@vyv03354 hmm! Definitely a bug if true, not intentional. I'll look.

[snarfed]

Confirmed, images with blank alt text aren't working. @vyv03354 thanks for the nudge!

[snarfed]

Fixed! Example: https://bsky.app/profile/snarfed.bsky.social/post/3ksuth5fk632i => https://indieweb.social/@snarfed.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gy/112470182089152821 (requires login)

Thanks again @vyv03354!