Configuration for default settings not working

[dbu]

For SonataDoctrinePhpcrAdmin, we usually define a tree block. We define a default setting for the id value. See for example https://github.com/symfony-cmf/cmf-sandbox/blob/master/app/config/config.yml#L139

This parameter is defined in the SonataBlockBundle configuration class. However, i can't find it being processed in the DI extension and it does not arrive at our TreeBlockService

[rmsint]

@dbu saw your note, remembered some idea that maybe could help. Could it be because the 'id' setting is already defined in the TreeBlockService as default with value "/"? And the blockcontext manager merges all settings for id were the service setting for "id" overwrites the bundle setting for the "id"? Maybe to make the bundle setting work, the service default settings can be removed and moved to the DI extension of 'SonataDoctrinePhpcrBundle and perpended as config for "SonataBlockBundle".

[dbu]

@rmsint but should those settings not be processed by the SonataBlockBundle? any idea why we had the idea that settings would be passed on to the block / service? i don't see why that would happen in https://github.com/sonata-project/SonataBlockBundle/blob/master/DependencyInjection/SonataBlockExtension.php

should we just configure our block service with the base path instead of hardcoding the default? however, that would mean there can be only one single block (or rather, they all have the same root path which at least would become configurable).

@rande can you help us here?

[puffinofdoom]

Has there been any progress with this?

[dbu]

not to my knowledge.

[jordisala1991]

Maybe this PR needs to be rescued: #222