Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Enhance the detection mechanism for the unhealthy etcd node #7730

Closed
JmPotato opened this issue Jan 18, 2024 · 1 comment
Closed

Enhance the detection mechanism for the unhealthy etcd node #7730

JmPotato opened this issue Jan 18, 2024 · 1 comment
Labels
component/election Election related logic. type/enhancement The issue belongs to an enhancement.

Comments

@JmPotato
Copy link
Member

Part of #7499.

In various tests, we always observe continuous unavailability when injecting IO latency and other chaos into the PD leader node., like #6291. Upon further investigation of the logs, we discovered that the detection and eviction of unhealthy nodes are not always accurate. As a result, problematic etcd nodes can persistently impact our requests due to the round-robin balancer used by the etcd client. Especially during the leader switch, this problem could cause the PD leader unable to be stabilized and prolong the election, which affects the availability a lot.

2024-01-17 12:42:26 | {"level":"INFO","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163","pod":"tc-pd-1","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]"} | 
2024-01-17 12:41:33 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:41:33 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:41:31 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:41:31 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:47 | {"level":"INFO","pod":"tc-pd-2","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:47 | {"level":"INFO","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163","pod":"tc-pd-1","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:46 | {"level":"INFO","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163","pod":"tc-pd-1","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]"} | 
2024-01-17 12:40:45 | {"level":"INFO","pod":"tc-pd-2","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:45 | {"level":"INFO","pod":"tc-pd-2","container":"pd","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:39 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:39 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:31 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:40:31 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=3->2] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:39:27 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"} |  
2024-01-17 12:39:27 | {"pod":"tc-pd-0","container":"pd","level":"INFO","log":"[etcdutil.go:314] [\"update endpoints\"] [num-change=2->3] [last-endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"] [endpoints=\"[http://tc-pd-0.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-2.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379,http://tc-pd-1.tc-pd-peer.endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163.svc:2379]\"]","namespace":"endless-ha-test-tps-6150264-1-163"}

For now, we just use 10 seconds as the timeout for the health check, it's kind of too loose in some cases. We require a more precise detection mechanism to promptly remove an unhealthy etcd node from the available endpoints and prevent it from rejoining before it truly recovers.
@JmPotato JmPotato added type/enhancement The issue belongs to an enhancement. component/election Election related logic. labels Jan 18, 2024
@HuSharp HuSharp mentioned this issue Jan 18, 2024
Closed
This was referenced Jan 19, 2024
Merged
Merged
ti-chi-bot bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jan 22, 2024
@JmPotato
etcdutil: move health checker into a separate file (#7743)
d9789dc 
ref #7730

Move the health checker into a separate file.

Signed-off-by: JmPotato <ghzpotato@gmail.com>
ti-chi-bot bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jan 30, 2024
@JmPotato
etcdutil: consider the latency while patrolling the healthy endpoints (…
1c54865 
…#7737)

ref #7730

Consider the latency while patrolling the healthy endpoints to reduce the effect of slow nodes.
Now, there are the following strategies to select and remove unhealthy endpoints:

- Choose only the healthy endpoint within the lowest acceptable latency range.
- The evicted endpoint can only rejoin if it is selected again for three consecutive times.

Signed-off-by: JmPotato <ghzpotato@gmail.com>
@JmPotato JmPotato mentioned this issue Jan 30, 2024
Merged
ti-chi-bot bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jan 31, 2024
@JmPotato
etcdutil: return original enpoints when all are evicted (#7779)
357ad3f 
ref #7499, ref #7730

Return the originally picked endpoints directly if all are evicted to gain better availability.

Signed-off-by: JmPotato <ghzpotato@gmail.com>
@JmPotato
Copy link
Member Author

JmPotato commented Feb 6, 2024

Close with #7737.

@JmPotato JmPotato closed this as completed Feb 6, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
component/election Election related logic. type/enhancement The issue belongs to an enhancement.
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
1 participant
@JmPotato