macOS - incorrect behavior at Full Screen

[Oleg-Chashko]

Full.Screen.mp4

[sweetppro]

@Oleg-Chashko uggh, fullscreen support really is troublesome. there are so many different scenarios which need to be accounted for. ill take another look tomorrow

[Oleg-Chashko]

@sweetppro
Thanks, for some reason I think that full screen mode is not really needed by this application?

[sweetppro]

@Oleg-Chashko yeah it is a weird way to use Transmission, but im sure some probably find it useful...

[ckerr]

I hate to make macOS UI suggestions based on other platforms, but FWIW neither the GTK nor Qt apps have full-screen.

I'd be OK with removing it unless it's idiomatic for macOS apps to have a full-screen mode

[GaryElshaw]

It is 'normal' to have that function.

[Oleg-Chashko]

Not all macOS applications use full screen mode.
The developer uses this mode at his own discretion in his application.
It seems to me that almost no one uses this mode in this application.
Since this mode was broken a long time ago and maybe never worked correctly.
And there is no one in the larger community who created this issue before me.
And I wouldn't have created it this issue because I don't use full screen mode in this app.

Example:

[sweetppro]

It would definitely save a lot of headaches to remove full screen support

[Oleg-Chashko]

To solve the problem with full screen mode:
need to create an algorithm that disables the "Auto resize" option when using full screen mode.
With "Auto resize" option disabled there is no problem with full screen mode.
I have already described this conflict.

[sweetppro]

@Oleg-Chashko are you running the latest version? I’ve already done this

[sweetppro]

The issue I’m facing right now is showing and hiding the filter/status bar if the toolbar is shown (in full screen mode) - but only if either/both is not showing when full screen is enabled…

I’m out excercising now, and will have another crack at this when I get home this afternoon.

[Oleg-Chashko]

@Oleg-Chashko are you running the latest version? I’ve already done this

v.3.00+8d61f07930

[sweetppro]

Which version of macOS?

[Oleg-Chashko]

Which version of macOS?

macOS Monterey v.12.4 (21F79)

[sweetppro]

Hmm,
That’s what I’m running.
And the issue you describe is not happening for me. The issue I have is the issue I described above

[sweetppro]

See here https://github.com/transmission/transmission/pull/3191/files

specifically windowWillEnterFullScreen And windowDidExitFullScreen

[Oleg-Chashko]

Fullscreen mode always worked fine.
Only it always conflicted with the "Auto Resize" feature that was on.

172131137-178b67fb-0ab2-4fc0-8b6d-842f5ba5a3be.mp4

[sweetppro]

Fullscreen mode always worked fine.
Only it always conflicted with the "Auto Resize" feature that was on.

That’s what I don’t understand, I disabled auto resize while in full screen in #3195

[Oleg-Chashko]

Fullscreen mode always worked fine.
Only it always conflicted with the "Auto Resize" feature that was on.

That’s what I don’t understand, I disabled auto resize while in full screen in #3195

Unfortunately, "auto resize" is not disabled in full screen mode.

Screen.mp4

[Coding4Coffee]

+1 for getting rid of full screen support. I would not say that a torrent client is a primary use day to day, and most users will be multi tasking in the background. The extra screen real estate full screen provides, does not add any real benefit to the user experience imo, apart from a bunch of white space.

The auto resize function is more than enough for my use case

[ckerr]

I'm also leaning towards "remove".

Code that doesn't exist has fewer bugs than code that exists...

[Oleg-Chashko]

The full screen mode does not work properly.

[GaryElshaw]

See #3278

[Oleg-Chashko]

v.3.00+c6b49e99d8 - Fixed.