Changes needed to execute release tests

Control measure costs were updated to reflect deprecation of $/occupant units. Commercial daylighting and integrated NGHP measures also required cost unit updates to $/ft^2 floor to work with updated baseline cost units in $/kBtu/h service demand. The flag for cost unit translation in ecm_prep.py was amended to address a bug uncovered when running commercial controls measures that span multiple end uses (heating, cooling, ventilation, lighting). Finally, the commit revises a part of run.py that links all stock turnover calculations for measures spanning multiple end use technologies that include heating and//or cooling to a single heating or (if unavailable) cooling technology in the measure definition. This part of the code was not properly handling non-heating/cooling technologies in the measure definition (for example, lighting and ventilation technologies in a controls measure definition that spans heating, cooling, ventilation and lighting end uses).
trynthink · Jan 31, 2022 · 05b6288 · 05b6288
1 parent f23c783
commit 05b6288
Show file tree

Hide file tree

Showing 18 changed files with 155 additions and 157 deletions.
diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective AFDD + Submetering 2030.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective AFDD + Submetering 2030.json
@@ -53,15 +53,15 @@
       "URL": "http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build07/PDF/b07023.pdf"}]},
   "installed_cost": 0.1466,
   "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
-  "installed_cost_source": {
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 20% HVAC energy savings and 1 year payback threshold",
+  "installed_cost_source":{
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 15,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Com. Comfort Ctl. 2030.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Com. Comfort Ctl. 2030.json
@@ -44,17 +44,17 @@
       "pages": [536, 548],
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269576957_A_knowledge_based_approach_for_selecting_energy-aware_and_comfort-driven_HVAC_temperature_set_points"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 49,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.245,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` large office factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Com. Occupancy Ctl. 2030.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Com. Occupancy Ctl. 2030.json
@@ -43,17 +43,17 @@
       "pages": null,
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259933762_Reducing_Energy_Waste_for_Computers_by_Human-in-the-Loop_Control"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 36,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.18,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` large office factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial AVCT HVAC (FS).json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial AVCT HVAC (FS).json
@@ -20,11 +20,14 @@
   },
   "market_exit_year": null,
   "market_exit_year_source": null,
-  "energy_efficiency": 6.02,
+  "energy_efficiency": {
+    "cooling": 6.05,
+    "heating": 3.03
+  },
   "energy_efficiency_units": "BTU out/BTU in",
   "energy_efficiency_source": {
-    "notes": "From Table 3, convert from primary COP target of 2.01 to COP by multiplying by 3.01, COP = BTU out/BTU in",
-    "source_data": {
+    "notes": "Convert from primary COP (from Table 3 in BTO MYPP) to COP, multiply by 3.01; heating COP approximated as half of the cooling COP",
+    "source data": {
       "title": "Building Technologies Office Multi-Year Program Plan",
       "author": null,
       "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy",

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Comfort Ctl..json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Comfort Ctl..json
@@ -44,17 +44,17 @@
       "pages": [536, 548],
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269576957_A_knowledge_based_approach_for_selecting_energy-aware_and_comfort-driven_HVAC_temperature_set_points"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 49,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.245,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` large office factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Daylighting.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Daylighting.json
@@ -19,10 +19,10 @@
     "notes": "Target performance based on expert judgment regarding the opportunity for potential improvement relative to current state-of-the-art",
     "source_data": null
   },
-  "installed_cost": 13.98,
-  "cost_units": "2016$/ft^2 glazing",
+  "installed_cost": 1.38,
+  "cost_units": "2016$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source": {
-    "notes": "Target cost based on 5 year payback period objective",
+    "notes": "Target cost based on 5 year payback period objective; convert from original units of $/ft^2 glazing to $/ft^2 floor using large office factors (glazing->wall->floor) in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": null
   },
   "product_lifetime": 20,

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Integrated NGHP.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Integrated NGHP.json
@@ -33,25 +33,17 @@
       "URL": "https://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2016/02/f29/BTO_MYPP_2016.pdf"
     }
   },
-  "installed_cost": 60.38,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/kBtu/h heating",
+  "installed_cost": 1.91,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source": {
-    "notes": "$1.1/ft^2 floor cost premium * 1 ft^2 floor/0.020 kBtu/h heating (see Scout 'ecm_cost_convert.json' file) + baseline cost of $5.38/kBtu/h ($2150 for 2020 'typical' commercial gas-fired furnace / 400 kBtu/h typical input capacity, from EIA data)",
+    "notes": "$1.1/ft^2 floor cost premium + baseline cost of $0.8112/ft^2 floor ($40.56/kBtu/h heating ($32450 for 2020 'typical' commercial gas-fired boiler / 800 kBtu/h typical input capacity, from EIA data), multiplied by 0.020 kBtu/h heating/ft^2 floor (see Scout directory, ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json)",
     "source_data": [{
       "title": "Building Technologies Office Multi-Year Program Plan",
       "author": null,
       "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy",
       "year": 2016,
-      "pages": 75,
+      "pages": 98,
       "URL": "https://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2016/02/f29/BTO_MYPP_2016.pdf"
-    },
-    {
-      "title": "Updated Buildings Sector Appliance and Equipment Costs and Efficiencies",
-      "author": null,
-      "organization": "U.S. Energy Information Administration",
-      "year": 2018,
-      "pages": 90,
-      "URL": "https://www.eia.gov/analysis/studies/buildings/equipcosts/pdf/full.pdf"
     }]
   },
   "product_lifetime": 23,

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial NVC HVAC (FS).json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial NVC HVAC (FS).json
@@ -20,10 +20,13 @@
   },
   "market_exit_year": null,
   "market_exit_year_source": null,
-  "energy_efficiency": 6.86,
+  "energy_efficiency": {
+    "cooling": 6.86,
+    "heating": 3.43
+  },
   "energy_efficiency_units": "BTU out/BTU in",
   "energy_efficiency_source": {
-    "notes": "Convert from primary COP of 2.28 (Table 3) to COP by multiplying by 3.01, COP=BTU out/BTU in",
+    "notes": "Convert from primary COP of 2.28 (from Table 3 in BTO MYPP) to COP, multiply by 3.01; heating COP approximated as half of the cooling COP",
     "source_data":{
       "title": "Building Technologies Office Multi-Year Program Plan",
       "author": null,

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Occupancy Ctl..json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Commercial Occupancy Ctl..json
@@ -43,17 +43,17 @@
       "pages": null,
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259933762_Reducing_Energy_Waste_for_Computers_by_Human-in-the-Loop_Control"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 36,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.18,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` large office factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Res. Comfort Ctl. 2030.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Res. Comfort Ctl. 2030.json
@@ -43,17 +43,17 @@
       "pages": [536, 548],
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269576957_A_knowledge_based_approach_for_selecting_energy-aware_and_comfort-driven_HVAC_temperature_set_points"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 91,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.095,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` SFH home factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Res. Occupancy Ctl. 2030.json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Res. Occupancy Ctl. 2030.json
@@ -41,17 +41,17 @@
       "year": 2013,
       "pages": null,
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259933762_Reducing_Energy_Waste_for_Computers_by_Human-in-the-Loop_Control"}]},
-  "installed_cost": 70,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.07,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` SFH home factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential AVCT HVAC (FS).json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential AVCT HVAC (FS).json
@@ -22,8 +22,8 @@
   "market_exit_year": null,
   "market_exit_year_source": null,
   "energy_efficiency": {
-    "cooling": 6.02,
-    "heating": 3.01
+    "cooling": 6.05,
+    "heating": 3.03
   },
   "energy_efficiency_units": "COP",
   "energy_efficiency_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential Comfort Ctl..json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential Comfort Ctl..json
@@ -43,17 +43,17 @@
       "pages": [536, 548],
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269576957_A_knowledge_based_approach_for_selecting_energy-aware_and_comfort-driven_HVAC_temperature_set_points"}
       ]},
-  "installed_cost": 91,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.095,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` SFH home factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {

diff --git a/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential Occupancy Ctl..json b/ecm_definitions/Prospective Residential Occupancy Ctl..json
@@ -41,17 +41,17 @@
       "year": 2013,
       "pages": null,
       "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259933762_Reducing_Energy_Waste_for_Computers_by_Human-in-the-Loop_Control"}]},
-  "installed_cost": 70,
-  "cost_units": "2017$/occupant",
+  "installed_cost": 0.07,
+  "cost_units": "2017$/ft^2 floor",
   "installed_cost_source":{
-    "notes": "BTO Prioritization Tool analysis assuming 35% HVAC savings, 45% lighting energy savings, 80% PCs savings, and 1 year payback threshold",
+    "notes": "Cost analysis for BTO Sensors and Controls proggram; 1 year payback; converted to $/ft^2 floor via `occupant-centered sensing and controls` SFH home factor in Scout directory ./supporting_data/convert_data/ecm_cost_convert.json",
     "source_data": {
-      "title": "A Tool to Prioritize Energy Efficiency Investments",
-      "author": "Farese et al.",
-      "organization": "National Renewable Energy Laboratory",
-      "year": 2012,
+      "title": "Laying Down the Foundation: An R&D Roadmap for Energy Savings through Advancements in Smart Building Technologies",
+      "author": "Sofos et al.",
+      "organization": "U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO)",
+      "year": 2018,
       "pages": null,
-      "URL": "http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/54799.pdf"}},
+      "URL": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332152674_Laying_Down_the_Foundation_An_RD_Roadmap_for_Energy_Savings_through_Advancements_in_Smart_Building_Technologies"}},
   "product_lifetime": 10,
   "product_lifetime_units": "years",
   "product_lifetime_source": {