metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase #12973

maxenglander · 2023-04-25T17:44:07Z

Description

After using vtbackup_duration_by_phase for a few weeks in production, I can confidently say that they are pretty awkward to use:

vtbackup currently doesn't report that a phase as active. It only reports the phase duration once that phase completes. This means that there's no way to tell what phase vtbackup is currently in, unless you know enough about the internals of the program to infer the current state from other metrics and logs.
If vtbackup exits before completing a phase, it won't report the time it spent in that phase.
After completing the last phase (TakeNewBackup), vtbackup exits pretty much right away. This means that there might only be a few seconds between vtbackup reporting that phase for the first time and vtbackup exiting, which might not be enough time for the the metric collector (e.g. Prometheus) to collect that metric. This necessitates using something awkward like --keep-alive-timeout to get keep vtbackup alive long enough for the collector to do at least one scrape.

This PR remove that metric and adds vtbackup_phase, a binary valued gauge similar to K8s metrics like kube_pod_status_phase. Here's an example of what these metrics look like:

# HELP vtbackup_phase Active phase.
# TYPE vtbackup_phase gauge
vtbackup_phase{phase="CatchUpReplication"} 0
vtbackup_phase{phase="InitialBackup"} 0
vtbackup_phase{phase="RestoreLastBackup"} 0
vtbackup_phase{phase="TakeNewBackup"} 1

At any given moment, at most one phase would be active. In order to calculate how long a phase has been active, you could do something like this:

sum_over_time(vtbackup_phase{phase="TakeNewBackup"}) * <interval>

Where <interval> is the number of seconds between data points.

Since vtbackup_duration_by_phase was released in v17 and this PR did not make it into v17, we need to release this change with a breaking change notice. ~~Hoping that the fact that vtbackup_duration_by_phase isn't yet released means we can replace with vtbackup_phase without any kind of deprecation dance.~~

Related Issue(s)

Fixes #12972

Checklist

"Backport to:" labels have been added if this change should be back-ported
Tests were added or are not required
Did the new or modified tests pass consistently locally and on the CI
Documentation was added

Deployment Notes

vitess-bot · 2023-04-25T17:44:10Z

Review Checklist

Hello reviewers! 👋 Please follow this checklist when reviewing this Pull Request.

General

Ensure that the Pull Request has a descriptive title.
If this is a change that users need to know about, please apply the release notes (needs details) label so that merging is blocked unless the summary release notes document is included.
If a test is added or modified, there should be a documentation on top of the test to explain what the expected behavior is what the test does.

If a new flag is being introduced:

Is it really necessary to add this flag?
Flag names should be clear and intuitive (as far as possible)
Help text should be descriptive.
Flag names should use dashes (-) as word separators rather than underscores (_).

If a workflow is added or modified:

Each item in Jobs should be named in order to mark it as required.
If the workflow should be required, the maintainer team should be notified.

Bug fixes

There should be at least one unit or end-to-end test.
The Pull Request description should include a link to an issue that describes the bug.

Non-trivial changes

There should be some code comments as to why things are implemented the way they are.

New/Existing features

Should be documented, either by modifying the existing documentation or creating new documentation.
New features should have a link to a feature request issue or an RFC that documents the use cases, corner cases and test cases.

Backward compatibility

Protobuf changes should be wire-compatible.
Changes to _vt tables and RPCs need to be backward compatible.
vtctl command output order should be stable and awk-able.
RPC changes should be compatible with vitess-operator
If a flag is removed, then it should also be removed from VTop, if used there.

deepthi · 2023-04-26T03:29:38Z

Can you fix the title of the PR? It should have metrics and not go/cmd

maxenglander · 2023-04-26T11:16:25Z

@deepthi fixed!

deepthi

Changes look just fine. How easy or difficult is it to add a unit test for these stats?

maxenglander · 2023-05-23T18:37:53Z

@deepthi the main difficulty is that the vtbackup integration tests we have run vtbackup, wait for it to finish, and then make assertions about the results. I don't think we have any integration tests for it that make assertions about its state in the middle of running.

I think what I would try to do first is try to configure vtbackup to dump stats to a file and then check that afterwards. If that doesn't work..would probably need to do something ugly like run HTTP GET in a loop in a separate goroutine and make vtbackup wait a few seconds before exiting to give that routine a chance to scrape stats.

So..would say medium difficulty, but happy to do it if you think it's worth it!

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:37:50Z

go/cmd/vtbackup/plugin_opentsdb.go

@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+/*


In order to test for vtbackup-specific metrics in an E2E test, used opentsdb plugin and write stats to file for later verification.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:39:30Z

go/stats/export.go

@@ -183,7 +183,9 @@ func publish(name string, v expvar.Var) {
 // to be pushed to it. It's used to support push-based metrics backends, as expvar
 // by default only supports pull-based ones.
 type PushBackend interface {
-	// PushAll pushes all stats from expvar to the backend
+	// Close shuts down the backend and flushes any pending data.
+	Close() error


In order to reduce test flakiness, --emit_stats at a high frequency. In order to reduce data written to disk, use gzip compression, which requires calling Close() on the gzip writer to flush pending data. Integrate PushBackend.Close with servenv.OnTerm.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:40:11Z

go/stats/opentsdb/backend.go

@@ -0,0 +1,67 @@
+/*


Ended up refactoring this package a bit, mostly moving stuff to their own files. Will call out which stuff was moved vs. new.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:40:28Z

go/stats/opentsdb/backend.go

+type backend struct {
+	// closed is set to true when Close is called, preventing further use of
+	// the backend and flushing any pending data.
+	closed bool


This is new. Set to true after Close is called.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:41:21Z

go/stats/opentsdb/backend.go

+	// point tag will override the common tag.
+	commonTags map[string]string
+	// writer is used to send data points somewhere (file, http, ...).
+	writer writer


This is new. Factor HTTP-vs.-file specific stats-writing logic into writer implementations.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:41:29Z

go/stats/opentsdb/backend.go

+}
+
+// Close shuts down the backend and flushes any pending data
+func (b *backend) Close() error {


This is new

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:41:55Z

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 /*
-Copyright 2019 The Vitess Authors.
+Copyright 2023 The Vitess Authors.


TODO Revert

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:42:32Z

go/stats/opentsdb/backend.go

+	return b.writer.Write(collector.data)
+}
+
+func (b *backend) collector() *collector {


This is new and supports multiple collection strategies (PushAll vs. PushOne).

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:42:41Z

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

@@ -14,151 +14,34 @@ See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
 limitations under the License.
 */

-// Package opentsdb adds support for pushing stats to opentsdb.


Moved to doc.go

Nothing really to see in this file except the addition of collectOne. Everything else is just LOC being moved around within the file or to other files.

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:43:09Z

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

 )

-var openTsdbURI string


Flag-related stuff moved to flags.go

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:43:25Z

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

-}
-
-// dataPoint represents a single OpenTSDB data point.
-type dataPoint struct {


Moved to datapoint.go

maxenglander · 2023-05-29T03:43:44Z

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

-// sendDataPoints pushes a list of data points to openTSDB.
-// All other code in this file is just to support getting this function called
-// with all stats represented as data points.
-func sendDataPoints(data []dataPoint) error {


Factored out to http_writer.go.

github-actions · 2023-09-02T01:22:57Z

This PR is being marked as stale because it has been open for 30 days with no activity. To rectify, you may do any of the following:

Push additional commits to the associated branch.
Remove the stale label.
Add a comment indicating why it is not stale.

If no action is taken within 7 days, this PR will be closed.

github-actions · 2023-09-09T01:23:43Z

This PR was closed because it has been stale for 7 days with no activity.

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

This reverts commit bb37b272c0c5e799bf49decd0c0e414c392fca2d. Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

GuptaManan100

The rest is all good, but we can't remove DurationByPhase stat directly. We need to deprecate it in one release and then remove it. There can be customers that are relying on the metric now.

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

deepthi

I have just one nit on naming, rest LGTM.

deepthi · 2023-09-19T17:14:34Z

changelog/18.0/18.0.0/summary.md

+
+`Phase` reports a 1 (active) or a 0 (inactive) for each of the following phases:
+
+ * `CatchUpReplication`


nit: I would have made this Catchup instead of CatchUp.

Good nit, done!

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

GuptaManan100

Thankyou for making the changes!

* fix conflicts * merge origin v18.0.0 * Back to dev mode after v18.0.0 (vitessio#14475) * Release of v18.0.0 (vitessio#14406) * [release-18.0] VReplication: Handle multiple streams in UpdateVReplicationWorkflow RPC (vitessio#14447) (vitessio#14468) * [release-18.0] VDiff: "show all" should only report vdiffs for the specified keyspace and workflow (vitessio#14442) (vitessio#14466) * [release-18.0] TestStreamMigrateMainflow: fix panic in test (vitessio#14425) * [release-18.0] vtgate: Allow more errors for the warning check (vitessio#14421) (vitessio#14423) * [release-18.0] servenv: Remove double close() logic (vitessio#14457) (vitessio#14459) * [release-18.0] viper: register dynamic config with both disk and live (vitessio#14453) (vitessio#14455) * [release-18.0] vtgate/engine: Fix race condition in join logic (vitessio#14435) (vitessio#14441) * tx_throttler: remove topo watchers metric (vitessio#14444) * [release-18.0] VDiff tablet selection: pick non-serving tablets in Reshard workflows (vitessio#14413) (vitessio#14418) * Code freeze of release-18.0 (vitessio#14405) * [release-18.0] Online DDL: lint DDL strategy flags (vitessio#14373) (vitessio#14399) * [release-18.0] tuple: serialized form (vitessio#14392) (vitessio#14394) * [release-18.0] schemadiff: fix missing `DROP CONSTRAINT` in duplicate/redundant constraints scenario. (vitessio#14387) (vitessio#14391) * [release-18.0] Performance Fixes for Vitess 18 (vitessio#14383) (vitessio#14393) * [release-18.0] Vtctld SwitchReads: fix bug where writes were also being switched as part of switching reads when all traffic was switched using SwitchTraffic (vitessio#14360) (vitessio#14379) * [release-18.0] VDiff: wait for shard streams of one table diff to complete for before starting that of the next table (vitessio#14345) (vitessio#14382) * [release-18.0] [Docker] Fix VTadmin build (vitessio#14363) (vitessio#14378) * [release-18.0] Fix backup on s3 like storage (vitessio#14311) (vitessio#14362) * [release-18.0] use aggregation engine over distinct engine when overlapping order by (vitessio#14359) (vitessio#14361) * [release-18.0] Automatic approval of `vitess-bot` clean backports (vitessio#14352) (vitessio#14357) * [release-18.0] evalengine: Misc bugs (vitessio#14351) (vitessio#14354) * [release-18.0] OnlineDDL: reduce vrepl_stress workload in forks (vitessio#14302) (vitessio#14349) * [release-18.0] VReplication: Add --all-cells flag to create sub-commands (vitessio#14341) (vitessio#14343) * [release-18.0] Incremental backup: fix race condition in reading 'mysqlbinlog' output (vitessio#14330) (vitessio#14335) * [release-18.0] release notes: edit summary for consistency (vitessio#14319) (vitessio#14320) * [release-18.0] Bump @babel/traverse from 7.21.4 to 7.23.2 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#14304) (vitessio#14308) * [release-18.0] Rename Foreign Key enum values in VSchema and drop `FK_` prefix (vitessio#14274) (vitessio#14299) * [release-18.0] VReplication: error on vtctldclient commands w/o tablet types (vitessio#14294) (vitessio#14298) * [release-18.0] Make vtctldclient mount command more standard (vitessio#14281) (vitessio#14283) * [release-18.0] VReplication: Add traffic state to vtctldclient workflow status output (vitessio#14280) (vitessio#14282) * [release-18.0] fix: analyze statement parsing and planning (vitessio#14268) (vitessio#14275) * [release-18.0] Bypass cobra completion commands so they still function (vitessio#14217) (vitessio#14234) * [release-18.0] Bump golang.org/x/net from 0.14.0 to 0.17.0 (vitessio#14260) (vitessio#14264) * Add vtctldclient info to the 18.0 summary (vitessio#14259) * [release-18.0] Bump postcss from 8.4.21 to 8.4.31 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#14173) (vitessio#14258) * [release-18.0] Bump github.com/cyphar/filepath-securejoin from 0.2.3 to 0.2.4 (vitessio#14239) (vitessio#14253) * [release-18.0] Tablet throttler: fix race condition by removing goroutine call (vitessio#14179) (vitessio#14198) * [release-18.0] fix: insert with negative value (vitessio#14244) (vitessio#14247) * [release-18.0] Fix anonymous paths in cobra code-gen (vitessio#14185) (vitessio#14238) * [release-18.0] Throttler: set timeouts on gRPC communication and on topo communication (vitessio#14165) (vitessio#14167) * [release-18.0] Move all examples to vtctldclient (vitessio#14226) (vitessio#14241) * [release-18.0] VReplication: Add missing info to vtctldclient workflow SHOW output (vitessio#14225) (vitessio#14240) * [release-18.0] Upgrade the Golang version to `go1.21.3` (vitessio#14230) * [release-18.0] Optimize the GetWorkflows RPC (vitessio#14212) (vitessio#14233) * [Release 18.0]: Online DDL: timeouts for all gRPC calls (vitessio#14182) (vitessio#14189) * [release-18.0] Migrate Materialize command to vtctldclient (vitessio#14184) (vitessio#14214) * [Release 18.0] Backport of #17174 (vitessio#14210) * [release-18.0] Upgrade the Golang version to `go1.21.2` (vitessio#14195) * [release-18.0] Migrate CreateLookupVindex and ExternalizeVindex to vtctldclient (vitessio#14086) (vitessio#14183) * Back to dev mode after `v18.0.0-rc1` release (vitessio#14169) * Release of v18.0.0-rc1 (vitessio#14136) * [release-18.0] docker: add dedicated vtorc container (vitessio#14126) (vitessio#14148) * [release-18.0] gen4: Support explicit column aliases on derived tables (vitessio#14129) (vitessio#14156) * Code freeze of release-18.0 (vitessio#14131) * VTGate FK stress tests suite: improvements (vitessio#14098) * DDL execution to commit open transaction (vitessio#14110) * Summary changes for foreign keys (vitessio#14112) * Move subqueries to use the operator model (vitessio#13750) * servenv: Allow for explicit bind address (vitessio#13188) * vtorc: add detected_problems counter (vitessio#13967) * fix bad copy-paste in zkctld docgen (vitessio#14123) * VDiff: Cleanup the controller for a VDiff before deleting it (vitessio#14107) * Remove deprecated flags before `v18.0.0` (vitessio#14071) * Remove FOSSA Test from CI until we can do it in a secure way (vitessio#14119) * go/cmd/vtbackup: wait for plugins to finish initializing (vitessio#14113) * bugfix: change column name and type to json (vitessio#14093) * `vtctld`/`vtorc`: improve reparenting stats (vitessio#13723) * E2E Fuzzing testing for foreign keys (vitessio#13980) * Backup/restore: provision and restore a tablet with point-in-time recovery flags (vitessio#13964) * anonymize homedirs in generated docs (vitessio#14101) * VDiff: properly split cell values in record when using TabletPicker (vitessio#14099) * miscellaneous cobras (vitessio#14069) * Reduce network pressure on multi row insert (vitessio#14064) * [cli] cobra zookeeper (vitessio#14094) * switch casing in onlineddl subcommand help text (vitessio#14091) * Fix Fk verification and update queries to accommodate for bindVariables being NULL (vitessio#14061) * actually test vtcombo (vitessio#14095) * VDiff: Migrate client command to vtctldclient (vitessio#13976) * ci: pool-related test flakyness (vitessio#14076) * Improve the rewriter to simplify more queries (vitessio#14059) * update docgen to embed commit ID in autogenerated doc frontmatter (vitessio#14056) * [CLI] cobra lots of things (vitessio#14007) * Add VSchema DDL support for dropping sequence and auto increment (vitessio#13882) * json: Fix quoting JSON keys (vitessio#14066) * Flakes: Address TestMigrate Failures (vitessio#12866) * [cli] migrate mysqlctl and mysqlctld to cobra (vitessio#13946) * evalengine: Mark UUID() function as non-constant (vitessio#14051) * Fix cascading Delete failure while using Prepared statements (vitessio#14048) * remove query_analyzer binary and release (vitessio#14055) * go/vt/mysqlctl: instrument s3 upload time (vitessio#12500) * Add session flag for stream execute grpc api (vitessio#14046) * Endtoend: stress tests for VTGate FOREIGN KEY support (vitessio#13799) * metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase (vitessio#12973) * TableGC: support DROP VIEW (vitessio#14020) * Support arbitrary ZooKeeper config lines (vitessio#13829) * Bump protobufjs from 7.2.3 to 7.2.5 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#13833) * Bump tough-cookie and @cypress/request in /vitess-mixin/e2e (vitessio#13768) * Remove excessive logging in transactions (vitessio#14021) * Fix bug in `fileNameFromPosition` test helper (vitessio#13778) * MoveTables Cancel: drop denied tables on target when dropping source/target tables (vitessio#14008) * java: update to latest dependencies for grpc and protobuf (vitessio#13996) * OnlineDDL: cleanup cancelled migration artifacts; support `--retain-artifacts=<duration>` DDL strategy flag (vitessio#14029) * moved timeout test to different package (vitessio#14028) * fix: cost to include subshard opcode (vitessio#14023) * VReplication VPlayer: set foreign_key_checks on initialization (vitessio#14013) * go/cmd/vtbackup: report replication status metrics during catch-up phase (vitessio#13995) * Fix the `SELECT` query we run on the child table to verify that update is allowed on a RESTRICT constraint (vitessio#13991) * fix data race in join engine primitive olap streaming mode execution (vitessio#14012) * test: added test to check binlogs to contain the cascade events (vitessio#13970) * Fix `TestLeftJoinUsingUnsharded` and remove instability when running E2E locally (vitessio#13973) * Enable failures in `tools/e2e_test_race.sh` and fix races (vitessio#13654) * Improve release process documentation (vitessio#14000) * Make `Static Code Checks Etc` fail if the `./changelog` folder is out-of-date (vitessio#14003) * Fix foreign key plan tests expectation (vitessio#13997) * Flakes: Add recently added 'select rows_copied' query to ignore list (vitessio#13993) * Foreign key cascade: retain "for update" lock on select query plans (vitessio#13985) * Fix `NOT IN` expression used in the SET NULL for a child table on an update (vitessio#13988) * consolidate docs (vitessio#13959) * VDiff: correct handling of default source and target cells (vitessio#13969) * [cobra] vtgate and vttablet (vitessio#13943) * handle large number of predicates without timing out (vitessio#13979) * Fix missing deprecated flags in `vttablet` and `vtgate` (vitessio#13975) * wrangler,workflow/workflow: materialize from intersecting source shards based on primary vindexes (vitessio#13782) * Cache v3 (vitessio#13939) * Implement Reshard in vtctldclient (vitessio#13792) * Disallow Insert with Duplicate key update and Replace Into queries on foreign key column, set locks on fk queries (vitessio#13953) * End to end testing suite for foreign keys (vitessio#13870) * copy over existing vreplication rows copied to local counter if resuming from another tablet (vitessio#13949) * vtctldclient OnlineDDL: support `throttle`, `unthrottle` (vitessio#13916) * Change internal vindex type recommendation for integrals to xxhash (vitessio#13956) * VTOrc converts a tablet to DRAINED type if it detects errant GTIDs on it (vitessio#13873) * Fix `ApplySchema --batch-size` with ` --allow-zero-in-date` (vitessio#13951) * Tablet throttler: empty list of probes on non-leader (vitessio#13926) * VReplication: Handle SQL NULL and JSON 'null' correctly for JSON columns (vitessio#13944) * [vtctld] more cobra binaries (vitessio#13930) * Merge branch 'planetscale-fk-verify-update-planning' * [main] Upgrade the Golang version to `go1.21.1` (vitessio#13933) * update fk error messages * cascade with new value should work * small refactor - removed unused code * return verify error based on type * store the verification type * update plan output test * small refactor * feat: add code to verify valdity of ON UPDATE RESTRICT foreign keys wherever required * Rewrite `USING` to `ON` condition for joins (vitessio#13931) * test: fix tests to reflect the recent changes * feat: add code to verify update with cascade run with foreign key checks 0 and validate all the foreign keys on vtgate * add where condition to fk verify query * changed parent verification query and accordingly change the engine primitive for foreign key constraint verification * foreign key verify operator and logical * refactor: add comment explaining map in input * add support for foreign key constraint verify on update * refactor: move DML logic to sql_builder.go (vitessio#13920) * OnlineDDL: fix nil 'completed_timestamp' for cancelled migrations (vitessio#13928) * Silence 'CheckThrottler' gRPC calls (vitessio#13925) * migrate vtorc to use cobra commands (vitessio#13917) * MoveTables: allow copying all tables in a single atomic copy phase cycle (vitessio#13137) * proto: Faster clone (vitessio#13914) * Properly support ignore_nulls in CreateLookupVindex (vitessio#13913) * [staticcheck] Last few staticchecks! (vitessio#13909) * icuregex: Update to ICU 73 (vitessio#13912) * gen4: Fast aggregations (vitessio#13904) * Use correct syntax in test (vitessio#13907) * Misc Local Install improvements. (vitessio#13446) * Consolidate helper functions for working with proto3 time messages (vitessio#13905) * Add vtsql flags to vtadmin (vitessio#13674) * MoveTables: add flag to specify that routing rules should not be created when a movetables workflow is created (vitessio#13895) * [staticcheck] miscellaneous tidying (vitessio#13892) * [misc] tidy imports (vitessio#13885) * Remove duplicate ACL check in tabletserver handleHTTPConsolidations (vitessio#13876) * vtexplain: Fix passing through context for cleanup (vitessio#13900) * [staticcheck] Cleanup deprecations (vitessio#13898) * inputs method to return additional information about the input primitive (vitessio#13883) * vttablet: do not notify `vtgate` about internal tables (vitessio#13897) * Skip launchable if the Pull Request is marked as a Draft (vitessio#13886) * vtctldclient: support OnlineDDL `complete`, `launch` commands (vitessio#13896) * collations: implement collation dumping as a docker image (vitessio#13879) * sqlparser: Tablespace option is case sensitive (vitessio#13884) * Clean up deprecated slice header usage and unused code (vitessio#13880) * [misc] Delete more unused functions, tidy up dupe imports (vitessio#13878) * collations: Refactor to separate basic collation information from data (vitessio#13868) * [wrangler] cleanup unused functions (vitessio#13867) * Fix setup order to avoid races (vitessio#13871) * Add Foreign key verify constraint engine primitive (vitessio#13848) * Foreign key cascade planning for DELETE and UPDATE queries (vitessio#13823) * Fix merge conflict with new tests (vitessio#13869) * vtctldclient OnlineDDL CANCEL (vitessio#13860) * Add leak checking for vtgate tests (vitessio#13835) * Fix for "text type with an unknown/unsupported collation cannot be hashed" error (vitessio#13852) * Go 1.21 cleanups (vitessio#13862) * VTGate Buffering: Use a more accurate heuristic for determining if we're doing a reshard (vitessio#13856) * docker/bootstrap: remove --no-cache flag (vitessio#13785) * Flakes: Improve reliability of vreplication_copy_parallel test (vitessio#13857) * [main] Upgrade the Golang version to `go1.21.0` (vitessio#13853) * Fix regular expression issue in Golang Upgrade and remove `release-14.0` from target branch (vitessio#13846) * Migrates most workflows to 4 and 16 cores Large GitHub-Hosted-Runners (vitessio#13845) * [onlineddl] retry and cleanup (vitessio#13830) * Bump word-wrap from 1.2.3 to 1.2.4 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#13569) * Bump tough-cookie from 4.1.2 to 4.1.3 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#13767) * Skip VTAdmin build in Docker tests (vitessio#13836) * Flakes: Synchronize access to logErrStacks in vterrors (vitessio#13827) * Flakes: VReplication unit tests: reduce goroutine leakage (vitessio#13824) * Remove explicit usage of etcd v2 (api and storage) (vitessio#13791) * Add OnlineDDL show support (vitessio#13738) * VReplication: Improve MoveTables Create Error Handling (vitessio#13737) * Add 2 new metrics with tablet type labels (vitessio#13521) * Add 2 more durability policies that allow RDONLY tablets to send semi-sync ACKs (vitessio#13698) * CI: Misc test improvements to limit failures with various runners (vitessio#13825) * Flakes: empty vtdataroot before starting a new vreplication e2e test (vitessio#13803) * Fix `BackupShard` to get its options from its own flags (vitessio#13813) * Flakes: skip flaky check that ETA for a VReplication VDiff2 Progress command is in the future. (vitessio#13804) * Copy release notes for v17.0.2 and v16.0.4 (vitessio#13811) * More union merging (vitessio#13743) * Add Foreign key Cascade engine primitive (vitessio#13802) * Add support for tuple as value type (vitessio#13800) * Foreign Keys: `UPDATE` planning (vitessio#13762) * Improving random query generation for endtoend testing (vitessio#13460) * Flakes: Delete VTDATAROOT files in reparent test teardown within CI (vitessio#13793) * vtgate: fix race condition iterating tables and views from schema tracker (vitessio#13673) * Fixing `backup_pitr` flaky tests via wait-for loop on topo reads (vitessio#13781) * Do not drain tablet in incremental backup (vitessio#13773) * Address vttablet memory usage with backups to Azure Blob Service (vitessio#13770) * Run auto golang upgrade only on vitessio/vitess (vitessio#13766) * Flakes: remove non-determinism from vtctldclient MoveTables unit test (vitessio#13765) * Minor --initialize-target-sequences followups (vitessio#13758) * CI: fix onlineddl_scheduler flakiness (vitessio#13754) * VReplication: Initialize Sequence Tables Used By Tables Being Moved (vitessio#13656) * Bump docker images to `bullseye` (vitessio#13664) * Use NodeJS v18 in VTAdmin Dockerfile (vitessio#13751) * Refactor Expression and Statement Simplifier (vitessio#13636) * Foreign Keys: `DELETE` planning (vitessio#13746) * build: Allow passing in custom -ldflags (vitessio#13748) * Point in time recovery: fix cross-tablet GTID evaluation (vitessio#13555) * Cache info schema table info (vitessio#13724) * BackupShard: support incremental backup (vitessio#13522) * OnlineDDL: support @@migration_context in vtgate session. Use if non-empty (vitessio#13675) * schemadiff: add time measure test for massive schema load and diff (vitessio#13697) * Vtgate: pass 'SHOW VITESS_MIGRATIONS' to tablet's query executor (vitessio#13726) * Move UNION planning to the operators (vitessio#13450) * Fix vtcombo DBDDL plugin race condition (vitessio#13117) * Foreign Keys: `INSERT` planning (vitessio#13676) * go/vt/vitessdriver: implement driver.{Connector,DriverContext} (vitessio#13704) * Backup: safe compressor/decompressor closure (vitessio#13668) * sqlparser: Track if original default value is a literal (vitessio#13730) * Solve RevertMigration.Comment read/write concurrency issue (vitessio#13700) * `ApplySchema`: support `--batch-size` flag in 'direct' strategy (vitessio#13693) * Fix closed channel `panic` in Online DDL cutover (vitessio#13729) * mysql: Refactor dependencies (vitessio#13688) * vtgate tablet gateway buffering: don't shutdown if not initialized (vitessio#13695) * [OnlineDDL] add label so break works as intended (vitessio#13691) * fastparse: Fix bug in overflow detection (vitessio#13702) * Refactor code to remove `evalengine` as a dependency of `VTOrc` (vitessio#13642) * `txthrottler`: remove `txThrottlerConfig` struct, rely on `tabletenv` (vitessio#13624) * [vtctldclient] flags need to be defined to be deprecated (vitessio#13681) * Add dry-run/monitoring-only mode for TxThrottler (vitessio#13604) * Enhancing VTGate buffering for MoveTables and Shard by Shard Migration (vitessio#13507) * Improvements to PRS (vitessio#13623) * Errant GTID Metrics Refactor (vitessio#13670) * Improve logging and renaming PrimaryTermStartTimestamp in vttablets (vitessio#13625) * Fix a couple of logs in VTOrc (vitessio#13667) * Throttler: exempt apps via `UpdateThrottlerConfig --throttle-app-exempt` (vitessio#13666) * Tablet throttler: inter-checks via gRPC (vitessio#13514) * Reroute 'ALTER VITESS_MIGRATION ... THROTTLE ...' through topo (vitessio#13511) * Build foreign key definition in schema tracker (vitessio#13657) * evalengine: Fix JSON weight string computation (vitessio#13669) * Throttler: verify deprecated flags are still allowed (vitessio#13615) * Backup & Restore: vtctldclient to support PITR flags (vitessio#13513) * `UpdateThrottlerConfig --unthrottle-app ...` (vitessio#13494) * tx throttler: healthcheck all cells if `--tx-throttler-healthcheck-cells` is undefined (vitessio#12477) * evalengine: Improve weight string support (vitessio#13658) * mysqlctl: Reduce logging for running commands (vitessio#13659) * Add v15.0.4, v16.0.3, and v17.0.1 changelogs (vitessio#13661) * [viper WatchConfig] platform-specific write to ensure callback fires exactly once (vitessio#13627) * go/mysql: switch to new API for x/exp/slices.SortFunc (vitessio#13644) * Per workload TxThrottler metrics (vitessio#13526) * VReplication: Make Source Tablet Selection More Robust (vitessio#13582) * Update known issues in `v16.x` and `v17.0.0` (vitessio#13618) * Augment VTOrc to also store the shard records and use it to better judge Primary recoveries (vitessio#13587) * icuregex: Lazy load ICU data into memory (vitessio#13640) * Ensure to call `servenv.Init` when needed (vitessio#13638) * GetSchema: limit concurrent operations (vitessio#13617) * check keyspace snapshot time if none specified for backup restores (vitessio#13557) * vtgate buffering logic: remove the deprecated healthcheck based implementation (vitessio#13584) * Fix type comparisons for Nullsafe* functions (vitessio#13605) * Reintroduce `TestReadOutdatedInstanceKeys` with debugging information (vitessio#13562) * mysqlctl: Remove noisy log line (vitessio#13599) * Vtctldclient MoveTables (vitessio#13015) * txthrottler: add metrics for topoWatcher and healthCheckStreamer (vitessio#13153) * Reduce usages of old horizon planning fallback (vitessio#13595) * Throttler: reintroduce deprecated flags so that deprecation actually works (vitessio#13597) * Incremental backup & recovery: restore-to-timestamp (vitessio#13270) * Fix potential panics due to "Fail in goroutine after test completed" (vitessio#13596) * ignore all error for views in engine reload (vitessio#13590) * vtgate table schema tracking to use GetSchema rpc (vitessio#13544) * MoveTables sequence e2e tests: change terminology to use basic vs simple everywhere for partial movetables workflows (vitessio#13435) * Skip VTAdmin build in more places (vitessio#13588) * Fix show character set (vitessio#13565) * Remove unused chromedriver (vitessio#13573) * fix TestQueryTimeoutWithTables flaky test (vitessio#13579) * CI: Fix make build related issues (vitessio#13583) * docker/mini: remove refs to orc configs (vitessio#13495) * stats: use *time.Ticker instead of time.After() (vitessio#13492) * VReplication: Ensure ROW events are sent within a transaction (vitessio#13547) * Add a `keyspace` configuration in the `vschema` for foreign key mode (vitessio#13553) * vreplication: Move to use collations package (vitessio#13566) * Flaky tests: Fix race in memory topo (vitessio#13559) * Fix flaky vtgate test TestInconsistentStateDetectedBuffering (vitessio#13560) * Flaky tests: Fix wrangler tests (vitessio#13568) * Optimize `make build` in `test.go` and in CI (vitessio#13567) * Unset the PREFIX environment variable when building VTAdmin (vitessio#13554) * vtctldclient: Add missing new backup option (vitessio#13543) * Skip flaky test `TestReadOutdatedInstanceKeys` (vitessio#13561) * Fix a number of encoding issues when evaluating expressions with the evalengine (vitessio#13509) * Deflake `TestPlannedReparentShardPromoteReplicaFail` (vitessio#13548) * [vipersync] deflake TestWatchConfig (vitessio#13545) * vtgate v3 planner removal (vitessio#13458) * Fix flakiness in VTOrc tests (vitessio#13489) * Replace deprecated `github.com/golang/mock` with `go.uber.org/mock` (vitessio#13512) * Fix dependencies in docker build script (vitessio#13520) * fix docgen for subcommands (vitessio#13518) * Merge pull request vitessio#13515 from planetscale/partial-movetables-traffic-status * Correct unit test * docker/k8s: add bookworm builds (vitessio#13436) * ignore ongoing backfill vindex from routing selection (vitessio#13505) * Adjust function names for improved clarity * More fixes related to partial traffic handling * Ignore unrelated shards in partial movetables workflow status * Better handling of vreplication setState() failure (vitessio#13488) * flags: Remove hardcoded runner paths (vitessio#13482) * viperutil: Remove potential cross site reflecting issue (vitessio#13483) * skip flaky test (vitessio#13501) * feat: remove --disable_active_reparents flag in vttablet-up.sh (vitessio#13504) * fix: error.as method usage to send pointer to the reference type expected. (vitessio#13496) * Fix `TestGatewayBufferingWhileReparenting` flakiness (vitessio#13469) * ApplySchema: deprecate '--allow_long_unavailability' flag (vitessio#10717) * Incremental backup: accept GTID position without 'MySQL56/' flavor prefix (vitessio#13474) * Deprecating and removing tablet throttler CLI flags and tests (vitessio#13246) * Online DDL: improved row estimation via ANALYE TABLE with --analyze-table strategy flag (vitessio#13352) * Tablet throttler: throttled app configuration via `vtctl UpdateThrottlerConfig` (vitessio#13351) * added no-commit-collection option to launchable record build command (vitessio#13490) * Fix remote VersionString API (vitessio#13484) * Fix logging by omitting the host and port in `SetReadOnly` (vitessio#13470) * `vtctl OnlineDDL`: complete command set (vitessio#12963) * Random selection of keyspace based on available tablet (vitessio#13359) * Improve and Fix Distinct Aggregation planner (vitessio#13466) * Fix ubi8.arm64.mysql80 build package mirrorserver error (vitessio#13431) * backup: Allow for upgrade safe backups (vitessio#13449) * Merge pull request vitessio#13468 from timvaillancourt/examples-compose-fix-consul-tag * Update a number of dependencies (vitessio#13031) * Enable Tcp keep alive and provide keep alive period setting (vitessio#13434) * rm mistaken commit * Update docker-compose.beginners.yml too * compose: fix `consul:latest` error * Add support for kill statement (vitessio#13371) * feat: remove excessive logging (vitessio#13459) * schema.Reload(): ignore column reading errors for views only, error for tables (vitessio#13442) * [CI] deflake viper sync tests (vitessio#13185) * mysql: introduce icuregex package (vitessio#13391) * Fix `Fakemysqldaemon` to store the host and port after `SetReplicationSource` call (vitessio#13439) * Examples: only terminate vtadmin if it was started (vitessio#13433) * [main] Upgrade-Downgrade Fix: Schema-initialization stuck on semi-sync ACKs while upgrading (vitessio#13411) (vitessio#13440) * Move more horizon planning to the operators (vitessio#13412) * Refactor backup_pitr into two distinct CI tests: builtin vs Xtrabackup (vitessio#13395) * Improve VTOrc logging statements, now that we have alias as a field (vitessio#13428) * vtorc: Cleanup more unused code (vitessio#13354) * VReplication Workflows: make sequence tables follow routing rules (vitessio#13238) * Ignore error while reading table data in Schema.Engine reload (vitessio#13421) * Improve time taken to run the examples by optimizing `vtadmin` build (vitessio#13262) * vtctl,vindexes: logs warnings and export stat for unknown vindex params (vitessio#13322) * Add end-of-life documentation + re-organize internal documentation (vitessio#13401) * Adding random query generation for endtoend testing of the Gen4 planner (vitessio#13260) * Aggregation engine refactor (vitessio#13378) * Deflake `TestQueryTimeoutWithDual` test (vitessio#13405) * Optimize release notes generation to use GitHub Milestones (vitessio#13398) * feat: don't run any reparent commands if the host is empty (vitessio#13396) * `vttestserver`: persist vschema changes in `--persistent_mode` (vitessio#13065) * Tablet throttler: only start watching SrvKeyspace once it's confirmed to exist (vitessio#13384) * Support views in BaseShowTablesWithSizes for MySQL 8.0 (vitessio#13394) * Fix incorrect output in release scripts (vitessio#13385) * Adds support for ANY_VALUE (vitessio#13342) * BaseShowTablesWithSizes: optimize MySQL 8.0 query (vitessio#13375) * Forward port of release notes changes from v17.0.0 GA (vitessio#13370) * feat: add timestamp to vtorc debug page (vitessio#13379) * Prevent resetting replication every time we set replication source (vitessio#13377) * Local example 101: idempotent on existing clusters (vitessio#13373) * governance: clean up language, link steering doc from first occurrence instead of from a random occurrence (vitessio#13337) * Add group_concat aggregation support (vitessio#13331) * Improve VTOrc failure detection to be able to better handle dead primary failures (vitessio#13190) * Improve lock action string (vitessio#13355) * Add RestorePosition and RestoredBackupTime as metrics to vttablet (vitessio#13339) * update link for reparenting guide (vitessio#13350) * Handle inconsistent state error in query buffering (vitessio#13333) * mysqlctl: Move more to use built in MySQL client (vitessio#13338) * VTOrc: Update the primary key for all the tables from `hostname, port` to `alias` (vitessio#13243) * docker/k8s: Cleanup done TODO (vitessio#13347) * bug: don't always wrap aggregation in coalesce (vitessio#13348) * Vttablet schema tracking: Fix _vt.schema_version corruption (vitessio#13045) * bugfixes: collection of fixes to bugs found while fuzzing (vitessio#13332) * Remove CI endtoend test for VReplication copy throttling (vitessio#13343) * Use sqlparser for all dynamic query building in VDiff2 (vitessio#13319) * txthrottler: verify config at vttablet startup, consolidate funcs (vitessio#13115) * mysqlctl: Use DBA connection for schema operations (vitessio#13178) * Bug fix: SQL queries erroring with message `unknown aggregation random` (vitessio#13330) * Support complex aggregation in Gen4's Operators (vitessio#13326) * [VTAdmin] Upgrade to use node 18.16.0 (vitessio#13288) * Cleanup unused Dockerfile entries (vitessio#13327) * Add metric for showing the errant GTIDs in VTOrc (vitessio#13281) * vtgate planner: HAVING in the new operator horizon planner (vitessio#13289) * vtgr: Remove deprecated vtgr (vitessio#13308) * mysqlctl: Correctly encode database and table names (vitessio#13312) * sqlparser: Add support for TIMESTAMPADD (vitessio#13314) * Refactor and add a comment to schema initialisation code (vitessio#13309) * Release notes for 17.0.0-rc2 (vitessio#13306) * remove os.Exit (vitessio#13310) * k8stopo: Remove the deprecated Kubernetes topo (vitessio#13303) * vindexes: return unknown params (vitessio#12951) * Operator planner refactor (vitessio#13294) * Deprecate VTGR (vitessio#13301) * k8stopo: Include deprecation warning (vitessio#13299) * [main] Upgrade the Golang version to `go1.20.5` (vitessio#13256) * evalengine: implement date/time math (vitessio#13274) * increase size of reparent_journal columns (vitessio#13287) * VReplication: Fix VDiff2 DeleteByUUID Query (vitessio#13255) * Miscellaneous code modifications based on observations made while doing a code walkthrough (vitessio#12873) * Set the number of threads for release notes generation with a flag (vitessio#13273) * Fix and Make aggregation planner handle aggregation functions better (vitessio#13228) * fix: ShardedRouting clone to clone slice of reference correctly (vitessio#13265) * Remove viper warnings from local examples (vitessio#13234) * Add flag to VTOrc to enable/disable its ability to run ERS (vitessio#13259) * Remove `out.txt` and add `release-17.0` to go upgrade automation (vitessio#13261) * build(deps-dev): bump vite from 4.2.1 to 4.2.3 in /web/vtadmin (vitessio#13240) * Copy v17.0.0-rc changelog to main (vitessio#13248) * fix: GetField to use existing session for query (vitessio#13219) * Fix flakiness in `TestDeadPrimaryRecoversImmediately` (vitessio#13232) * Augmenting the `GetSchema` RPC to also work for `Table` and `All` type of input (vitessio#13197) * Incremental backup and point in time recovery for XtraBackup (vitessio#13156) * VReplication: More intelligently manage vschema table entries on unsharded targets (vitessio#13220) * Use $hostname in vtadmin script as other scripts do (vitessio#13231) * Tablet throttler: throttler-config-via-topo defaults 'true', deprecation message for old flags (vitessio#13130) * [ci] add generator for templated flag testdata (vitessio#13150) * schemadiff: validating case-sensitive view names (vitessio#13208) * Add security audit report (vitessio#13221) * gentler warning message on config-not-found (vitessio#13215) * Bump the vitess version on main (vitessio#13212) * Handle DISTINCT with the new operators (vitessio#13201) * Gen4: move insert planner to gen4 (vitessio#12934)

* metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase (vitessio#12973) Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com> Signed-off-by: Andrew Mason <andrew@planetscale.com> * [CLI] cobra lots of things (vitessio#14007) Signed-off-by: Andrew Mason <andrew@planetscale.com> * go/cmd/vtbackup: wait for plugins to finish initializing (vitessio#14113) Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com> --------- Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com> Signed-off-by: Andrew Mason <andrew@planetscale.com> Co-authored-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

vitess-bot bot added NeedsDescriptionUpdate The description is not clear or comprehensive enough, and needs work NeedsWebsiteDocsUpdate What it says labels Apr 25, 2023

github-actions bot added this to the v17.0.0 milestone Apr 25, 2023

maxenglander mentioned this pull request Apr 25, 2023

content/en/docs/18.0: rework vtbackup DurationByPhase into binary valued Phase vitessio/website#1452

Merged

maxenglander marked this pull request as ready for review April 25, 2023 21:53

maxenglander requested review from ajm188 and deepthi as code owners April 25, 2023 21:53

maxenglander changed the title ~~go/cmd: vtbackup_duration_by_phase => vtbackup_phase~~ metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase Apr 26, 2023

maxenglander added Type: Enhancement Logical improvement (somewhere between a bug and feature) Component: Backup and Restore labels May 8, 2023

deepthi removed NeedsDescriptionUpdate The description is not clear or comprehensive enough, and needs work NeedsWebsiteDocsUpdate What it says labels May 23, 2023

deepthi reviewed May 23, 2023

View reviewed changes

maxenglander force-pushed the maxeng-rework-vtbackup-phase-stats branch from 106dec0 to f49fcb2 Compare May 29, 2023 03:32

maxenglander commented May 29, 2023

View reviewed changes

go/stats/opentsdb/collector.go

)

var openTsdbURI string

Copy link

Collaborator Author

maxenglander May 29, 2023

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Flag-related stuff moved to flags.go

maxenglander commented May 29, 2023

View reviewed changes

shlomi-noach mentioned this pull request Aug 2, 2023

Revert "content/en/docs/18.0: rework vtbackup DurationByPhase into binary valued Phase" vitessio/website#1552

Merged

github-actions bot added the Stale Marks PRs as stale after a period of inactivity, which are then closed after a grace period. label Sep 2, 2023

github-actions bot closed this Sep 9, 2023

maxenglander removed the Stale Marks PRs as stale after a period of inactivity, which are then closed after a grace period. label Sep 13, 2023

maxenglander reopened this Sep 13, 2023

maxenglander added 4 commits September 14, 2023 16:24

try fix upgrade/downgrade test

19e1e32

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

Revert "update release notes"

ad61e10

This reverts commit bb37b272c0c5e799bf49decd0c0e414c392fca2d. Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

update v18 release notes

ff22dc3

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

Merge branch 'main' into maxeng-rework-vtbackup-phase-stats

93c4852

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

maxenglander force-pushed the maxeng-rework-vtbackup-phase-stats branch from edc6569 to 93c4852 Compare September 14, 2023 15:37

maxenglander mentioned this pull request Sep 15, 2023

go/cmd/vtbackup: report replication status metrics during catch-up phase #13995

Merged

4 tasks

deepthi requested review from GuptaManan100, mattlord and shlomi-noach and removed request for ajm188 September 18, 2023 21:06

GuptaManan100 reviewed Sep 19, 2023

View reviewed changes

maxenglander added 2 commits September 19, 2023 12:56

merge <- main

706716f

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

deprecate not deletE

fb5fe50

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

maxenglander mentioned this pull request Sep 19, 2023

content/en/docs/18.0: vtbackup metrics deprecate DurationByPhase add Phase vitessio/website#1589

Merged

maxenglander requested a review from GuptaManan100 September 19, 2023 12:32

deepthi approved these changes Sep 19, 2023

View reviewed changes

CatchUpReplication -> CatchupReplication

d8e54a3

Signed-off-by: Max Englander <max@planetscale.com>

maxenglander requested a review from deepthi September 19, 2023 23:35

GuptaManan100 approved these changes Sep 20, 2023

View reviewed changes

GuptaManan100 merged commit ebbd418 into vitessio:main Sep 20, 2023
114 checks passed

GuptaManan100 deleted the maxeng-rework-vtbackup-phase-stats branch September 20, 2023 09:58

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase #12973

metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase #12973

maxenglander commented Apr 25, 2023 •

edited

Loading

vitess-bot bot commented Apr 25, 2023

deepthi commented Apr 26, 2023

maxenglander commented Apr 26, 2023

deepthi left a comment

maxenglander commented May 23, 2023 •

edited

Loading

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023 •

edited

Loading

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

maxenglander May 29, 2023

github-actions bot commented Sep 2, 2023

github-actions bot commented Sep 9, 2023

GuptaManan100 left a comment

deepthi left a comment

deepthi Sep 19, 2023

maxenglander Sep 19, 2023

GuptaManan100 left a comment


		`Phase` reports a 1 (active) or a 0 (inactive) for each of the following phases:

		* `CatchUpReplication`

metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase #12973

metrics: change vtbackup_duration_by_phase to binary-valued vtbackup_phase #12973

Conversation

maxenglander commented Apr 25, 2023 • edited Loading

Description

Related Issue(s)

Checklist

Deployment Notes

vitess-bot bot commented Apr 25, 2023

Review Checklist

General

If a new flag is being introduced:

If a workflow is added or modified:

Bug fixes

Non-trivial changes

New/Existing features

Backward compatibility

deepthi commented Apr 26, 2023

maxenglander commented Apr 26, 2023

deepthi left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

maxenglander commented May 23, 2023 • edited Loading

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

maxenglander May 29, 2023 • edited Loading

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

github-actions bot commented Sep 2, 2023

github-actions bot commented Sep 9, 2023

GuptaManan100 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

deepthi left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

GuptaManan100 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

maxenglander commented Apr 25, 2023 •

edited

Loading

maxenglander commented May 23, 2023 •

edited

Loading

maxenglander May 29, 2023 •

edited

Loading