Question/Problem: Using Foundry in Doctrine Fixtures with service injection

[skuhnow]

I want to use UserPasswordEncoderInterface in my UserFactory to set the encoded password after instantiate. When I try to create my Factory ($userAdmin = UserFactory::new();), I get:

Model Factories with dependencies (Model Factory services) cannot be used without the foundry bundle.

but Flex registered the Bundle: Zenstruck\Foundry\ZenstruckFoundryBundle::class => ['dev' => true, 'test' => true],

It looks like Foundry has booted, but the injected $factories in \Zenstruck\Foundry\ModelFactoryManager are empty.

[kbond]

Hello, I think perhaps your factories are not being autowired/autoconfigured. Can you find the service with bin/console debug:container?

[kbond]

Closing as stale. If you're still having issues, let me know and I'll reopen.

[marcinmdev]

I've encountered this issue:

• had GlobalStory as service with param injected in constructor by DI

#services_test.yaml
services:   
    App\Story\GlobalStory:
        arguments:
            $env: 'test'

• only used in dev/test env
• ran bin/console doctrine:fixtures:load --append -n => Stories with dependencies (Story services) cannot be used without the foundry bundle.

Fix:
set autoconfigure and autowire true to said service:

#services_test.yaml
services:   
    App\Story\GlobalStory:
        autowire: true
        autoconfigure: true
        arguments:
            $env: 'test'

[kbond]

https://symfony.com/bundles/ZenstruckFoundryBundle/current/index.html#stories-as-services describes that the tag is needed (below the example). Could probably make that pop a bit more with it as a note.

[Perf]

@kbond
I had fresh symfony installation (6.4.1) with zenstruck/foundry v1.36.0.
When trying to create fixtures like:

class AppFixtures extends Fixture
{
    public function load(ObjectManager $manager): void
    {
        UserFactory::createMany(25);
    }
}

Or in tests, like:

describe('User Resource', function () {
    it('Fetches Users collection', function () {
        UserFactory::createMany(50);

        $res = $this->getJson('users');

        dd($res->getContent(false));
    });
});

I always getting an error:
Model Factories with dependencies (Model Factory services) cannot be used without the foundry bundle.
However, it's installed with Flex, so bundle it added into bundles.php in test and dev envs.
Also, I tried to serach containers with tag foundry.factory or even just foundry and can't find anything.

[kbond]

@Perf where is your userfacrory located? It needs to be autoconfigured/autowired.

[Perf]

@Perf where is your userfacrory located? It needs to be autoconfigured/autowired.

it's located under src/ folder (\App\User\Doctrine\Factory\UserFactory) so it should be autoconfigured and autowired. Other classes under src/ are autoconfigured and autowired.

[kbond]

Hmm, ok, can you find the factory with debug:container?

[kbond]

What does your config/services.yaml look like? Any exclusions for src/User?

I tried a branch new symfony new --version=lts with composer require --dev zenstruck/foundry and couldn't re-create your issue. I think it's your config.

[Perf]

Hmm, ok, can you find the factory with debug:container?

nope, absolutely nothing found

What does your config/services.yaml look like? Any exclusions for src/User?

parameters:

services:
    _defaults:
        autowire: true      # Automatically injects dependencies in your services.
        autoconfigure: true # Automatically registers your services as commands, event subscribers, etc.

    _instanceof:
        App\Shared\Application\Command\CommandHandlerInterface:
            tags:
                - { name: messenger.message_handler, bus: command.bus }

        App\Shared\Application\Query\QueryHandlerInterface:
            tags:
                - { name: messenger.message_handler, bus: query.bus }

    App\User\:
        resource: '../src/User/'
        exclude:
            - '../src/User/**/{Entity,ValueObject,CompilerPass}/**'
            - '../src/User/**/ApiPlatform/{Dto,Resource}/**'
            - '../src/User/**/*Exception.php'

    App\Shared\:
        resource: '../src/Shared/'
        exclude:
            - '../src/Shared/**/{Entity,ValueObject,CompilerPass}/**'
            - '../src/Shared/**/ApiPlatform/{Dto,Resource}/**'
            - '../src/Shared/**/*Exception.php'
            - '../src/Shared/Infrastructure/Symfony/Kernel.php'

[nikophil]

Hi @Perf

with this service.yaml, you should be able to retrieve App\User\Doctrine\Factory\UserFactory with $ bin/console debug:container UserFactory... this is not even related to foundry 🤔

don't you have any other config file? maybe for test environment?

[Perf]

Hi @Perf

with this service.yaml, you should be able to retrieve App\User\Doctrine\Factory\UserFactory with $ bin/console debug:container UserFactory... this is not even related to foundry 🤔

Hi @nikophil

$ bin/console de:cont UserFactory

No services found that match "UserFactory".

$ bin/console de:cont --tag=foundry.factory

No tags found that match "foundry.factory".

don't you have any other config file? maybe for test environment?

I have 2 other configs, but they are empty

imports:
    - { resource: services/shared.yaml }
    - { resource: services/user.yaml }

no configs for test env

[nikophil]

maybe your glob patterns do not work as expected? (although they look good to me)

Foundry does not make funky stuff with dependency injection, beside of tagging classes which extend ModelFactory.

[Perf]

maybe your glob patterns do not work as expected? (although they look good to me)

Foundry does not make funky stuff with dependency injection, beside of tagging classes which extend ModelFactory.

hey @nikophil
good finding, I commented the exclude lines and now UserFactory is up, with proper tag
so, I need to review my excludes...
Thank you very much!

[nikophil]

I'm curious to know the origin of the problem, when you'll find it out!

[Perf]

I'm curious to know the origin of the problem, when you'll find it out!

I updated excludes to the following and now UserFactory works!

    App\User\:
        resource: '../src/User/'
        exclude:
            - '../src/User/Domain/{Entity,ValueObject}/'
            - '../src/User/Infrastructure/ApiPlatform/{Dto,Resource}/'
            - '../src/User/Infrastructure/Doctrine/DataFixtures/'
            - '../src/User/**/*Exception.php'

    App\Shared\:
        resource: '../src/Shared/'
        exclude:
            - '../src/Shared/Domain/{Entity,ValueObject}/'
            - '../src/Shared/Infrastructure/ApiPlatform/{Dto,Resource}/'
            - '../src/Shared/Infrastructure/Doctrine/DataFixtures/'
            - '../src/Shared/Infrastructure/Symfony/Kernel.php'
            - '../src/Shared/Infrastructure/Symfony/CompilerPass/'
            - '../src/Shared/**/*Exception.php'

Now excludes are more explicit )

[nikophil]

yes but, which one was excluding the path src/User/Doctrine/Factory/UserFactory? 🤔

[Perf]

@nikophil

    App\User\:
        resource: '../src/User/'
        exclude:
            - '../src/User/**/{Entity,ValueObject,CompilerPass}/**' <<< THIS ONE
            - '../src/User/**/ApiPlatform/{Dto,Resource}/**'
            - '../src/User/**/*Exception.php'

[nikophil]

ok, thanks, good to know... this is... very strange! 😅