Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Oct 25, 2023. It is now read-only.

Group sent messages. #177

Closed
andreyvital opened this issue Mar 20, 2014 · 16 comments
Closed

Group sent messages. #177

andreyvital opened this issue Mar 20, 2014 · 16 comments

Comments

@andreyvital
Copy link

Hi!

I don't know if there's already a PR for that, but, what about introduce message grouping? like WhatsApp/Hangouts, etc.

Hugs!

@eliseumds
Copy link

+1

But.... let's convert it all to ReactJS before that hahahaha

@zhukov
Copy link
Owner

zhukov commented Mar 21, 2014

Do you mean broadcasts?

@andreyvital
Copy link
Author

@zhukov Nope.

@Haktrum
Copy link
Contributor

Haktrum commented Mar 22, 2014

Do you mean visually grouping consecutive sent messages? (BTW, WhatsApp doesn't do that on my phone)

@andreyvital
Copy link
Author

@Haktrum

captura de tela de 2014-03-22 15 32 16

@zhukov
Copy link
Owner

zhukov commented Mar 26, 2014

It's a lot harder to make them selectable then. Hangouts doesn't have this feature.

@zhukov
Copy link
Owner

zhukov commented Mar 26, 2014

I mean, if we make it grouped like you suggest, then we have to solve problems with proper selection. Have you seen mass edit feature?
2014-03-26 19 34 32

@ingria
Copy link
Contributor

ingria commented Mar 26, 2014

Look how they did that in vk.com:

conversations

Sent messages are grouped, and you also can select any of the grouped messages

@andreyvital
Copy link
Author

Exactly @jmcdn.

@eirinnm
Copy link

eirinnm commented Mar 27, 2014

I'm in favour of this, because it'll make the conversation a lot more compact!

@igorsantos07
Copy link

Not sure if this feature is behaving properly. I just opened webogram's web version (not chrome app) and sent some messages to two friends, as below:

Correct:
correct behaviour

Incorrect:
ungrouped behaviour

@zhukov
Copy link
Owner

zhukov commented May 8, 2014

There are some restrictions for these groups. E.g. the time difference must be less than 30 secs.

@igorsantos07
Copy link

I think I've sent all the messages together, but I'll keep that in mind anyway :)

@macandron
Copy link

I'd like for the time difference to be longer. 30 seconds seems a bit unnecessarily short. If you think about the flow of conversation - a conversation topic would not "end" until after a long break - say 5 minutes.

Personally I think the timeout for a "dialogue turn" should be at least 2 minutes. Sometimes it takes a while to write out your entire thought, but it's still about the same topic. As it stands now, conversations become quite verbose and difficult to follow, because almost every conversation looks like Igor Santos's example.

However I don't see why the timeout could not be 5 or 15 minutes instead? I think the main point of the timeout is that separate conversations (or conversations with very long time differences) are easy to tell apart.

"This dialogue turn took 15 minutes, then there was a one-hour break, then the same person continued for another 15 minutes." What difference do breaks of 30 seconds make? It often takes longer than 30 seconds to write one sentence. :D

Usually a conversation is broken up only after a few hours. Not 30 seconds.

Correct me if you think I'm wrong!

@macandron
Copy link

One more idea. Think about how long it takes before you start thinking that the other person left the conversation. Are you sure after 30 second of silence? After 2 minutes? After 5 minutes? 10? 15? 30?

For me, this is usually about 10 minutes. If I get no reply, I imagine the person has left to do something else. So their dialogue "turn" would be over and this should show in the conversation history with a new message group.

@igorsantos07
Copy link

I cannot add any other thing than saying that's something I've been thinking of and you could express exactly what I still had no words to say :)

I've been noticing how much space is spent between messages, with or without grouping - the screen still looks much more verbose and "empty" than other messengers.

zhukov added a commit that referenced this issue May 14, 2014
Now displaying unread icon for grouped messages
Increase group timeout to 5 minutes:
#177 (comment)
zhukov added a commit that referenced this issue Jun 2, 2014
Fixes #177
First attempt on #296
Video modal bugfixes
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

8 participants