Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Deletes Skrell #5406

Closed
wants to merge 3 commits into from
Closed

Deletes Skrell #5406

wants to merge 3 commits into from

Conversation

LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor

@LordFowl LordFowl commented Oct 10, 2018

This PR deletes all user-facing elements of Skrell (henceforth skrellements), primarily loadout items, vending machine items, voidsuit items, and the race itself, from being available in-game. These items and race datums still exist because presumably Skrell will not totally be removed from lore, so they have some potential use as adminbus items. However their total removal is certainly a feasible possibility given the necessary impetus.

Come November 3rd (The date of the next devmerge) it will have been over 100 days (102 specifically) since the Skrell have had a loredev, much less any development in their lore. When we were determining whether or not to remove Vaurca sometime in 2016, their loredev had been absent for far less, and even then their lore was not as infrequently updated as Skrell lore is. And to boot Vaurca barely hung on (Yes, there was a time when Vaurca nearly were removed from the server).

If Skrell will not be updated, and will not have a loredev, and will not participate in the server lore except as something to occasionally point to as a frame of reference, then why have them available in game? They are as relevant as Vox are at this point.

I do not have the stats on hand, but I can't imagine that this lore drought has down Skrell playerbase any good either. I would be surprised to see if there were even a handful of dedicated Skrell players at this point.

  • Complete removal of user-facing skrellements.
  • Verify removal of user-facing skrellements.
  • Verify changes with lore-team.

@Arrow768 Arrow768 added the Feedback Required The PR requires a feedback topic and feedback on the forum. label Oct 10, 2018
@Sindorman
Copy link
Contributor

I personally would not remove species items, etc. I would only remove In game reference and ability to spawn as skrell for players.

@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

The species items still exist in code, but are no longer available at round-start on station (e.g. voidsuits have been removed from EVA, skrell accessories have been removed from the loadout, skrellsnax have been removed from vendors and lunchboxes, etc.) This is what I refer to as a level 1 removal:

Level 1, Soft removal: Species is removed, but all lore and items remain intact. See; Vox
Level 2. Hard removal: Species is removed, lore is changed drastically, items are re-fluffed. See; Resomi, Bay's removal of Tajara.
Level 3. Total purge: The species is made to have never existed. All trace of it is wiped out, and to future generations its existence will be the subject of myth, not history.. See; Kocasslani.

@Alberyk Alberyk added the WIP The PR is a work in progress and should not be reviewed yet. label Oct 11, 2018
@Kaedwuff
Copy link
Contributor

Kaedwuff commented Oct 11, 2018

Why, though?

Are there plans to implement something new in their place? I don't particularly care about skrell, but it's odd to me to just remove them from the game because there is no lore devs around. People still play them.

They also exist currently as the only race that can play any role except humans. Are there plans to reshuffle the species availability for head roles? Skrell are supposed to be close allies to humans, unlike vaurca, who just kind of showed up one day and exist as second class citizens.

@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

A species without a loredev is a species frozen in time. They recieve no lore development, are involved in no lore events, and receive no new whitelists. The lifeblood of lore is motion, development. A lore that does not develop is dead. If nobody wants to become the Skrell loredev, even when faced with their removal, then I can’t imagine any of those few Skrell players cared much anyways.

I also do not see the need to replace the Skrell with anything. Our current species count is arbitrary, and can be arbitrarily reduced. Regarding the lore-side of why the Skrell are no longer present, anything can be justified. If it absolutely can’t then I suppose we can remove Skrell from the lore as well.

@Kaedwuff
Copy link
Contributor

Is there a thread about this, then?

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Oct 11, 2018

"If nobody wants to become the Skrell loredev, even when faced with their removal, then I can’t imagine any of those few Skrell players cared much anyways."
I've firsthand seen people claim that they'd absolutely do it if not for things like jobs, school, or other responsibilities. Combine with the fact that there was no form of server announcement or forum thread to this project in particular right up until it was ceremoniously made a PR and posted on discord and it should be apparent why this claim is pretty much ridiculous.
I (nor I Imagine any of the Skrell players outside of the staff) were aware that without a loredev their removal was upcoming, so this attitude of 'Nobody cares if Skrell are being removed, why even keep them' strikes me as an excuse, not a reason. If you're going to go with the actually reasonable claim of 'The fact that they have no progress in the lore whatsoever right now which makes them dead weight', maybe don't back it up with nonsensical 'Nobody cares anyway' claims.

@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

LordFowl commented Oct 11, 2018

Chill out, bröther. This PR is not even a day old. It's a full month until the devmerge. This change isn't being snuck in under the cover of darkness. You have seen the coming possibility, and you have an opportunity to react. The Skrell are not being removed tomorrow, nor indeed next week. I would be equally glad to see the Skrell revived as I would be to see them deleted, I just do not think it is particularly likely.

My points stand, regardless of whether you see them as excuses or reasons.

@LordFowl LordFowl changed the title [WIP] Deletes Skrell Deletes Skrell Oct 13, 2018
@Arrow768
Copy link
Member

Closing it, since it has served its purpose.
There are now a few applicants for skrell lore dev.

@Arrow768 Arrow768 closed this Oct 14, 2018
@Aurorastation Aurorastation deleted a comment from BurgerLUA Oct 14, 2018
@LordFowl LordFowl reopened this Oct 28, 2018
@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

Just in case we need it for the November merge

@LordFowl LordFowl closed this Oct 29, 2018
@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

Re-opening for dramatic effect.

@LordFowl LordFowl reopened this Oct 29, 2018
@LordFowl LordFowl removed the WIP The PR is a work in progress and should not be reviewed yet. label Oct 29, 2018
@Arrow768
Copy link
Member

Closing it. A new skrell lore dev has been chosen

@Arrow768 Arrow768 closed this Oct 29, 2018
@LordFowl
Copy link
Contributor Author

Actually you'll find that the new skrell lore-dev has thumbs up'd this PR, which means it's approved, so please stop trying to break through departmental barriers and stick to your lane, Arrow.

@LordFowl LordFowl deleted the delete_skrell branch January 26, 2019 19:11
@LordFowl LordFowl restored the delete_skrell branch April 1, 2019 03:21
@LordFowl LordFowl changed the base branch from development to master April 1, 2019 03:21
@LordFowl LordFowl reopened this Apr 1, 2019
@ToasterStrudes
Copy link

Heck yeah synth pride world wide glorsh did nothing wrong

@Sindorman
Copy link
Contributor

@LordFowl Have you tested the PR? If it still has some skrell presence that would be a no-no.

@LordFowl LordFowl closed this Apr 4, 2019
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Awaiting Merge Changelog Required Feedback Required The PR requires a feedback topic and feedback on the forum. 🗺️ Mapping - Aurora The PR touches the Aurora map files.
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

None yet

9 participants