mariadb-10.1.9 won't install because of conflicting mysql_config binaries

[linuxfood]

Seems like some days ago there was a split of the output paths for mariadb that makes it impossible to install or upgrade mariadb as near as I can tell.

This is the commit: e97b63a

collision between ‘/nix/store/mkmiziygv2v9hsq14xjs4lyjj12ncgsc-mariadb-10.1.9-lib/bin/mysql_config’ and ‘/nix/store/kbl8fh8mpdmisrhbaarg14v17024mbnq-mariadb-10.1.9/bin/mysql_config’; use ‘nix-env --set-flag priority NUMBER PKGNAME’ to change the priority of one of the conflicting packages

The suggested fix doesn't work because there's only one package in question.

[linuxfood]

For now I've locally forked the config for mariadb to change the cp to a mv.

[linuxfood]

For now I've locally forked the config for mariadb to change the cp to a mv.

[mogorman]

would changing mysql_config to mariadb_config be the right fix?

[mogorman]

would changing mysql_config to mariadb_config be the right fix?

[linuxfood]

@mogorman The two programs are literally identical. As far as I can tell, it's just invalid to have it in both output paths. The comment in the commit doesn't make sense to me. @wkennington could you elaborate a little on the intended purpose of the change?

My trivial one line change of 'cp' -> 'mv' at least makes it possible to create the user environment, but, I don't know if I've broken something else since I haven't tried to build any other expression that depends on mariadb yet.

[linuxfood]

@mogorman The two programs are literally identical. As far as I can tell, it's just invalid to have it in both output paths. The comment in the commit doesn't make sense to me. @wkennington could you elaborate a little on the intended purpose of the change?

My trivial one line change of 'cp' -> 'mv' at least makes it possible to create the user environment, but, I don't know if I've broken something else since I haven't tried to build any other expression that depends on mariadb yet.

[vcunat]

I assume that you don't need mariadb.lib in the user env and mariadb.out is enough, but that's rather a side step.

[vcunat]

I assume that you don't need mariadb.lib in the user env and mariadb.out is enough, but that's rather a side step.

[retrry]

I do too get this error still and I can't install mysql to user profile.

$ nix-env -iA nixos.mysql                                                                                                                                                
installing ‘mariadb-10.1.9’
building path(s) ‘/nix/store/0l8vqmcqng2ykiws4hxhavpzzh4mq4sh-user-environment’
Wide character in die at /nix/store/64jc9gd2rkbgdb4yjx3nrgc91bpjj5ky-buildenv.pl line 79.
collision between ‘/nix/store/b9799ll2ji4s505s6vy27wsh8zy8wsnz-mariadb-10.1.9-lib/bin/mysql_config’ and ‘/nix/store/6833bdiydb9ldv1j5dzgzqg1y1yh514d-mariadb-10.1.9/bin/mysql_config’; use ‘nix-env --set-flag priority NUMBER PKGNAME’ to change the priority of one of the conflicting packages
builder for ‘/nix/store/vv3akfnfbvbqym1p50iind80l5q2wfd0-user-environment.drv’ failed with exit code 255
error: build of ‘/nix/store/vv3akfnfbvbqym1p50iind80l5q2wfd0-user-environment.drv’ failed

[retrry]

I do too get this error still and I can't install mysql to user profile.

$ nix-env -iA nixos.mysql                                                                                                                                                
installing ‘mariadb-10.1.9’
building path(s) ‘/nix/store/0l8vqmcqng2ykiws4hxhavpzzh4mq4sh-user-environment’
Wide character in die at /nix/store/64jc9gd2rkbgdb4yjx3nrgc91bpjj5ky-buildenv.pl line 79.
collision between ‘/nix/store/b9799ll2ji4s505s6vy27wsh8zy8wsnz-mariadb-10.1.9-lib/bin/mysql_config’ and ‘/nix/store/6833bdiydb9ldv1j5dzgzqg1y1yh514d-mariadb-10.1.9/bin/mysql_config’; use ‘nix-env --set-flag priority NUMBER PKGNAME’ to change the priority of one of the conflicting packages
builder for ‘/nix/store/vv3akfnfbvbqym1p50iind80l5q2wfd0-user-environment.drv’ failed with exit code 255
error: build of ‘/nix/store/vv3akfnfbvbqym1p50iind80l5q2wfd0-user-environment.drv’ failed

[vcunat]

NixOS/nix#815 will give us a nice tool to specify that we only want mariadb.out when installing into a user env.

[vcunat]

NixOS/nix#815 will give us a nice tool to specify that we only want mariadb.out when installing into a user env.

[HittingSmoke]

Is there still no fix for this aside from forking the config? Trying to get Nix setup to handle my web servers.

[HittingSmoke]

Is there still no fix for this aside from forking the config? Trying to get Nix setup to handle my web servers.

[nicholasknight]

I started playing with Nix and quickly ran into this on OS X. :(

Is this heavily dependent on internal development work in Nix, or is there something I, as someone not familiar with the internals, can do to move it forward?

If the answer is "take over MariaDB maintenance in nixpkgs because the current maintainer(s) lack time", that's something I'm willing to try. I just really don't want to maintain a separate fork and make all our engineers use it for an indeterminate period of time.

[nicholasknight]

I started playing with Nix and quickly ran into this on OS X. :(

Is this heavily dependent on internal development work in Nix, or is there something I, as someone not familiar with the internals, can do to move it forward?

If the answer is "take over MariaDB maintenance in nixpkgs because the current maintainer(s) lack time", that's something I'm willing to try. I just really don't want to maintain a separate fork and make all our engineers use it for an indeterminate period of time.

[davidak]

@nicholasknight in general, you can fix issues and create pull requests.

but this is not a build problem. it's a collision of two outputs. i think you need deep understanding of how nix works to fix this.

[davidak]

@nicholasknight in general, you can fix issues and create pull requests.

but this is not a build problem. it's a collision of two outputs. i think you need deep understanding of how nix works to fix this.

[zimbatm]

how hard would it be to wrap one of the outputs with lib.lowPrio ?

[zimbatm]

how hard would it be to wrap one of the outputs with lib.lowPrio ?

[vcunat]

The problem is that nix installs all outputs by default. That is changeable with recent nix, after NixOS/nix#815.

[vcunat]

The problem is that nix installs all outputs by default. That is changeable with recent nix, after NixOS/nix#815.

[domenkozar]

@vcunat do we have a workaround for this except for reverting multiple outputs?

[domenkozar]

@vcunat do we have a workaround for this except for reverting multiple outputs?

[vcunat]

nix-env -f . -iA mariadb works for me now. I think it's because of NixOS/nix#815.

Note: this problem was there long before merging the closure-size branch.

[vcunat]

nix-env -f . -iA mariadb works for me now. I think it's because of NixOS/nix#815.

Note: this problem was there long before merging the closure-size branch.

[vcunat]

Note: it "works" because now only .out is installed and not .lib. If you forced installing both, you would run into this problem again, but I can't see why someone might want both outputs in their user env.

[vcunat]

Note: it "works" because now only .out is installed and not .lib. If you forced installing both, you would run into this problem again, but I can't see why someone might want both outputs in their user env.