Http mixin default http header overwrites bot configuration #2137
Conversation
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
sebix
reviewed
Jan 12, 2022
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks for the PR, but unfortunately this is a bit a can of worms. While most of the HTTP Mixin works perfectly fine, there's an unclear behaviour regarding the http_header variable which is the reason why it's re-set in the constructor (see the test fail https://github.com/certtools/intelmq/runs/4790117560?check_suite_focus=true#step:9:118).
A few months ago (still at cert.at), we tried to debug that but came to no conclusion, only this workaround. But as you now have found, that creates another bug :/
I fear there's a flaw elsewhere causing that.
The is not None
sebix
added
bug
|
Understood. However there should either be some reliable way to construct a http requests or this should be kept the generic http collector (with the proper handling of all configuration). I think I'd be okay with both of those options. Anyway these changes fixed the two issues I was facing so I'll leave it up to you whether you want this to be merged or not. |
I completely agree. However, as I am no longer working at CERT.at my work on IntelMQ is also not funded any more. I fear this is left unsolved unless someone steps up with either time or budget to fix this bug. |
sebix
added
the
help wanted
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 4, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 7, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 7, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 7, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
waldbauer-certat
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 7, 2022
**General** Removed 'requests' MissingDependencyError, because requests is a core lib from intelmq Removed HTTP variables from Bot class in favor of HttpMixin Removed trying to import requests in pipeline, its a core lib from intelmq Added additional configuration variables to HttpMixin ( from Bot class ) **Bots** GitHub API is now using HttpMixin MS Azure Collector is now using HttpMixin DO-Portal Expert is now using HttpMixin GeoHash using MissingDependencyError instead of ValueError (consistency) HttpContentExpert is now using HttpMixin HttpStatusExpert is now using HttpMixin NationalCERTContactCertATExpert is now using HttpMixin RDAPExpert is now using HttpMixin RIPEExpert is now using HttpMixin SplunkSavedSearchExpert is now using HttpMixin TuencyExpert is now using HttpMixin RestAPIOutput is now using HttpMixin **Bot tests** GitHub API Collector is now using requests_mock instead of MagicMock (consistency) RestAPI Output is now using correct headers Fixes #2150 Fixes #2137 Signed-off-by: Sebastian Waldbauer <waldbauer@cert.at>
|
@waldbauer-certat I think you are more experienced with the HTTP Mixin than me (#2151), can you take charge of this PR? |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Description
The default value for http headers was present also in the constructor of the mixin class effectively overwriting the bot http header configuration if any was supplied. This should be aligned with the 3.x design pattern.
Update: I found issue with the user agent not being replaced in the http header since the section was unreachable. I've added this commit to this pr since I think that creating a new one wouldn't be needed.