Update EIP-5570: Move to Last Call

[darcys22]

No description provided.

[eth-bot]

File EIPS/eip-5570.md

Requires 1 more reviewers from @axic, @Pandapip1, @SamWilsn, @xinbenlv

[Pandapip1]

I wouldn't usually block an EIP for content-related reasons, but this has some pretty significant privacy concerns, namely, doxxing the Ethereum address used to submit a transaction, their IRL name, telephone number, email address, and physical address and revealing the contents of everything the person has bought.

The above should be addressed before this moves to last call.

[darcys22]

I wouldn't usually block an EIP for content-related reasons, but this has some pretty significant privacy concerns, namely, doxxing the Ethereum address used to submit a transaction, their IRL name, telephone number, email address, and physical address and revealing the contents of everything the person has bought.

The above should be addressed before this moves to last call.

Hi @Pandapip1 thanks for raising this. I have made a response in the ethereum cat herders thead because its such an important topic. https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/idea-standard-digital-receipts-using-erc-721/9908/40

Do you think this information should be conveyed directly in the ERC? I can update it to include a note recommending that the metadata be encrypted, but the description of how to encrypt it is out of scope for this ERC

[SamWilsn]

Is this ready to go to last call, or are you still sorting out the privacy issues? If it isn't ready, would you mind making this a draft pull request?

[darcys22]

Hi @SamWilsn i believe it is ready for last call (but definitely needing a privacy NFT ERC to be made in the future to work with this ERC).

i didnt get a response to my comment, i was thinking about adding a line to the ERC saying the privacy issues would be out of scope and recommending the data be encrypted. But that was just going to be a stab in the dark to try resolve pandapips concerns