New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Remove Show from View menu items #1788
base: master
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Conversation
I don't agree 100% here. But also I don't care much. |
Agreed with Frank. @scootergrisen would you care on elaborating why this change is warranted? IMO it makes it slightly less clear, at least to a casual read, and doesn't really add any burden on the reader -- yet, I'm no HCI expert. |
Having something like "Show sidebar" don't make super much sense when its something you can toggle. If you really want to use "Show sidebar" then i guess it should say "Show sidebar" when the sidebar is hidden and "Hide sidebar" when the sidebar is showed. But since we got a checkmark there is no need for "Show" and "Hide". The checkmark tells the user if its on or off. When its in the View menu people know the menu items are about viewing something. There is also some strings starting with "Show " in Preferences - Editor - View under View. |
Don't really see the point of changing the view menu, a quick unscientific survey of the editor-like apps on my machine show about 50-50 so clearly either works. Removing the show would IMO make it slightly less clear, having a verb helps. And But for anyone with some basic UI ability, a checkbox in front of a UI element is pretty obvious what it does (and lets face it Geany is an IDE, if you can't work a UI you won't be much of a programmer). And as its a checkbox the label should not swap from Since the longest item in the menu is "Toggle all additional widgets" removing the shows won't make the menu smaller, so I don't see much point of changing it. @scootergrisen There is no |
As I see it, the checkbox is selecting [whether or not to] Show [the] sidebar, and it's clearer than just [checkbox] Sidebar. |
Thats the Gnome 3, stupid dumbed down applications HIG :( And GIMP (the REAL GTK HIG :) uses show. |
@scootergrisen Oh, display. Actually I'm not sure what those are there for, maybe they just predate the view menu, but they seem to do exactly the same thing. If thats the case then maybe they could be totally removed from the prefs dialog. Otherwise I kind of think the show should stay in the dialog, the heading is "Display" and it collects a group of "Display" related items, its not an action verb that naturally prepends to the items like menus do. But to me the whole thing seems to be movement for no purpose. |
The menu is called "View" so the "Show " part of the menu item is not nessesary.