cmd/go: switch to entirely content-based staleness determination

This CL changes the go command to base all its rebuilding decisions
on the content of the files being processed and not their file system
modification times. It also eliminates the special handling of release
toolchains, which were previously considered always up-to-date
because modification time order could not be trusted when unpacking
a pre-built release.

The go command previously tracked "build IDs" as a backup to
modification times, to catch changes not reflected in modification times.
For example, if you remove one .go file in a package with multiple .go
files, there is no modification time remaining in the system that indicates
that the installed package is out of date. The old build ID was the hash
of a list of file names and a few other factors, expected to change if
those factors changed.

This CL moves to using this kind of build ID as the only way to
detect staleness, making sure that the build ID hash includes all
possible factors that need to influence the rebuild decision.

One such factor is the compiler flags. As of this CL, if you run

	go build -gcflags -N cmd/gofmt

you will get a gofmt where every package is built with -N,
regardless of what may or may not be installed already.

Another such factor is the linker flags. As of this CL, if you run

	go install myprog
	go install -ldflags=-s myprog

the second go install will now correctly build a new myprog with
the updated linker flags. (Previously the installed myprog appeared
up-to-date, because the ldflags were not included in the build ID.)

Because we have more precise information we can also validate whether
the target of a "go test -c" operation is already the right binary and
therefore can avoid a rebuild.

This CL sets us up for having a more general build artifact cache,
maybe even a step toward not having a pkg directory with .a files,
but this CL does not take that step. For now the result of go install
is the same as it ever was; we just do a better job of what needs to
be installed.

This CL does slow down builds a small amount by reading all the
dependent source files in full. (The go command already read the
beginning of every dependent source file to discover build tags
and imports.) On my MacBook Pro, before this CL all.bash takes
3m58s, while after this CL and a few optimizations stacked above it
all.bash takes 4m28s. Given that CL 73850 cut 1m43s off the all.bash
time earlier today, we can afford adding 30s back for now.
More optimizations are planned that should make the go command
more efficient than it was even before this CL.

Fixes #15799.
Fixes #18369.
Fixes #19340.
Fixes #21477.

Change-Id: I10d7ca0e31ca3f58aabb9b1f11e2e3d9d18f0bc9
Reviewed-on: https://go-review.googlesource.com/73212
Run-TryBot: Russ Cox <rsc@golang.org>
TryBot-Result: Gobot Gobot <gobot@golang.org>
Reviewed-by: David Crawshaw <crawshaw@golang.org>

misc/cgo/testshared/shared_test.go

@@ -598,6 +598,7 @@ func TestThreeGopathShlibs(t *testing.T) {
 // If gccgo is not available or not new enough call t.Skip. Otherwise,
 // return a build.Context that is set up for gccgo.
 func prepGccgo(t *testing.T) build.Context {
+	t.Skip("golang.org/issue/22472")
 	gccgoName := os.Getenv("GCCGO")
 	if gccgoName == "" {
 		gccgoName = "gccgo"

src/cmd/dist/build.go

@@ -1018,7 +1018,9 @@ func cmdenv() {
 // that setting, not the new one.
 func cmdbootstrap() {
 	var noBanner bool
+	var debug bool
 	flag.BoolVar(&rebuildall, "a", rebuildall, "rebuild all")
+	flag.BoolVar(&debug, "d", debug, "enable debugging of bootstrap process")
 	flag.BoolVar(&noBanner, "no-banner", noBanner, "do not print banner")
 
 	xflagparse(0)
@@ -1055,31 +1057,7 @@ func cmdbootstrap() {
 	os.Setenv("GOARCH", goarch)
 	os.Setenv("GOOS", goos)
 
-	// TODO(rsc): Enable when appropriate.
-	// This step is only needed if we believe that the Go compiler built from Go 1.4
-	// will produce different object files than the Go compiler built from itself.
-	// In the absence of bugs, that should not happen.
-	// And if there are bugs, they're more likely in the current development tree
-	// than in a standard release like Go 1.4, so don't do this rebuild by default.
-	if false {
-		xprintf("##### Building Go toolchain using itself.\n")
-		for _, dir := range buildlist {
-			installed[dir] = make(chan struct{})
-		}
-		var wg sync.WaitGroup
-		for _, dir := range builddeps["cmd/go"] {
-			wg.Add(1)
-			dir := dir
-			go func() {
-				defer wg.Done()
-				install(dir)
-			}()
-		}
-		wg.Wait()
-		xprintf("\n")
-	}
-
-	xprintf("##### Building go_bootstrap for host, %s/%s.\n", gohostos, gohostarch)
+	xprintf("##### Building go_bootstrap.\n")
 	for _, dir := range buildlist {
 		installed[dir] = make(chan struct{})
 	}
@@ -1091,20 +1069,97 @@ func cmdbootstrap() {
 
 	gogcflags = os.Getenv("GO_GCFLAGS") // we were using $BOOT_GO_GCFLAGS until now
 	goldflags = os.Getenv("GO_LDFLAGS")
-
-	// Build full toolchain for host and (if different) for target.
-	if goos != oldgoos || goarch != oldgoarch {
-		os.Setenv("CC", defaultcc)
-		buildAll()
-		xprintf("\n")
+	goBootstrap := pathf("%s/go_bootstrap", tooldir)
+	cmdGo := pathf("%s/go", gobin)
+	if debug {
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), "-V=full")
+		copyfile(pathf("%s/compile1", tooldir), pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), writeExec)
+	}
+
+	// To recap, so far we have built the new toolchain
+	// (cmd/asm, cmd/cgo, cmd/compile, cmd/link)
+	// using Go 1.4's toolchain and go command.
+	// Then we built the new go command (as go_bootstrap)
+	// using the new toolchain and our own build logic (above).
+	//
+	//	toolchain1 = mk(new toolchain, go1.4 toolchain, go1.4 cmd/go)
+	//	go_bootstrap = mk(new cmd/go, toolchain1, cmd/dist)
+	//
+	// The toolchain1 we built earlier is built from the new sources,
+	// but because it was built using cmd/go it has no build IDs.
+	// The eventually installed toolchain needs build IDs, so we need
+	// to do another round:
+	//
+	//	toolchain2 = mk(new toolchain, toolchain1, go_bootstrap)
+	//
+	xprintf("\n##### Building Go toolchain2 using go_bootstrap and Go toolchain1.\n")
+	os.Setenv("CC", defaultcc)
+	if goos == oldgoos && goarch == oldgoarch {
+		// Host and target are same, and we have historically
+		// chosen $CC_FOR_TARGET in this case.
+		os.Setenv("CC", defaultcctarget)
+	}
+	toolchain := []string{"cmd/asm", "cmd/cgo", "cmd/compile", "cmd/link", "cmd/buildid"}
+	goInstall(toolchain...)
+	if debug {
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), "-V=full")
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/buildid", tooldir), pathf("%s/../../darwin_amd64/runtime/internal/sys.a", tooldir))
+		copyfile(pathf("%s/compile2", tooldir), pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), writeExec)
+	}
+
+	// Toolchain2 should be semantically equivalent to toolchain1,
+	// but it was built using the new compilers instead of the Go 1.4 compilers,
+	// so it should at the least run faster. Also, toolchain1 had no build IDs
+	// in the binaries, while toolchain2 does. In non-release builds, the
+	// toolchain's build IDs feed into constructing the build IDs of built targets,
+	// so in non-release builds, everything now looks out-of-date due to
+	// toolchain2 having build IDs - that is, due to the go command seeing
+	// that there are new compilers. In release builds, the toolchain's reported
+	// version is used in place of the build ID, and the go command does not
+	// see that change from toolchain1 to toolchain2, so in release builds,
+	// nothing looks out of date.
+	// To keep the behavior the same in both non-release and release builds,
+	// we force-install everything here.
+	//
+	//	toolchain3 = mk(new toolchain, toolchain2, go_bootstrap)
+	//
+	xprintf("\n##### Building Go toolchain3 using go_bootstrap and Go toolchain2.\n")
+	goInstall(append([]string{"-a"}, toolchain...)...)
+	if debug {
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), "-V=full")
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/buildid", tooldir), pathf("%s/../../darwin_amd64/runtime/internal/sys.a", tooldir))
+		copyfile(pathf("%s/compile3", tooldir), pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), writeExec)
+	}
+	checkNotStale(goBootstrap, append(toolchain, "runtime/internal/sys")...)
+
+	if goos == oldgoos && goarch == oldgoarch {
+		// Common case - not setting up for cross-compilation.
+		xprintf("\n##### Building packages and commands for %s/%s\n", goos, goarch)
+	} else {
+		// GOOS/GOARCH does not match GOHOSTOS/GOHOSTARCH.
+		// Finish GOHOSTOS/GOHOSTARCH installation and then
+		// run GOOS/GOARCH installation.
+		xprintf("\n##### Building packages and commands for host, %s/%s\n", goos, goarch)
+		goInstall("std", "cmd")
+		checkNotStale(goBootstrap, "std", "cmd")
+		checkNotStale(cmdGo, "std", "cmd")
+
+		xprintf("\n##### Building packages and commands for target, %s/%s\n", goos, goarch)
 		goos = oldgoos
 		goarch = oldgoarch
 		os.Setenv("GOOS", goos)
 		os.Setenv("GOARCH", goarch)
+		os.Setenv("CC", defaultcctarget)
+	}
+	goInstall("std", "cmd")
+	checkNotStale(goBootstrap, "std", "cmd")
+	checkNotStale(cmdGo, "std", "cmd")
+	if debug {
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), "-V=full")
+		run("", ShowOutput|CheckExit, pathf("%s/buildid", tooldir), pathf("%s/../../darwin_amd64/runtime/internal/sys.a", tooldir))
+		checkNotStale(goBootstrap, append(toolchain, "runtime/internal/sys")...)
+		copyfile(pathf("%s/compile4", tooldir), pathf("%s/compile", tooldir), writeExec)
 	}
-
-	os.Setenv("CC", defaultcctarget)
-	buildAll()
 
 	// Check that there are no new files in $GOROOT/bin other than
 	// go and gofmt and $GOOS_$GOARCH (target bin when cross-compiling).
@@ -1129,21 +1184,34 @@ func cmdbootstrap() {
 	}
 }
 
-func buildAll() {
-	desc := ""
-	if oldgoos != goos || oldgoarch != goarch {
-		desc = " host,"
-	}
-	xprintf("##### Building packages and commands for%s %s/%s.\n", desc, goos, goarch)
-	go_bootstrap := pathf("%s/go_bootstrap", tooldir)
-	go_install := []string{go_bootstrap, "install", "-v", "-gcflags=" + gogcflags, "-ldflags=" + goldflags}
+func goInstall(args ...string) {
+	installCmd := []string{pathf("%s/go_bootstrap", tooldir), "install", "-v", "-gcflags=" + gogcflags, "-ldflags=" + goldflags}
 
 	// Force only one process at a time on vx32 emulation.
 	if gohostos == "plan9" && os.Getenv("sysname") == "vx32" {
-		go_install = append(go_install, "-p=1")
+		installCmd = append(installCmd, "-p=1")
 	}
 
-	run(pathf("%s/src", goroot), ShowOutput|CheckExit, append(go_install, "std", "cmd")...)
+	run(goroot, ShowOutput|CheckExit, append(installCmd, args...)...)
+}
+
+func checkNotStale(goBinary string, targets ...string) {
+	out := run(goroot, CheckExit,
+		append([]string{
+			goBinary,
+			"list", "-gcflags=" + gogcflags, "-ldflags=" + goldflags,
+			"-f={{if .Stale}}\t{{.ImportPath}}: {{.StaleReason}}{{end}}",
+		}, targets...)...)
+	if out != "" {
+		os.Setenv("GOCMDDEBUGHASH", "1")
+		for _, target := range []string{"runtime/internal/sys", "cmd/dist", "cmd/link"} {
+			if strings.Contains(out, target) {
+				run(goroot, ShowOutput|CheckExit, goBinary, "list", "-f={{.ImportPath}} {{.Stale}}", target)
+				break
+			}
+		}
+		fatalf("unexpected stale targets reported by %s list -gcflags=\"%s\" -ldflags=\"%s\" for %v:\n%s", goBinary, gogcflags, goldflags, targets, out)
+	}
 }
 
 // Cannot use go/build directly because cmd/dist for a new release

src/cmd/dist/buildtool.go

@@ -106,7 +106,7 @@ func bootstrapBuildTools() {
 	if goroot_bootstrap == "" {
 		goroot_bootstrap = pathf("%s/go1.4", os.Getenv("HOME"))
 	}
-	xprintf("##### Building Go toolchain using %s.\n", goroot_bootstrap)
+	xprintf("##### Building Go toolchain1 using %s.\n", goroot_bootstrap)
 
 	mkzbootstrap(pathf("%s/src/cmd/internal/objabi/zbootstrap.go", goroot))
 

src/cmd/dist/test.go

@@ -23,6 +23,8 @@ import (
 )
 
 func cmdtest() {
+	gogcflags = os.Getenv("GO_GCFLAGS")
+
 	var t tester
 	var noRebuild bool
 	flag.BoolVar(&t.listMode, "list", false, "list available tests")
@@ -272,7 +274,7 @@ func (t *tester) registerStdTest(pkg string) {
 				"-short",
 				t.tags(),
 				t.timeout(180),
-				"-gcflags=" + os.Getenv("GO_GCFLAGS"),
+				"-gcflags=" + gogcflags,
 			}
 			if t.race {
 				args = append(args, "-race")
@@ -936,6 +938,7 @@ func (t *tester) cgoTest(dt *distTest) error {
 // running in parallel with earlier tests, or if it has some other reason
 // for needing the earlier tests to be done.
 func (t *tester) runPending(nextTest *distTest) {
+	checkNotStale("go", "std", "cmd")
 	worklist := t.worklist
 	t.worklist = nil
 	for _, w := range worklist {
@@ -985,6 +988,7 @@ func (t *tester) runPending(nextTest *distTest) {
 			log.Printf("Failed: %v", w.err)
 			t.failed = true
 		}
+		checkNotStale("go", "std", "cmd")
 	}
 	if t.failed && !t.keepGoing {
 		log.Fatal("FAILED")