New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[JENKINS-70326] Deprecate unleash plugin #3042
[JENKINS-70326] Deprecate unleash plugin #3042
Conversation
https://github.com/shillner/unleash-maven-plugin/ has been archived. That is the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. The Jenkins unleash maven plugin depends on the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. https://github.com/jenkinsci/unleash-plugin has been archived. That is the Jenkins unleash Maven plugin. The last release of the Jenkins unleash maven plugin was 3 years ago. Since the Jenkins plugin repository has been archived, we can expect no new releases of the plugin. https://issues.jenkins.io/browse/JENKINS-70326 notes that the Jenkins unleash maven plugin does not work with Java 17. Let's deprecate the Jenkins plugin so that it is clear to users that the Jenkins plugin is not being maintained and that the Apache Maven plugin is not being maintained. https://www.jenkins.io/doc/developer/plugin-governance/deprecating-or-removing-plugin/ says that the preferred way to deprecate a plugin is to add the "deprecated" topic to the repository and to explain in the plugin documentation why it is being deprecated. That would mean allowing writes to the repository again, just long enough to set the topic. I assume that is more complicated than the alternate method, a pull request to the update center repository to mark the repository as deprecated. https://github.com/jenkins-infra/plugins-wiki-docs/tree/master/unleash is the documentation for the plugin. I'll submit a pull request to the wiki repository to note that the plugin is deprecated.
You can see the error and some discussion about it here: |
If the upstream service the plugin depends on is no longer maintained, we may also suspend the plugin from the update center, making the deprecation note obsolete 🤔 |
https://github.com/shillner/unleash-maven-plugin/ has been archived. That is the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. The Jenkins unleash maven plugin depends on the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. https://github.com/jenkinsci/unleash-plugin has been archived. That is the Jenkins unleash Maven plugin. The last release of the Jenkins unleash maven plugin was 3 years ago. Since the Jenkins plugin repository has been archived, we can expect no new releases of the plugin. [JENKINS-70326](https://issues.jenkins.io/browse/JENKINS-70326) notes that the Jenkins unleash maven plugin does not work with Java 17. Let's deprecate the Jenkins plugin so that it is clear to users that the Jenkins plugin is not being maintained and that the Apache Maven plugin is not being maintained. https://www.jenkins.io/doc/developer/plugin-governance/deprecating-or-removing-plugin/ says that the preferred way to deprecate a plugin is to add the "deprecated" topic to the repository and to explain in the plugin documentation why it is being deprecated. That would mean allowing writes to the repository again, just long enough to set the topic. I assume that is more complicated than the alternate method, a pull request to the update center repository to mark the repository as deprecated. jenkins-infra/repository-permissions-updater#3042 is the request to remove all developers from the archived plugin repository.
As far as I understand it, the Apache Maven unleash plugin is unmaintained but still available. The existing functionality continues to work. Since the existing functionality continues to work, I think that deprecation is more appropriate than suspension. |
https://github.com/shillner/unleash-maven-plugin/ has been archived. That is the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. The Jenkins unleash maven plugin depends on the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. https://github.com/jenkinsci/unleash-plugin has been archived. That is the Jenkins unleash Maven plugin. The last release of the Jenkins unleash maven plugin was 3 years ago. Since the Jenkins plugin repository has been archived, we can expect no new releases of the plugin. [JENKINS-70326](https://issues.jenkins.io/browse/JENKINS-70326) notes that the Jenkins unleash maven plugin does not work with Java 17. Let's deprecate the Jenkins plugin so that it is clear to users that the Jenkins plugin is not being maintained and that the Apache Maven plugin is not being maintained. jenkins-infra/repository-permissions-updater#3042 is the request to remove all developers from the archived plugin repository
JENKINS-70326 Deprecate unleash plugin
https://github.com/shillner/unleash-maven-plugin/ has been archived. That is the unleash plugin for Apache Maven. The Jenkins unleash maven plugin depends on the unleash plugin for Apache Maven.
https://github.com/jenkinsci/unleash-plugin has been archived. That is the Jenkins unleash Maven plugin. The last release of the Jenkins unleash maven plugin was 3 years ago. Since the Jenkins plugin repository has been archived, we can expect no new releases of the plugin.
JENKINS-70326 notes that the Jenkins unleash maven plugin does not work with Java 17.
Let's deprecate the Jenkins plugin so that it is clear to users that the Jenkins plugin is not being maintained and that the Apache Maven plugin is not being maintained.
The deprecation document says that the preferred way to deprecate a plugin is to add the "deprecated" topic to the repository and to explain in the plugin documentation why it is being deprecated. That would mean allowing writes to the repository again, just long enough to set the topic.
I assume that is more complicated than the alternate method, a pull request to the update center repository to mark the repository as deprecated. @daniel-beck is it better / easier for me to submit the pull request to the update center or would you prefer that I ask that the repository be temporarily unarchived?
https://github.com/jenkins-infra/plugins-wiki-docs/tree/master/unleash is the documentation for the plugin. I'll submit a pull request to the wiki repository to note that the plugin is deprecated.
Submitter checklist for adding or changing permissions
Always
Reviewer checklist (not for requesters!)
$pluginId Developers
team hasAdmin
permissions while granting the access.@Wadeck
) in this pull request. If an email contact is changed, wait for approval from the security officer.There are IRC Bot commands for it