Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

To-fix: Crossing highways #104

Closed
Rub21 opened this issue Jul 23, 2015 · 43 comments
Closed

To-fix: Crossing highways #104

Rub21 opened this issue Jul 23, 2015 · 43 comments
Labels
task

Comments

@Rub21
Copy link
Contributor

Rub21 commented Jul 23, 2015 •
edited by samely
Loading

Objective

Review and repair highway intersections that are not connected to a node.

Tasks

Tasks below are updating everyday from Monday to Friday with the latest errors in OpenStreetMap

Changeset comment

Adding junction nodes or bridges to overlapping highways using #to-fix https://github.com/mapbox/mapping/issues/104

Coverage

All countries in this list: https://s3.amazonaws.com/mapbox/to-fix/mbtiles.txt

Tools for edition

Instructions

  • Connect level intersections of two highways with a node where they are not connected. This excludes bridges and tunnels. Confirm an intersection is level from satellite imagery.
  • According to the satellite imagery, add bridge=yes and layer=* or tunnel=yes and layer=-1.
  • If editing in an actively mapped area, add a note instead of making a fix.
  • If satellite imagery isn't clear click on not an error of to-fix

Common issues

image
Add layer=1 to the bridge

image1
Join the node to the road

image2
Add tunnel=yes and layer=-1

image3
Add a node to connect both roads

How are we doing the error detection?

We are using osm-qa-tiles and osmlint selfIntersectingHighways

Who will work on these tasks?

Everybody is available to work on resolving these issues. However, @mapbox/data-team (Peru office) will work on everyday.

Question

Tag @planemad or @Rub21 for questions.

cc. @mapbox/team-data @lxbarth @aaronlidman
@planemad planemad added the task label Aug 11, 2015
@samely
Copy link

samely commented Aug 25, 2015

Today @mapbox/peru-office is starting to work in this task.

image
Happy mapping 🚀
cc. @lxbarth

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Oct 19, 2015

@Rub21 has updated issues in this task, so we the status is:

image

@Rub21
Copy link
Contributor Author

Rub21 commented Mar 8, 2016

Updates

We've added 76,182 issues on 08/03/2016, the detection was made using osmlint.

@Rub21 Rub21 changed the title To-fix: highway intersecting highways To-fix: Crossing major highways Apr 1, 2016
@Rub21
Copy link
Contributor Author

Rub21 commented Apr 1, 2016

Update 28/03/2016

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Apr 1, 2016

Well done team! 🚀 🚀 🚀
image

@shvrm
Copy link

shvrm commented Apr 2, 2016

Great work guys! 💥

@ruthmaben
Copy link

Nice work 👏 @mapbox/peru-office!

@pratikyadav
Copy link
Contributor

Great work team 🚀
Closing here.

@karitotp karitotp mentioned this issue May 3, 2016
Closed
@geochetan geochetan mentioned this issue May 11, 2016
Closed
@karitotp karitotp mentioned this issue May 17, 2016
Closed
@karitotp karitotp mentioned this issue Jun 7, 2016
Closed
@ediyes ediyes reopened this Jun 24, 2016
@Rub21
Copy link
Contributor Author

Rub21 commented Jun 30, 2016

Osmlint for the error detection

https://github.com/osmlab/osmlint/tree/master/validators/crossingHighways

@samely samely changed the title To-fix: Crossing major highways To-fix: Crossing highways Jun 30, 2016
@calfarome
Copy link

calfarome commented Jul 7, 2016 •
edited by Rub21
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 06/20/2016 - 06/24/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th, June 61 0
Tuesday 21st, June 95 54
Wednesday 22nd, June 10 4
Thursday 23rd, June 38 7
Friday 24th, June 129 52
Total -- 117
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 06/20/2016 - 06/24/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th, June 66 0
Tuesday 21st, June 123 68
Wednesday 22nd, June 28 12
Thursday 23rd, June 45 18
Friday 24th, June 1311 942
Total -- 1040

@RichRico
Copy link

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 06/27/2016 - 07/01/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th, June 127 76
Tuesday 21st, June 32 13
Wednesday 22nd, June 45 13
Thursday 23rd, June 25 0
Friday 24th, June 24 19
Total -- 121
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 06/27/2016 - 07/01/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th, June 282 215
Tuesday 21st, June 38 21
Wednesday 22nd, June 37 21
Thursday 23rd, June 21 0
Friday 24th, June 143 66
Total -- 323

@karitotp
Copy link

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 07/04/2016 - 07/08/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 04th, July 135 71
Tuesday 05th, July 36 19
Wednesday 06th, July 81 30
Thursday 07th, July 45 45
Friday 08th, July 43 23
Total -- 188
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 07/04/2016 - 07/08/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 04th, July 167 0
Tuesday 05th, July 109 71
Wednesday 06th, July 96 14
Thursday 07th, July 27 27
Friday 08th, July 64 34
Total -- 146

@krishnanammala krishnanammala mentioned this issue Jul 12, 2016
Closed
@dannykath
Copy link

dannykath commented Jul 15, 2016 •
edited
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 07/11/2016 - 07/14/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 11th, July 23 23
Tuesday 12th, July 68 68
Wednesday 13th, July 34 3
Total -- 94
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 07/11/2016 - 07/14/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 11th, July 3020 --
Tuesday 12th, July 3107 2119
Wednesday 13th, July 2118 --
Friday 15th, July 168 94
Total -- 2213

@luiswalter
Copy link

luiswalter commented Jul 22, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 07/18/2016 - 07/22/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 18th, July 61 26
Wednesday 20th, July 152 95
Thursday 21th, July 45 25
Total -- 146
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 07/18/2016 - 07/22/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 18th, June 18967 13470
Tuesday 19th, June 3007 2423
Wednesday 20th, June 247 0
Thursday 21st, June 265 0
Friday 22nd, June 314 0
Total 22800 15993

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Aug 1, 2016 •
edited
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 07/25/2016 - 07/27/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 25th, July 100 0
Tuesday 26th, July 106 59
Wednesday 27th, July 86 86
Total -- 145

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Aug 5, 2016

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 07/25/2016 - 07/27/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 18th, June 409 158
Tuesday 19th, June 190 28
Wednesday 20th, June 54 0
Total 653 186

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Aug 8, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 08/01/2016 - 08/05/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 1st, August 173 0
Tuesday 2nd, August 39 12
Wednesday 3th, August 1810 0 obs.
Thursday 4th, August 123 0
Friday 5th, August 135 64
Total -- 76
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 08/01/2016 - 08/05/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 1st, August 309 0
Tuesday 2nd, August 33 22
Wednesday 3th, August 4932 0 obs.
Thursday 4th, August 120 0
Friday 5th, August 149 74
Total -- 96

@samely samely mentioned this issue Aug 12, 2016
Closed
@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Aug 15, 2016 •
edited by samely
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 08/08/2016 - 08/12/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 8th, August 17 17
Tuesday 9th, August 30 29
Wednesday 10th, August 13 13
Thursday 11th, August 17 8
Friday 12th, August 17 13
Total -- 80
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 08/08/2016 - 08/12/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 8th, August 58 0
Tuesday 9th, August 136 68
Wednesday 10th, August 95 24
Thursday 11th, August 37 27
Friday 12th, August 35 15
Total -- 134

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Aug 19, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 08/15/2016 - 08/19/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 15th, August 88 56
Tuesday 16th, August 38 0
Wednesday 17th, August 69 0
Thursday 18th, August 113 49
Friday 19th, August 68 32
Total -- 137
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 08/15/2016 - 08/19/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 15th, August 115 92
Tuesday 16th, August 29 20
Wednesday 17th, August 35 0
Thursday 18th, August 56 25
Friday 19th, August 76 69
Total -- 206

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Aug 28, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 08/22/2016 - 08/26/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 22th, August 48 20
Tuesday 23th, August 89 49
Wednesday 24th, August 96 15
Thursday 25th, August 52 0
Friday 26th, August 82 35
Total -- 119
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 08/22/2016 - 08/26/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 22th, August 126 62
Tuesday 23th, August 121 32
Wednesday 24th, August 96 17
Thursday 25th, August 52 10
Friday 26th, August 14 3
Total -- 124

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Sep 5, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 08/29/2016 - 09/02/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 29th, August 76 56
Tuesday 30th, August 315 0
Wednesday 31th, August 269 0
Total -- 56
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 08/29/2016 - 09/02/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 29th, August 167 36
Tuesday 30th, August 46 20
Wednesday 31th, August 88 46
Total -- 102

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Sep 9, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 09/05/2016 - 09/09/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 5th, August 107 65
Tuesday 6th, August 30 18
Wednesday 7th, August 70 0
Thursday 8th, August 109 0
Friday 9th, August 83 45
Total -- 128
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 09/05/2016 - 09/09/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 5th, August 406 76
Tuesday 6th, August 214 79
Wednesday 7th, August 177 76
Thursday 8th, August 53 46
Friday 9th, August 75 26
Total -- 303

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Sep 16, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 09/12/2016 - 09/16/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 12th, August 160 76
Tuesday 13th, August 76 40
Wednesday 14th, August 42 0
Thursday 15th, August 80 30
Friday 16th, August 50 31
Total -- 178
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 09/12/2016 - 09/16/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 12th, August 117 87
Tuesday 13th, August 63 48
Wednesday 14th, August 105 0
Thursday 15th, August 179 66
Friday 16th, August 90 56
Total -- 257

@RichRico
Copy link

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 09/19/2016 - 09/23/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 19th, August 111 70
Tuesday 20th, August 838 0
Wednesday 21st, August 792 0
Thursday 22nd, August 191 134
Friday 23rd, August 12515 7764
Total **** 7968

@ediyes
Copy link

ediyes commented Oct 28, 2016 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 10/24/2016 - 10/28/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Tuesday 25th, October 444 73
Wednesday 26th, October 339 143
Thursday 27th, October 143 1
Friday 28th, October 130 64
Total -- 281
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 10/24/2016 - 10/28/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Tuesday 25th, October 246 181
Wednesday 26th, October 165 81
Thursday 27th, October 88 4
Friday 28th, October 213 92
Total -- 358

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Nov 7, 2016 •
edited
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 10/31/2016 - 11/04/2016
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 31th, August 155 76
Tuesday 01th, August -- --
Wednesday 02nd, August 103 0
Thursday 03rd, August 59 11
Friday 04th, August -- --
Total **** 87
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 01/02/2017 - 01/06/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 02nd, January -- --
Tuesday 03th, January -- --
Wednesday 04th, January 127 62
Thursday 05th, January -- --
Friday 06th, January -- --
Total **** 62

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Jan 14, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 09/01/2017 - 13/01/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 09th, January 275
Tuesday 10th, January 275
Wednesday 11th, January 357 72
Thursday 12th, January 152 2
Friday 13th, January 148 53
Total -- 127
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 01/09/2017 - 01/13/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 09th, January 294
Tuesday 10th, January 284
Wednesday 11th, January 232 143
Thursday 12th, January 137 76
Friday 13th, January 90 52
Total -- 271

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Jan 17, 2017

Last and this week I found many crossing issues due to some changesets made by Gã Trùm, some of his edits look good, however, doesn't match with satellite imagery (I even looked at google map to be sure), also he has been editing with iD and is a new mapper. I've already left changeset comments last week but there is no reply. Not sure if I should revert them, what do you think @krishnanammala?
Those are the changeset that I've found:

cc. @Rub21

@samely
Copy link

samely commented Jan 20, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 16/01/2017 - 20/01/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 16th, January 216 111
Tuesday 17th, January 74 38
Wednesday 18th, January 38 1
Thursday 19th, January 0 0
Friday 20th, January 304 109
Total -- 259
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 16/01/2017 - 20/01/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 16th, January 229 127
Tuesday 17th, January 97 45
Wednesday 18th, January 45 0
Thursday 19th, January 0 0
Friday 20th, January 185 126
Total -- 298

Obs.

  • I found those features in Poland that are based on proposal tags: #1, #2, #3 and more around this area.
  • I also found some deleted highways.

@ediyes
Copy link

ediyes commented Jan 27, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 01/23/2017 - 01/27/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 23rd January 117 57
Wednesday 25th January 298 120
Thursday 26th January 373 215
Total -- 392
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 01/23/2017 - 01/27/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 23rd January 181 71
Tuesday 24th January 75 --
Wednesday 25th January 228 --
Total -- 71

@ediyes
Copy link

ediyes commented Feb 3, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 01/30/2017 - 02/03/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 30th January 1099 237
Tuesday 31st January 634 282
Wednesday 01st February 706 70
Thursday 2nd February 240 85
Total -- 674
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 01/30/2017 - 02/03/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Tuesday 31st January 1070 454
Wednesday 01st February 416 0
Thursday 2nd February 276 64
Friday 3rd February 331 187
Total -- 705

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Feb 13, 2017 •
edited by ridixcr
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 02/06/2017 - 02/10/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 615 55
Tuesday 605 74
Total -- 129
Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 02/06/2017 - 02/10/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 6th February 168 111
Tuesday 7th February 473 100
Wednesday 8th February 473 311
Thursday 9th February 👈(No detected) 0 0
Friday 10th February 👈(No detected) 0 0
Total -- 522

@ridixcr
Copy link

ridixcr commented Feb 20, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from issues from 02/13/2017 - 02/17/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Wednesday 15th February 👈(No detected) 0 0
Thursday 16th February 0 0
Friday 17th February 516 107
Total -- 107
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 02/13/2017 - 02/17/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Thursday 475 82
Total -- 82

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Feb 27, 2017 •
edited by ridixcr
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 02/20/2017 - 02/24/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th February 454 79
Tuesday 21th February 365 7
Wednesday 22nd February 310 75
Thursday 23th February -- --
Friday 24th February 257 73
Total -- 234
Progress Crossing minor highwaysissues from 02/20/2017 - 02/24/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 20th February 611 247
Tuesday 21th February 227 192
Wednesday 22nd February 68 41
Thursday 23th February 0 0
Friday 24th February 194 74
Total -- 554

@ridixcr
Copy link

ridixcr commented Mar 5, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 02/27/2017 - 03/03/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 27th February 178 74
Tuesday 28th February 261 20
Wednesday 1st March 231 0
Thursday 2nd March 276 172
Friday 3rd March 121 89
Total -- 355
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 02/20/2017 - 02/24/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 27th February 265 101
Tuesday 28th February 90 0
Wednesday 1st March 166 6
Thursday 2nd March 0 0
Friday 3rd March 383 69
Total -- 176

@ridixcr
Copy link

ridixcr commented Mar 12, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 03/06/2017 - 03/10/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 06th March 131 91
Tuesday 07th March 72 0
Wednesday 08th March 72 0
Thursday 09th March 72 56
Friday 10th March 108 97
Total -- 244
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 03/06/2017 - 03/10/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Tuesday 310 18
Wednesday 107 62
Thursday 0 0
Friday 241 73
Total -- 153

@ridixcr
Copy link

ridixcr commented Mar 20, 2017 •
edited by RichRico
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways issues from 03/13/2017 - 03/17/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Wednesday 15th March 258 157
Friday 17th March 167 120
Total -- 277
Progress Crossing major highways issues from 03/13/2017 - 03/17/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Wednesday 15th March 553 56
Friday 17th March 532 113
Total -- 163

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented Apr 3, 2017 •
edited
Loading

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 03/27/2017- 03/31/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Tuesday 28th March 282 81
Total -- 81

@RichRico
Copy link

Progress Crossing major highways issues from 04/03/2017- 04/07/2017
Date N° detected error Total Fixed
Monday 3th April 11 9
Tuesday 4th April 9 0
Wednesday 5th April 2 1
Friday 7th 2 1
Total -- 11

@RichRico
Copy link

Progress Crossing major highways from 04/17/2017 - 04/21/2017
Date Detected Issues Fixed Issues
Monday 17th April 46 6
Tuesday 18th April 10 5
Wednesday 19th April 2 0
-- Total 11

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented May 2, 2017

Progress Crossing major highways from 04/24/2017 - 04/28/2017
Date Detected Issues Fixed Issues
Monday 24th April 112 10
-- Total 10

@RichRico
Copy link

RichRico commented May 8, 2017 •
edited by ridixcr
Loading

Progress Crossing minor highways 05/01/2017 - 05/05/2017
Date Detected Issues Fixed Issues
Wednesday 3rd May 304 171
Friday 5th May 16 7
-- Total 178
Progress Crossing major highways from 05/01/2017 - 05/05/2017
Date Detected Issues Fixed Issues
Tuesday 2nd May 373 174
Wednesday 3rd May 76 56
Friday 5th May 42 32
-- Total 262

@RichRico
Copy link

Progress Crossing major highways from 05/08/2017 - 05/12/2017
Date Detected Issues Fixed Issues
Monday 8th May 26 11
Tuesday 9th May 11 7
Thursday 11th May 21 6
Friday 12th May 6563 24
-- Total 48

@maning maning closed this as completed Nov 19, 2017
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
task
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests