CompositeView attempts to appendHtml of itemViews before itemViewContainer exists (before template is rendered) #533

wants to merge 1 commit into


None yet

8 participants


I have a CompositeView which takes a model (already downloaded from server) and a collection which is then fetched. As soon as the sync is finished, I want to render my CompositeView. However, the CompositeView appears to try appending the itemViews for the collection before it renders its own template, and so it can't find its own itemViewContainer, generating error Uncaught ItemViewContainerMissingError: The specifieditemViewContainerwas not found: .modal__body.

Here is a gist.

I should note that I have exactly the same setup elsewhere and it works with no problems, so it could well be something on my end, but I've spent long enough debugging this one and I can't seem to find the problem!


Here is a screenshot of my call stack which might point you to something.


Aha, the reason it was working in another part of my application is because I had a custom appendHtml. If I remove that, I have the same problem there too…


This commit seems to attempt to fix the problem, but I had to go a little bit further and check that the CollectionView/CompositeView was rendered before executing appendHtml for the ItemViews. I wonder if we can prevent renderItemView from executing at all when a model is added to the collection, as currently this is what it does, even when the CollectionView/CompositeView is not rendered.

Glad I'm finally getting to the bottom of this. One thing is for sure, it has improved my JS debugging skills! Sorry I couldn't submit a spec for this.

Marionette.js member

AHA! good catch, and totally makes sense now that you point it out. Will get this pulled in w/ a spec, along with some other bug fixes, ASAP.


It does cause quite a few specs to fail, hope you can work around that!


Hi everyone.
I have same problem, and some thoughts.

Before you apply this fix:
Does attribute isRendered used in CollectionView ?
This fix causes another problem. Collection views won't work properly.

So i added renderItemView method with isRendered condition to CompositeView class. And now it works fine.

I hope it can help you.


@atorian Could you make a PR, and reference it here? I would be grateful to see your solution and it makes it easier for @derickbailey to just merge.


I think a much cleaner solution is the one proposed by @b4cedev in #377 - binding to collection events only after the CompositeView has been rendered:

_initialEvents: function(){
    this.once('render', function () {
      if (this.collection){
        this.listenTo(this.collection, "add", this.addChildView, this);
        this.listenTo(this.collection, "remove", this.removeItemView, this);
        this.listenTo(this.collection, "reset", this._renderChildren, this);
    }, this);

This way we avoid unnecessary calculations in all methods starting from addChildView, not just in appendHtml.


Thanks @lukaszfiszer and @b4cedev ! That's exactly what I needed.

Marionette.js member


@samccone samccone closed this Sep 25, 2013

When this fix will be in the upstream?


👍 Need this one too, it should be re opened, no ?

@samccone samccone reopened this Oct 25, 2013
Marionette.js member

I like @lukaszfiszer solution, anyone want to take a stab at opening a PR with this fix?


I can submit a PR during this weekend.

@lukaszfiszer lukaszfiszer added a commit to lukaszfiszer/backbone.marionette that referenced this pull request Oct 30, 2013
@lukaszfiszer lukaszfiszer Fix CompositeView adding child views before render
* in CompositeView._initialEvents wait for 'render' event before binding
to collection events.
* added specs

Fixes #533.
@samccone samccone closed this in #763 Nov 14, 2013
@naegelyd naegelyd referenced this pull request in chop-dbhi/cilantro Feb 5, 2014

Cannot save query #377

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment