Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 40 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
MSC2312: Matrix URI scheme proposal #2312
MayeulC left a comment
This looks like a solid MSC to me, with good self-consistency. I am still not sold on the type specifier, though maybe the way to go is to have a first version out and iterate on it (with all the complexity due to backwards compatibility).
I would put a lot more real-life examples in the spec, as advised in the RFCs. Have this been trough a lot of verification, or does it need further analysis (like fuzzing) to check that no ambiguous situation might arise?
I would like to see someone from the IETF review this MSC once it is approved on the Matrix side, before accepting this, as they are likely to have a lot more experience on that topic.
The most relevant stuff from those notes is probably the action plan I wrote:
The following steps are required to bootstrap the ecosystem once the proposal has been accepted:
Not exactly, it's just a result of copy-pasting from the older Google doc. If that causes problems, I can revert to ASCII quotes.