MCP-0033 Annotations for Predefined Plots #2482
Conversation
…ptional identifier. Closes #2363
Batter -> Battery (twice)
The decisions at 99th Design meeting.
…sign meeting These changes are mainly about renaming and reorganizing features presented or planned at the previous design meeting. References and comparisons to the current use of predefined plots in Wolfram SystemModeler have been removed. The handling of axis boundaries have been defined by making the choice of unit explicit.
Having figures as part of the Documentation has become very natural now that they also include captions, and that part of the current content of the 'info' might end up being migrated to figure captions instead. Second, the figures are expected to be heavily linked from the 'info', which is another reason for keeping them close together. Third, this avoids the use of a container record with just a single record member.
Added example figure from the prototype
Consistently using record constructors.
Update predefined-plots.md
Text markup for captions
Merge master into the MCP branch
…Annotations for the Graphical User Interface"
…ppear anywhere in any annotation)
Co-authored-by: Henrik Tidefelt <henrikt@wolfram.com>
Incorporate suggestions from #2578
Merging, based on decision to move the MCP into _Under evaluation_ state at yesterday's phone meeting.
Merging, based on decision to move the MCP into _Under evaluation_ state at yesterday's phone meeting.
|
All PRs targeting this MCP branch are now merged, and the MCP is now entering state Under evaluation as agreed during yesterday's phone meeting. I thought now was the time to remove the draft state of the PR, but it had already been removed, I don't remember when… The three required reviews have been provided by the following persons, see above: @maltelenz, @DagBruck, @gkurzbach |
|
@HansOlsson is there any reason to delay the voting further, or could you please make the announcement? |
|
While currently in the state Under evaluation, some smaller issues have come to our attention, resulting in two PRs:
These are considered minor enough to not abort the ongoing voting for acceptance of the MCP. Instead, we hope that the MCP can be accepted despite these issues, and that the issues can still be resolved before the figure annotations appear for the first time in a released version of the specification. |
|
Since it was unclear for some people voting, the generated PDF and HTML files are available in the CI/CD system in case you don't want to read the LaTeX code. |
|
Is there a working prototype of this MCP available in any Modelica tool e.g., SystemModeler? SystemModeler 12.0.0.11 doesn't support this, right? |
Dymola 2021 included parts of it (but not the links-part as far as I recall - and there might have been some mistakes), and it will be improved in future Dymola versions (and likely the same will be included in versions of 3D Experience platforms as well). Persons working on other tools will have to answer themselves. |
No SystemModeler 12.0.0.11 doesn't support it. 12.1 supports the proposal as it was around October 2019. However, it has changed too much since then so it cannot read the current format (there might be an intersection that works, but I have tried to find it). 12.2 will support the proposal in the current state. |
|
The vote is now complete.
Thus the MCP is accepted (every member should be able to follow the vote-link to confirm the result). |
|
Don't be sorry for the negligible delay. Regarding the two open PRs against this branch, I would suggest that we now merge MCP/0033 and close this PR, but without removing the branch. Then, we can just merge the branch again once we are done with the two remaining PRs. |
We are now beginning the collection of reviews in order to be able to enter the MCP state under evaluation.
This PR is currently in draft state, since reviewers might raise non-trivial issues that we would like to address before entering under evaluation. When entering under evaluation, the draft state will be removed as a signal of not intending to commit anything but minor corrections.