Invalid parameter error: metricsContext.utmCampaign

[marniepw]

1. Got an email (10:57am PST, Dec. 11) at my personal gmail address (opened in Safari):
   Title: Find out if you've been part of a breach.
   Body: A lot can happen in a year
2. Clicked blue "Sign up for breach alerts" button
3. It opened a new tab (in Safari) to "Sign in to continue to Firefox Monitor"
4. It prefilled my mozilla.com email address and requested my password.
5. I entered the password (both by typing and then tried using Safari's autofill).
6. Error appeared.

[groovecoder]

I think this is an issue for the @mozilla/fxa-devs ?

[vladikoff]

Yeap, we should transfer this issue to mozilla/fxa-content-server

[vladikoff]

@marniepw just checking, what's the utm_campaign param in the URL?

[marniepw]

@vladikoff - utm_campaign=fx-monitor-twos%20utm_content%3Dfx-monitor-twos-en

[marniepw]

And obvs, feel free to move to another repo wherever it best fits..

[vladikoff]

Thanks @pdehaan !

[pdehaan]

@vladikoff Sorry, you said transfer to mozilla/fxa-content-server, but I only saw the fxa monorepo in the GitHub issue transfer list. Feel free to rehome it if the monorepo isn't the correct place. ❤️

[vladikoff]

fxa is correct, sorry!

[clouserw]

@vladikoff - utm_campaign=fx-monitor-twos%20utm_content%3Dfx-monitor-twos-en

That is a weird looking string. We'd expect the %20 to be an ampersand, and %3D to be an equals sign. It looks like this is double encoded but also with a space instead of an ampersand?

@marniepw can you give us the URL that the blue button in the email went to?

@groovecoder can you give us the URL that "Sign in to continue to Firefox Monitor" would go to?

Thanks

[marniepw]

@clouserw - https://click.e.mozilla.org/?qs=a2d5dc25f44040ecdc4ab72f6878ceafe32c34e792b9cc211dc216386a7e5bbb56f13f50bea3e27960286c3b6144691d59e20e68d39028d0

[digitarald]

This happened to my wife as well, using her private email and account.

Her link shows the same broken params: https://accounts.firefox.com/reset_password?…&utm_source=email&utm_campaign=fx-monitor-twos%20utm_content%3Dfx-monitor-twos-en

[vladikoff]

@mozilla/fxa-devs should bump this in priority possibly. Also can amplitude tell us how many places are sending this utm campaign?

[vbudhram]

Looks like this is sending utm_campaign = fx-monitor-twos utm_content=fx-monitor-twos-en which is fails because auth-server and content-server don't accept = and symbols.

Ref:

fxa/packages/fxa-auth-server/lib/metrics/context.js

Line 20 in 1d44b3d

const UTM_SCHEMA = isA

[clouserw]

Since these urls bounce through the e.click domain the marketing team was able to fix these URLs, even for emails that were already sent. 👍 Thanks for filing this