What should the extension do when there is not a single price on a product page?

[sharonbautista]

I initially set an alert for the 400ml version of this watering can: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06X6FSJNP/ref=sspa_dk_detail_0?pd_rd_i=B06WRQPNJ4&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_p=a54d13fc-b8a1-4ce8-b285-d77489a09cf6&pf_rd_r=7MC0VQSVZZFDYAS9KBZ4&pd_rd_wg=PNtEh&pf_rd_s=desktop-dp-sims&pf_rd_t=40701&pd_rd_w=tKkis&pf_rd_i=desktop-dp-sims&pd_rd_r=586b96ae-ac7f-11e8-861c-cd06ea1130b1&th=1

I was able to create that 400ml watering can alert as expected. When I went to view the 900ml version of that watering can, the extension would not detect the page (900ml can is page being viewed; 400ml can is reflected in alert panel):

This instance raises a few questions:

• For products that have different varieties such as watering cans in different sizes with different prices, should people be able to set an alert for a specific size can? With dynamic pricing, do we know if prices for both sizes of watering can would fluctuate at the same time and same %?
• Since with the demo I can only create an alert for one size of watering can, will I get a notification of price change for any watering can sizes or just the size that I created the alert for?

[biancadanforth]

Thank you Sharon; you raise an important semantic and product question:

This page and others, like the Etsy page in #88 and the Macy's page and Walmart page in #79 do not represent a single product but a class of products with an often implicit range of prices.

• @javaun @bryanbell @sharonbautista , Conceptually, what should our add-on do when there is not a single price on the page? What should it do for the MVP?

From a technical point of view, we don't know how to determine what the correct price is, since pages like these violate our extension's assumption that there is a single product on a product page. We also wouldn't know how to update the prices in the background in many cases, since the URLs for sites like Etsy (example) may not change to reflect that the user selected a particular variation.

Edit: Going to rename this issue to be more reflective of the question it raises. Also related: #43 .

[javaun]

This is a super important conversation -- and why we need to be in Test Pilot. First, we can move this beyond the MVP and ship as-is. We'll get some helpful user feedback.

We can backlog this one for post-MVP and think about it in multiple contexts. This one straddles not just a large body of work that would fit under "fathom improvement" but also general UI improvements.

[brucko]

We likely can learn from other extensions like Honey how they handle some of these edge cases for guidance on how to handle. 

…

On Wed, Sep 19, 2018 at 2:06 PM, Javaun Moradi < ***@***.*** > wrote: This is a super important conversation -- and why we need to be in Test Pilot. First, we can move this beyond the MVP and ship as-is. We'll get some helpful user feedback. We can backlog this one for post-MVP and think about it in multiple contexts. This one straddles not just a large body of work that would fit under "fathom improvement" but also general UI improvements. — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub ( #86 (comment) ) , or mute the thread ( https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AJQPSC3vjxWdJ44xxKIV8Csbm4ImYMI6ks5ucrHDgaJpZM4WT-he ).