Using AzureAD authentication I cannot get the group members for the user that authenticates

[enribla]

NetBox version

v3.3.8

Python version

3.9

Steps to Reproduce

1. I authenticate using AzureAD with my user
2. I get authenticated
3. I check the user groups in admin with a superuser account
4. I don't see any group even if the user has several groups in AzureAD
5. I check in the user id_token in User social auths (inside the meny PYTHON SOCIAL AUTH) and I verify that I get the group id

Expected Behavior

The expected behaviour would be to see the member groups related to the user that is authenticated using AzureAD

Observed Behavior

No groups appeared related to the user.

My configurations related with authentication is:

REMOTE_AUTH_BACKEND = 'social_core.backends.azuread.AzureADOAuth2'

SOCIAL_AUTH_AZUREAD_OAUTH2_KEY = 'xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx'
SOCIAL_AUTH_AZUREAD_OAUTH2_SECRET = 'xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx'
SOCIAL_AUTH_REDIRECT_IS_HTTPS = True

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. NetBox is governed by a small group of core maintainers which means not all opened issues may receive direct feedback. Do not attempt to circumvent this process by "bumping" the issue; doing so will result in its immediate closure and you may be barred from participating in any future discussions. Please see our contributing guide.

[jeremystretch]

The expected behaviour would be to see the member groups related to the user that is authenticated using AzureAD

Neither the NetBox documentation nor the documentation for the upstream python-social-auth package suggests that this functionality exists. This should have been submitted as a feature request.

I'm marking this as needs owner for anyone who would like to dig into this, however some preliminary analysis suggests that the upstream Azure AD authentication backend would need to be extended to support group assignment.

[candlerb]

I tried to do it for Keycloak, and it broke things badly. Here's a potted history in case it helps.

In python-social-auth/social-core#668, in an attempt to be helpful I also picked up the "groups" claim and returned it in the user structure from all OIDC responses:

    def get_user_details(self, response):
        username_key = self.setting('USERNAME_KEY', default=self.USERNAME_KEY)
        return {
            'username': response.get(username_key),
            'email': response.get('email'),
            'fullname': response.get('name'),
            'first_name': response.get('given_name'),
            'last_name': response.get('family_name'),
            'groups': response.get('groups'),    # <<<<<<<<< returns a list of strings
        }

But it turns out that if you do this, Django barfs, and this change had to be rolled back: see python-social-auth/social-core#690 / python-social-auth/social-core#692

The actual error from Django is:

Direct assignment to the forward side of a many-to-many set is prohibited. Use groups.set() instead.

If you can work out where that's coming from, you may be able to fix this issue. There's a full backtrace at #8579 (comment)

[jeremystretch]

Thanks @candlerb, that's very helpful. I suspected that this sort of change would be necessary so it's nice to have that confirmed.

If you can work out where that's coming from, you may be able to fix this issue.

I assume that the dictionary of attributes returned by the backend is being applied to the user instance blindly. groups would cause an issue because it's a reverse manager (rather than a normal attribute). So I'm not sure how it's working (if it's working) for other backends as you pointed out here.

[CTV-2023]

Hi, just in case that helps, the workaround I found was not using AzureAD but SAML against AzureAD and store groups in SOCIAL_AUTH_SAML_EXTRA_DATA to use them with a custom pipeline. Might be considered as "dirty" (and the code far from perfect)
https://www.reddit.com/r/Netbox/comments/104ouqz/netbox_saml_with_azure_ad_authorization/

[jeremystretch]

There's now a feature request to implement this ability natively within python-social-auth: python-social-auth/social-core#794

[BBezaire]

Hi All,

I noticed PR #13373 was reverted.
Can we reopen this issue, or has discussion moved elsewhere?

[enribla]

Good morning,
If I understand correctly, this functionality has been reverted?
Is not possible to map azureAD groups with netbox groups? Or simply replicate the AzureAD groups on the netbox application?
Thanks