Permalink
Browse files

gemko comments

  • Loading branch information...
1 parent 98dd6e7 commit d36394741f923c244a7005fd4647803f659e6c66 Reini Urban committed May 24, 2012
Showing with 22 additions and 20 deletions.
  1. +18 −18 Cannes2012.sorted.html
  2. +4 −2 Cannes2012.txt
View
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@
<h1>All official sections</h1>
-<h2>Ratings for <b>Competition [6.09/19]</b></h2>
+<h2>Ratings for <b>Competition [6.11/19]</b></h2>
<pre>
1. "COSMOPOLIS" (David Cronenberg) [9.50/1 0.0]
2. "DO-NUI MAT (TASTE OF MONEY)" (Im Sangsoo) [8.80/1 0.0]
@@ -62,7 +62,7 @@
14. "THE ANGELS' SHARE" (Ken Loach) [5.09/35 1.5]
15. "LAWLESS" (John Hillcoat) [5.02/63 1.8]
16. <i>"JAGTEN (THE HUNT)" (Thomas Vinterberg)</i> [4.92/48 2.2]
-17. <i>"POST TENEBRAS LUX" (Carlos Reygadas)</i> [4.36/10 2.0]
+17. <i>"POST TENEBRAS LUX" (Carlos Reygadas)</i> [4.87/10 2.1]
18. "ON THE ROAD" (Walter Salles) [3.94/14 1.3]
19. "BAAD EL MAWKEAA (AFTER THE BATTLE)" (Yousry Nasrallah) [3.49/58 1.3]
"IN THE FOG" (Sergei Loznitsa) [-]
@@ -227,10 +227,10 @@
59. "YEK KHANÉVADÉH-E MOHTARAM (A RESPECTABLE FAMILY)" (Massoud Bakhshi) [4.95/4 1.3]
60. <b><i>"JAGTEN (THE HUNT)" (Thomas Vinterberg)</i></b> [4.92/58 2.2]
61. "GANGS OF WASSEYPUR" (Anurag Kashyap) [4.90/2 0.4]
-62. "DER MÜLL IM GARTEN EDEN (POLLUTING PARADISE)" (Fatih Akin) [4.76/12 1.1]
-63. "ADIEU BERTHE, L'ENTERREMENT DE MÉMÉ" (Bruno Podalydès) [4.60/3 0.4]
-64. "OPÉRATION LIBERTAD" (Nicolas Wadimoff) [4.50/2 0.5]
-65. <b><i>"POST TENEBRAS LUX" (Carlos Reygadas)</i></b> [4.36/10 2.0]
+62. <b><i>"POST TENEBRAS LUX" (Carlos Reygadas)</i></b> [4.87/11 2.1]
+63. "DER MÜLL IM GARTEN EDEN (POLLUTING PARADISE)" (Fatih Akin) [4.76/12 1.1]
+64. "ADIEU BERTHE, L'ENTERREMENT DE MÉMÉ" (Bruno Podalydès) [4.60/3 0.4]
+65. "OPÉRATION LIBERTAD" (Nicolas Wadimoff) [4.50/2 0.5]
66. "ANTIVIRAL" (Brandon Cronenberg) [4.36/32 1.6]
67. "J’ENRAGE DE SON ABSENCE" (Sandrine Bonnaire) [4.30/4 1.3]
68. <i>"LES CHEVAUX DE DIEU" (Nabil Ayouch)</i> [4.28/12 2.3]
@@ -260,7 +260,7 @@
"THE CENTRAL PARK FIVE" (Ken Burns, Sarah Burns y David McMahon) [-]
</pre>
-<h1>102/118 Critics</h1>
+<h1>101/118 Critics</h1>
<i>filter stddev >2.5 from avg</i>
stddev name (magazine, cn) numratings <i>±diff</i>
@@ -269,12 +269,11 @@
0.10 Don Simpson (Smells Like Screen Spirit, USA) 1 <i>-0.1</i>
0.11 David Edelstein (New York Magazine-Vulture, USA) 1 <i>+0.1</i>
0.11 Peter Debruge (Variety, USA) 1 <i>+0.1</i>
-0.44 Mike d'Angelo 4.8 - for now. If demystified, could be (, ) 1 <i>+0.4</i>
0.61 Olivier Père (Les Inrockuptibles, France) 1 <i>+0.6</i>
0.84 David Calhoun (The Out London, UK) 11 <i>-0.3</i>
0.86 Henry Barnes (Guardian, UK) 1 <i>+0.9</i>
0.91 Allan Hunter (Screen Daily, USA) 1 <i>+0.9</i>
-1.07 Mike d'Angelo (AV Club, USA) 23 <i>-0.1</i>
+1.05 Mike d'Angelo (AV Club, USA) 24 <i>-0.1</i>
1.10 Pamela Bienzobas (Mabuse, Chile) 3 <i>+0.3</i>
1.11 Pete Hammond (Boxoffice Magazine, USA) 1 <i>+1.1</i>
1.11 Todd McCarthy (The Hollywood Reporter, USA) 1 <i>+1.1</i>
@@ -288,25 +287,25 @@
1.20 Cristina Nord (Die Tageszeitung, Germany) 21 <i>-0.0</i>
1.24 Tim Robey (Daily Telegraph, England) 1 <i>+1.2</i>
1.27 David Gritten (The Telegraph, UK) 3 <i>+1.1</i>
+1.27 Diego Batlle (La Nación, OtrosCines, Argentina) 41 <i>+0.7</i>
1.27 Clementine Gallot (Cahiers du cinema, Cahiers du Cinema) 2 <i>+0.3</i>
-1.28 Xavi Serra (Ara, España) 21 <i>+0.4</i>
-1.28 Diego Batlle (La Nación, OtrosCines, Argentina) 41 <i>+0.8</i>
1.31 Catherine Shoard (Guardian, UK) 1 <i>-1.3</i>
-1.31 Javier H. Estrada (Caimán CDC, España) 41 <i>-0.3</i>
+1.33 Xavi Serra (Ara, España) 21 <i>+0.3</i>
1.33 Dana Linssen (De Filmkrant, Netherlands) 18 <i>+1.0</i>
+1.33 Javier H. Estrada (Caimán CDC, España) 41 <i>-0.3</i>
1.34 Alexandra Zawia (Wiener Zeitung, Furche, Celluloid, Austria) 28 <i>-0.2</i>
1.36 Aaron Hillis (GreenCine Daily, GreenCine Daily) 7 <i>+0.6</i>
1.37 Carlos F. Heredero (Cahiers du cinema Espana, Spain) 35 <i>+0.1</i>
1.38 Tim Grierson (Screen International, L.A. Weekly, USA) 2 <i>+1.3</i>
1.38 Andrew Schenker (Slant, USA) 2 <i>+1.2</i>
1.40 Gonzalo de Pedro (Caimán, CDC, España) 6 <i>+0.7</i>
+1.44 Philipp Engel (Go Mag, España) 19 <i>+0.9</i>
1.44 Diego Lerer (Clarín, Micropsia, Argentina) 37 <i>+0.5</i>
-1.45 Neil Young (Hollywood Reporter, Tribune, UK) 27 <i>-0.2</i>
1.45 Guy Lodge (Variety, InContention, South Africa/USA) 13 <i>+0.4</i>
-1.47 Philipp Engel (Go Mag, España) 19 <i>+0.9</i>
+1.47 Neil Young (Hollywood Reporter, Tribune, UK) 27 <i>-0.2</i>
1.48 Alex Vicente (Público, España) 18 <i>-0.3</i>
1.48 Eric Lavallée (Ioncinema.com, Canada) 9 <i>-1.1</i>
-1.48 Carlos Reviriego (elcultural.es y de Caiman. Cuadernos de cine, España) 32 <i>+0.1</i>
+1.50 Carlos Reviriego (elcultural.es y de Caiman. Cuadernos de cine, España) 32 <i>+0.1</i>
1.53 Patrick Z. McGavin (, Lightsensitive.typepad.com) 10 <i>+0.1</i>
1.53 Kong Rithdee (The Bangkok Post, Thailand) 3 <i>+1.3</i>
1.55 Clarence Tsui (South China Morning Post, Hong Kong) 10 <i>-0.5</i>
@@ -320,24 +319,24 @@
1.61 Fabien Lemercier (Cineeuropa.org, Belgium) 13 <i>+0.4</i>
1.65 Emanuel Levy (EmanuelLevy.com, USA) 9 <i>+0.7</i>
1.66 Blake Williams (Ioncinema.com, Canada) 16 <i>-0.2</i>
+1.67 Roger Alan Koza (La Voz del Interior, Con los ojos abiertos, Argentina) 26 <i>+0.9</i>
1.69 Violeta Kovacsics (, España) 20 <i>+0.1</i>
1.69 Jon Frosch (France 24, France 24) 9 <i>+0.0</i>
1.70 Arthur Mas (Independencia, France) 7 <i>+1.0</i>
-1.72 Roger Alan Koza (La Voz del Interior, Con los ojos abiertos, Argentina) 26 <i>+0.9</i>
1.72 Luciano Barisone (Duellanti/Panoramiche, Italy) 32 <i>-0.0</i>
1.74 Paola Casella (Europa, Italy) 14 <i>-0.1</i>
1.77 Anna Bielak (Smells Like Screen Spirit, Smells Like Screen Spirit) 5 <i>-0.7</i>
1.77 Fernando Ganzo (Lumiere, España) 19 <i>-0.9</i>
1.78 Arnaud schwartz (la Croix, France) 22 <i>-0.1</i>
-1.78 Jaime Pena (El Amante, España/Argentina) 36 <i>-0.4</i>
+1.79 Jaime Pena (El Amante, España/Argentina) 36 <i>-0.5</i>
1.83 José Luis de Lorenzo (A Sala Llena, Argentina) 31 <i>+0.3</i>
1.83 Robbie Collins (The Telegraph, UK) 2 <i>+1.7</i>
1.86 Manu Yáñez (Fotogramas, OtrosCines, España) 18 <i>+0.2</i>
1.89 Peter Bradshaw (Guardian, UK) 17 <i>+0.9</i>
1.89 Jean Roy (l'Humanite, France) 23 <i>-0.7</i>
1.89 Martial Pisani (Independencia, France) 8 <i>+0.5</i>
-1.90 Alejandro G. Calvo (Sensacine, España) 32 <i>-0.4</i>
1.90 Fernando Juan Lima (El Amante, Argentina) 29 <i>+0.9</i>
+1.91 Alejandro G. Calvo (Sensacine, España) 32 <i>-0.4</i>
1.96 Raffi Asdourian (The Film Stage, USA) 8 <i>+0.5</i>
1.97 Michael Ghennam (, Les Fiches du Cinéma) 4 <i>+0.1</i>
1.98 Robert Koehler (Variety, USA) 23 <i>-0.2</i>
@@ -383,6 +382,7 @@
3.39 <strike>Ruta Buciunaite (theupcoming.co.uk, UK)</strike> 6 <i>+2.6</i>
3.41 <strike>Eric Neuhoff (Le Figaro, France)</strike> 21 <i>-1.7</i>
4.23 <strike>Drew McWeeny (InContention, USA)</strike> 1 <i>-4.2</i>
+5.13 <strike> for now. If demystified, could be (, )</strike> 1 <i>+5.1</i>
</pre>
<pre>
--
View
@@ -1316,7 +1316,8 @@ Christophe Beney
David Calhoun
Per Juul Carlsen
Paola Casella
-Mike d'Angelo 4.8 - for now. If demystified, could be 84. Tho' the feeling of ultra-super-mega-pretentiousness might linger.
+Mike d'Angelo 4.8
+ for now. If demystified, could be 84. Tho' the feeling of ultra-super-mega-pretentiousness might linger.
#Carlos F. Heredero
Eric Lavallée
Fabien Lemercier
@@ -1687,7 +1688,8 @@ Jaime Pena 4.5
Javier H. Estrada 5
Neil Young 7
Other:
-Mike d'Angelo w/o This is an amazing year but UCR does seem kinda blah. Totally generic downtrodden-kid saga
+Mike d'Angelo
+ w/o This is an amazing year but UCR does seem kinda blah. Totally generic downtrodden-kid saga
Le film français:
Stéphanie Lamome
Arnaud schwartz

0 comments on commit d363947

Please sign in to comment.