feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional #414

dasanra · 2023-04-20T08:50:39Z

What it solves

Resolves #362

Features added

GasLimit optional in the relay-kit
Full Counterfactual deployment feature added to the relay-kit.
Improved usability of the relay-kit (no need to manually encode transactions by developers)

New Syntax

 
  // dump transfer as an example
  const dumpTransfer = {
    to: '0x123', // to address
    data: '0x',
    value: '1000000000000000' // 0.001 ETH
  }

  // batch to be executed by Gelato
  const transactions: MetaTransactionData[] = [
     dumpTransfer
  ]

  // we create the Gelato relay pack instance
  const relayPack = new GelatoRelayPack()

  // we create the relayed transaction
  const safeTransaction = await relayPack.createRelayedTransaction({ safe, transactions })

  // we sign the relayed transaction with all the owners
  const signedSafeTransaction = await signTransactionWithAllOwners(safe, safeTransaction)

  // we execute the relayed transaction with all the signatures
  const { taskId } = await relayPack.executeRelayTransaction(signedSafeTransaction, safe)

How this PR fixes it

Added Functions:

`Protocol-kit`

getEncodedTransaction in the protocol-kit: Returns the Safe Transaction encoded (as a string).
wrapSafeTransactionIntoDeploymentBatch in the protocol-kit: Wraps a Safe transaction into a Safe deployment batch.
createSafeDeploymentTransaction in the protocol-kit: Creates a Safe deployment transaction of the Safe.
createTransactionBatch in the protocol-kit: This function creates a batch transaction of the provided Safe transactions using the MultiSend contract.

estimation functions

estimateTxBaseGas: This function estimates the baseGas of a Safe transaction:
- Generation of the Safe transaction hash (txHash)
- Increasing the nonce of the Safe.
- Verifying the signatures of the Safe transaction
- Payment to relayers for executing the transaction
- Emitting events ExecutionSuccess or ExecutionFailure

Note: estimateTxBaseGas estimation does not include the transaction execution cost (safeTxGas)
Note: estimateTxBaseGas estimation does not include guards execution cost (Manual GasLimit required in this case)

estimateSafeTxGas: This function estimates the safeTxGas of a Safe transaction. The safeTxGas value represents the amount of gas required to execute the Safe transaction itself. The estimation method differs based on the version of the Safe:
- For versions >= 1.3.0, the simulate function defined in the simulateTxAccessor.sol Contract is used.
- For versions < 1.3.0, the deprecated requiredTxGas method defined in the GnosisSafe contract is used.
estimateSafeDeploymentGas: This function estimates the gas cost of deploying a Safe.

Detailed Summary

Basic Tests

Safe `1/1`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

Test 1: 1 Transfer in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0x14e55a35cb34fb6fbf6f36c16ba320496877041d4c5b67f84b1c75f435aa9f8e

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
47904 gas	35163 gas	26,59%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
9.006 gas	8.771 gas	2,6%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
206.910 gas	183.194 gas	11,46%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.000630 ETH	0.00042404 ETH	32,69%

Links

Screenshots

Test 2: 1 Contract Interaction in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0x70115d1489133d4994ac6eebfbc80b82eab2455e8fa42102c1a6ed5f2b59aa7d

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
48.032 gas	35.424 gas	26,24%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
396.499 gas	396.258 gas	0,06%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
594.531 gas	571.502 gas	3,8%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.002834 ETH	0.0025333 ETH	10,62%

Links

Screenshots

Test 3: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0x9fb36e0560834834f2c1148aed7526f18e8f96e61a477fffcf3f3271aff5558a

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
53.624 gas	42.005 gas	21,66%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1.222.793 gas	1.222.407 gas	0,031%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1.426.417 gas	1.420.444 gas	0,41%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.6804 ETH	0.5555 ETH	18,35%

Links

Screenshots

Safe `2/3`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

Test 4: 1 Transfer in Goerli chain with a Safe 2/3 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0xd71a3c9b59f01bc758c2d50d230d8587fbb677f2a5b3898bf26676baf68ab43d.

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
54.944 Gas	41.844 Gas	23,84%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
9.006 Gas	8.771 Gas	2,6%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
213.950 Gas	191.771 Gas	10,39%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.000005824 ETH	0.00000463 ETH	20,44%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 15 40 26

Test 5: 1 Contract Interaction in Goerli chain with a Safe 2/3 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0x3c10b488dd44c7716825f4938b3f3c30bac1d7dc7406b48d57863edaf073c388.

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
55.072 gas	42.105 gas	23,54%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
396.499 gas	396.258 Gas	0,06%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
601.571 gas	580.083 Gas	3,57%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.00001339 ETH	0.000009951 ETH	25,69%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 15 45 47

Test 6: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions in Goerli chain with a Safe 2/3 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0xdca18d1e9a92f1076fbdd1c2bd3570a26e4f958be10caea55b3bd4f6c6d73437

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
60.664 gas	48.686 gas	19,74%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1.222.793 gas	1.222.407 Gas	0,031%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1.433.457 gas	1.429.007 Gas	0,31%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.00000783 ETH	0.0000060463 ETH	22,86%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 16 02 42

Counterfactual deployment feature

Safe `1/1`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

Test 7: 1 Transfer & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0xc26bf2b11820be139fa1d07b173e1970dd1a0ad323ebd002dad8c370edfcaa6f

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
62904	48263	23,27%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
9677	9442 Gas	2,42%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
261547	234.592 Gas	10,30%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
484128	446.355 Gas	7,80%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.000000536 ETH	0.000000431 ETH	19,58%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 16 25 06

Test 8: 1 Contract Interaction & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0x20008d1b370f3525ae315d2411a9068495e4ae24f6cfadb0b7391fff8a554f29

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
63.032 gas	48.524 gas	23,01%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
413.599 gas	413.358 Gas	0,058%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
261547	234.592 Gas	10,30%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
888.178 gas	851.157 Gas	4,16%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.0000009526 ETH	0.0000005810 ETH	39%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 16 40 13

Test 9: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 1/1 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0x6df17fa801efe102d574fd6d92a7d823d5b90e2515bdf39eacfd41104c27dd4d

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
68.624 gas	55.105 gas	19,7%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1.233.248 gas	1.232.862 Gas	0,031%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
261.547 gas	234.592 Gas	10,30%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1713419	1.693.588 Gas	4,30%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.000001549 ETH	0.000001275 ETH	17,68%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 16 51 54

Safe `5/7`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

Test 10: 1 Transfer & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0x2a24c3574cb6127d1c63b00ffe43c68a6d70a1ead9703234f1f4befef05ec947

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
91064	66985	26,44%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
9677	9442 Gas	2,42%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
406815	373.242 Gas	8,25%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
657556	616.276 Gas	6,27%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.000000605 ETH	0.000000407 ETH	32,72%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 17 27 39

Test 11: 1 Contract interaction & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0xa39fd07b22286cccae2365308091064a3468ccf0c77cb51b02d8d9c0b7ddeede

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
91192	67246	26,25%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
413599	413.358 Gas	0,058%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
406815	373.242 Gas	8,25%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1061606	1.021.027 Gas	3,82%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.00000123 ETH	0.000000900 ETH	26,82%

Links

Screenshots

Test 12: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions & Counterfactual deployment in Goerli chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0xf3c1d9723965763c058df5af7f9e09192b0a5f35c758b04af7b45403c37549d7

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
96784	73828	23,71%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1233248	1232862 Gas	0,03%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
406815	373.242 Gas	8,25%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1886847	1.863.528 Gas	1,23%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.00000172 ETH	0.00000123 ETH	28,48%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 17 10 35

Production chains

`Gnosis` chain

Test 13: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions & Counterfactual deployment in Gnosis chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0xec3b28b7ce9535a6197cb0aa120f9056f0cb88b1dec517218b7219c68299a52c

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
96784	73828	23,71%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1233248	1.232.862 Gas	0,031%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
418258	373.208 Gas	10,77%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1898290	1.863.506 Gas	1,83%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.003107 xDAI	0.002378 xDAI	23,46%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 18 31 22

Test 14: a batch of 5 Transfers & 3 contract interactions in Gnosis chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0x5015a04d41eadf85b4379fb2bd9342a1126c28d3dac779760a963d4eb92de03b

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
53504	42005	21,49%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1222781	1222407	0,03%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
1426285	1.420.256 Gas	0,42%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.002916 xDAI	0.002385 xDAI	18,20%

Links

Screenshots

`Polygon` chain

Test 15: 1 Transfer deployment in Gnosis chain with a Safe 2/3 v1.3.0 (already deployed)

Transaction hash: 0xa630476c12e54ed409fed1c61273584d20fc760294ac4be10ab29faa09886a0b

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
54932	40844	25,64%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
9006	8771	2,60%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
0	0	0%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
213938	191.767 Gas	10,36%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.025112 MATIC	0.02077 MATIC	17,28%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 19 34 25

Test 16: a batch of 3 Transfers & 1 Contract Interaction & Counterfactual deployment in Polygon chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0xb7149eaf7601ed3a22beceb89c59da7f4554a345f7bfd451daaad63d55f29bd7

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
94104	70821	24,74%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
56079	55.760 Gas	0,56%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
406781	373.208 Gas	8,25%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
706964	675.740 Gas	4,41%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.1130 MATIC	0.0741 MATIC	34,424%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 19 48 19

Test 17: 5 Transfers & 3 Contract Interactions & Counterfactual deployment in Polygon chain with a Safe 5/7 v1.3.0

Transaction hash: 0x99cb0f5ab0362a7f09bba067a2c6815b60aa33f397fea3ecde778707f5051906

`BaseGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
96724	73838	23,66%

`SafeTxGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
78911	78.525 Gas	0,48%

`DeploymentGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
406781	373.208 Gas	8,25%

`TotalGas`

Estimated	Real	Difference (%)
732416	709.099 Gas	3,18%

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Gelato Payment	Transaction Fee Cost	Difference (%)
0.0955 MATIC	0.0784 MATIC	17,90%

Links

Screenshots

Captura de pantalla 2023-07-09 a las 20 19 05

Formula used to calculate the difference estimated vs real

( (Estimated - Real) / Estimated ) * 100 = X %

…oyment

coveralls · 2023-07-12T12:07:20Z

Pull Request Test Coverage Report for Build 5668577336

24 of 44 (54.55%) changed or added relevant lines in 1 file are covered.
2 unchanged lines in 1 file lost coverage.
Overall coverage decreased (-2.3%) to 72.651%

Changes Missing Coverage	Covered Lines	Changed/Added Lines	%
packages/relay-kit/src/packs/gelato/GelatoRelayPack.ts	24	44	54.55%

Files with Coverage Reduction	New Missed Lines	%
packages/relay-kit/src/packs/gelato/GelatoRelayPack.ts	2	67.96%

Totals
Change from base Build 5542834488:	-2.3%
Covered Lines:	416
Relevant Lines:	530

💛 - Coveralls

packages/protocol-kit/src/Safe.ts

packages/protocol-kit/src/utils/transactions/gas.ts

packages/relay-kit/src/packs/gelato/GelatoRelayPack.ts

dasanra · 2023-07-18T11:58:15Z

packages/safe-core-sdk-types/src/types.ts

+  nonce?: number
+}
+
+export interface MultiSendTransaction {


This is MetaTransactionData at line 21

packages/safe-core-sdk-types/src/types.ts

dasanra · 2023-07-31T11:26:40Z

packages/protocol-kit/src/managers/contractManager.ts

    } else {
-      const temporarySafeContract = await getSafeContract({
+      // We use the lastest version of the Safe contract to get the correct version of this Safe
+      const latestVersionOfTheSafeContract = await getSafeContract({


I was thinking that this variable name may not be accurate, as the DEFAULT_SAFE_VERSION may not be the latest.

I would rename it to defaultSafeContractInstance

dasanra added 16 commits April 17, 2023 13:02

create first experimental base gas

74aed4e

Type uint256 using strings

1a3e579

fix tests

be68c5b

keep nonce as number

1c91559

fix tests

852ee99

fix tests

87d00f7

fix tests

30b0a07

Remove unused toString()

d44f536

rollback bignumberish to number | string to increase web3 compatibility

eac95b7

update response transaction types

c64b316

Merge branch 'development' into type-string-uint256

84f0a4c

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

db801bd

Merge branch 'development' into type-string-uint256

7c10192

chore test naming

83d6583

Merge branch 'type-string-uint256' into make-gas-limit-optional

bddddd8

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

aafc1cd

dasanra changed the base branch from main to development April 20, 2023 08:50

revert type regression

68007e2

germartinez changed the title ~~feature(relay-kit): make gas limit optional~~ feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional May 29, 2023

DaniSomoza added 2 commits May 31, 2023 12:13

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

6861140

Add singleton to encode execTransaction data

003d9fe

germartinez assigned DaniSomoza Jun 26, 2023

DaniSomoza added 5 commits July 3, 2023 12:06

Added GasLimit as optional and compatible with the conterfactual depl…

640d49c

…oyment

Added onlyCalls prop in createTransaction in the relay-kit

5ca0761

Add SimulateTxAccessor Contract

3670bc1

Add estimateSafeTxGasWithSimulate function

06d21d2

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

e86fdf6

DaniSomoza and others added 2 commits July 12, 2023 23:18

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

25184f6

Update safe-deployment v1.26.0

025e73d

germartinez and others added 9 commits July 13, 2023 10:56

Add new networks

60966bb

Update yarn.lock

8b5277a

Fix yarn.lock

b3ed718

Merge branch 'safe-deployments-1_26_0' into make-gas-limit-optional

7e5adf6

Add decodeSafeTxGas function

bd51056

Set default Safe version to 1.3.0

4199edb

Update default version in READMEs

94fcfb4

Merge branch 'default_1_3_0' into make-gas-limit-optional

1801f06

Merge branch 'development' into make-gas-limit-optional

9202697

yagopv reviewed Jul 17, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/protocol-kit/src/Safe.ts Show resolved Hide resolved

yagopv reviewed Jul 17, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/protocol-kit/src/Safe.ts Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

yagopv reviewed Jul 17, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/protocol-kit/src/Safe.ts Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

yagopv reviewed Jul 18, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/protocol-kit/src/utils/transactions/gas.ts Show resolved Hide resolved

dasanra commented Jul 18, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/relay-kit/src/packs/gelato/GelatoRelayPack.ts Show resolved Hide resolved

dasanra commented Jul 18, 2023

View reviewed changes

packages/safe-core-sdk-types/src/types.ts Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

DaniSomoza added 7 commits July 19, 2023 02:29

Add options to executeRelayTransaction

729e324

Add to the safeTxGas estimation a security margin factor

ff343e4

Add check token selected for gas payment is compatible

60d5c16

restores SimulateTxAccessorContract files

b175a64

fix relay-kit tests

26692ea

Add parseSafeTxGasErrorResponse util function

eb262f0

Add custom contracts

b040b64

DaniSomoza marked this pull request as ready for review July 26, 2023 12:19

yagopv approved these changes Jul 26, 2023

View reviewed changes

dasanra commented Jul 31, 2023

View reviewed changes

dasanra mentioned this pull request Aug 1, 2023

feat(relay-kit): Add separate ERC20 transfer for fee payment with non-standard ERC20 tokens #496

Merged

dasanra merged commit 5b5fff3 into development Aug 1, 2023
14 of 15 checks passed

dasanra deleted the make-gas-limit-optional branch August 1, 2023 14:45

github-actions bot locked and limited conversation to collaborators Aug 1, 2023

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional #414

feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional #414

dasanra commented Apr 20, 2023 •

edited by DaniSomoza

coveralls commented Jul 12, 2023 •

edited

dasanra Jul 18, 2023

DaniSomoza Jul 19, 2023

dasanra Jul 31, 2023

feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional #414

feat(relay-kit): make gas limit optional #414

Conversation

dasanra commented Apr 20, 2023 • edited by DaniSomoza

What it solves

Features added

How this PR fixes it

Protocol-kit

estimation functions

Detailed Summary

Basic Tests

Safe 1/1, v1.3.0 Goerli chain

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

Safe 2/3, v1.3.0 Goerli chain

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

Counterfactual deployment feature

Safe 1/1, v1.3.0 Goerli chain

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

BaseGas

SafeTxGas

DeploymentGas

TotalGas

Gelato payment vs Transaction fee cost

Links

Screenshots

Safe 5/7, v1.3.0 Goerli chain

BaseGas

dasanra commented Apr 20, 2023 •

edited by DaniSomoza

`Protocol-kit`

Safe `1/1`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

Safe `2/3`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

Safe `1/1`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

Safe `5/7`, `v1.3.0` `Goerli` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`Gnosis` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`Polygon` chain

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

`BaseGas`

`SafeTxGas`

`DeploymentGas`

`TotalGas`

coveralls commented Jul 12, 2023 •

edited