no vacabulary defintion for CoAP and MQTT yet

[sebastiankb]

in section section 3.3 we should clarify that CoAP and MQTT has no standardized RDF representation yet like for http

[egekorkan]

it is fixed now, @sebastiankb could you review it and close it if it is OK

[takuki]

In TD spec, vocabulary terms are listed in tables with columns "Description", "Assignment" and "Type".

The columns used in section 4 Vocabulary are different.
In particular, "Mandatory" used in this document should be changed to "Assignment" as used in TD spec.

Protocol Vocabulary are considered extension to TD vocabulary, therefore, should be described in a consistent way.

I plan to create another issue for this.
(Please go ahead to close this)

[sebastiankb]

thanks @takuki, this was also my first thought. The presentation of the tables should be similar as you can find in the TD spec. I think, the tables are quite clear in understanding what have to be used.

@egekorkan where does the MQTT codeNumbers (3, 8, and 10) come from?

[egekorkan]

I will rearrange the vocabularies as @takuki and @sebastiankb mentinoed.

@egekorkan where does the MQTT codeNumbers (3, 8, and 10) come from?

They come from the MQTT specification. All the possible values are documented here

[sebastiankb]

They come from the MQTT specification. All the possible values are documented here

To increase the MQTT recognition I would prefer to rely on the same term usage as you can find in the MQTT specification. That means I would prefer to use the term controlPacketTypeValue or short controlPacketValue instead commandCode.

[takuki]

The table in Section 4.3.3 MQTT Vocabulary, there is a row describing mqv:options member.

The example used in mqv:options is quoted below.

[ { "cov:optionNumber": 6, "cov:optionValue": 49 } ]

I think the above example was copied from coap section.
It should use mqv prefix instead of cov prefix.

[egekorkan]

@mjkoster could you comment why the term commandCode was chosen in the beginning and also why the integer values were used instead of the English words, i.e. why 8 instead of SUBSCRIBE?

[egekorkan]

I think that this issue has two different issues in it, both that don't match the title. I have created issues #72 and #73 .
Additionally, mqv:options is fixed in PR #71