Fix bugs in reader releasing algorithm

As illustrated by the new tests, there were previously issues around auto-releasing not always giving the right result for errored or closed streams, especially with regard to allowing future readers to be acquired. This commit simplifies the logic and ensures consistency across all readers obtained from errored or closed streams.

index.bs

@@ -539,7 +539,17 @@ Instances of <code>ReadableStreamReader</code> are created with the internal slo
   <tr>
     <td>\[[readRequests]]
     <td>A List of promises returned by calls to the reader's <code>read()</code> method that have not yet been resolved,
-      due to the <a>consumer</a> requesting <a>chunks</a> sooner than they are available.
+      due to the <a>consumer</a> requesting <a>chunks</a> sooner than they are available
+  </tr>
+  <tr>
+    <td>\[[state]]
+    <td>A string containing the reader's current state, used internally; one of <code>"readable"</code>,
+      <code>"closed"</code>, or <code>"errored"</code>
+  </tr>
+  <tr>
+    <td>\[[storedError]]
+    <td>A value indicating how the reader's stream failed, to be given as a failure reason or exception when trying to
+      operate on the reader; applicable only when \[[state]] is <code>"errored"</code>
   </tr>
 </table>
 
@@ -556,12 +566,12 @@ Instances of <code>ReadableStreamReader</code> are created with the internal slo
   <li> If IsReadableStreamLocked(<var>stream</var>) is <b>true</b>, throw a <b>TypeError</b> exception.
   <li> Set <var>stream</var>@\[[reader]] to <b>this</b>.
   <li> Set <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]] to <var>stream</var>.
+  <li> Set <b>this</b>@\[[state]] to <code>"readable"</code>.
+  <li> Set <b>this</b>@\[[storedError]] to <b>undefined</b>.
   <li> Set <b>this</b>@\[[readRequests]] to a new empty List.
   <li> Set <b>this</b>@\[[closedPromise]] to a new promise.
-  <li> If <var>stream</var>@\[[state]] is <code>"closed"</code>, resolve <b>this</b>@\[[closedPromise]] with
-    <b>undefined</b>.
-  <li> If <var>stream</var>@\[[state]] is <code>"errored"</code>, reject <b>this</b>@\[[closedPromise]] with
-    <var>stream</bar>@\[[storedError]].
+  <li> If <var>stream</var>@\[[state]] is <code>"closed"</code> or <code>"errored"</code>, call-with-rethrow
+    ReleaseReadableStreamReader(<b>this</b>).
 </ol>
 
 <h4 id="reader-prototype">Properties of the <code>ReadableStreamReader</code> Prototype</h4>
@@ -614,11 +624,12 @@ Instances of <code>ReadableStreamReader</code> are created with the internal slo
 
 <ol>
   <li> If IsReadableStreamReader(<b>this</b>) is <b>false</b>, throw a <b>TypeError</b> exception.
-  <li> If <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]] is <b>undefined</b> or
-    <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[state]] is <code>"closed"</code>, return a new promise resolved with
+  <li> If <b>this</b>@\[[state]] is <code>"closed"</code>, return a new promise resolved with
     CreateIterResultObject(<b>undefined</b>, <b>true</b>).
-  <li> If <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[state]] is <code>"errored"</code>, return a new promise
-    rejected with <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[storedError]].
+  <li> If <b>this</b>@\[[state]] is <code>"errored"</code>, return a new promise rejected with
+    <b>this</b>@\[[storedError]].
+  <li> Assert: <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]] is not <b>undefined</b>.
+  <li> Assert: <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[state]] is <code>"readable"</code>.
   <li> If <b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[queue]] is not empty,
     <ol>
       <li> Let <var>chunk</var> be DequeueValue(<b>this</b>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[queue]]).
@@ -820,16 +831,8 @@ a variable <var>stream</var>, that performs the following steps:
   <li> Let <var>stream</var>@\[[queue]] be a new empty List.
   <li> Set <var>stream</var>@\[[storedError]] to <var>e</var>.
   <li> Set <var>stream</var>@\[[state]] to <code>"errored"</code>.
-  <li> If IsReadableStreamLocked(<var>stream</var>) is <b>true</b>,
-    <ol>
-      <li> Reject <var>stream</var>@\[[reader]]@\[[closedPromise]] with <var>e</var>.
-      <li> Repeat for each <var>readRequestPromise</var> that is an element of
-        <var>stream</var>@\[[reader]]@\[[readRequests]],
-        <ol>
-          <li> Reject <var>readRequestPromise</var> with <var>e</var>.
-        </ol>
-      <li> Set <var>stream</var>@\[[reader]]@\[[readRequests]] to a new empty List.
-    </ol>
+  <li> If IsReadableStreamLocked(<var>stream</var>) is <b>true</b>, return
+    ReleaseReadableStreamReader(<var>stream</var>@\[[reader]]).
 </ol>
 
 <h4 id="is-readable-stream">IsReadableStream ( x )</h4>
@@ -865,14 +868,29 @@ a variable <var>stream</var>, that performs the following steps:
 
 <ol>
   <li> Assert: <var>reader</var>@\[[ownerReadableStream]] is not <b>undefined</b>.
-  <li> Repeat for each <var>readRequestPromise</var> that is an element of <var>reader</var>@\[[readRequests]],
+  <li> If <var>reader</var>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[state]] is <code>"errored"</code>,
     <ol>
-      <li> Resolve <var>readRequestPromise</var> with CreateIterResultObject(<b>undefined</b>, <b>true</b>).
+      <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[state]] to <code>"errored"</code>.
+      <li> Let <var>e</var> be <var>reader</var>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[storedError]].
+      <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[storedError]] to <var>e</var>.
+      <li> Reject <var>reader</var>@\[[closedPromise]] with <var>e</var>.
+      <li> Repeat for each <var>readRequestPromise</var> that is an element of <var>reader</var>@\[[readRequests]],
+        <ol>
+          <li> Reject <var>readRequestPromise</var> with <var>e</var>.
+        </ol>
+    </ol>
+  <li> Otherwise,
+    <ol>
+      <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[state]] to <code>"closed"</code>.
+      <li> Resolve <var>reader</var>@\[[closedPromise]] with <b>undefined</b>.
+      <li> Repeat for each <var>readRequestPromise</var> that is an element of <var>reader</var>@\[[readRequests]],
+        <ol>
+          <li> Resolve <var>readRequestPromise</var> with CreateIterResultObject(<b>undefined</b>, <b>true</b>).
+        </ol>
     </ol>
   <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[readRequests]] to a new empty List.
   <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[ownerReadableStream]]@\[[reader]] to <b>undefined</b>.
   <li> Set <var>reader</var>@\[[ownerReadableStream]] to <b>undefined</b>.
-  <li> Resolve <var>reader</var>@\[[closedPromise]] with <b>undefined</b>.
 </ol>
 
 <h4 id="should-readable-stream-apply-backpressure">ShouldReadableStreamApplyBackpressure ( stream )</h4>

reference-implementation/lib/readable-stream.js

@@ -154,6 +154,8 @@ class ReadableStreamReader {
 
     stream._reader = this;
     this._ownerReadableStream = stream;
+    this._state = 'readable';
+    this._storedError = undefined;
 
     this._readRequests = [];
 
@@ -162,12 +164,8 @@ class ReadableStreamReader {
       this._closedPromise_reject = reject;
     });
 
-    if (stream._state === 'closed') {
-      this._closedPromise_resolve(undefined);
-    }
-
-    if (stream._state === 'errored') {
-      this._closedPromise_reject(stream._storedError);
+    if (stream._state === 'closed' || stream._state === 'errored') {
+      ReleaseReadableStreamReader(this);
     }
   }
 
@@ -199,14 +197,17 @@ class ReadableStreamReader {
         new TypeError('ReadableStreamReader.prototype.read can only be used on a ReadableStreamReader'));
     }
 
-    if (this._ownerReadableStream === undefined || this._ownerReadableStream._state === 'closed') {
+    if (this._state === 'closed') {
       return Promise.resolve(CreateIterResultObject(undefined, true));
     }
 
-    if (this._ownerReadableStream._state === 'errored') {
-      return Promise.reject(this._ownerReadableStream._storedError);
+    if (this._state === 'errored') {
+      return Promise.reject(this._storedError);
     }
 
+    assert(this._ownerReadableStream !== undefined);
+    assert(this._ownerReadableStream._state === 'readable');
+
     if (this._ownerReadableStream._queue.length > 0) {
       const chunk = DequeueValue(this._ownerReadableStream._queue);
 
@@ -242,7 +243,7 @@ class ReadableStreamReader {
       throw new TypeError('Tried to release a reader lock when that reader has pending read() calls un-settled');
     }
 
-    ReleaseReadableStreamReader(this);
+    return ReleaseReadableStreamReader(this);
   }
 }
 
@@ -387,12 +388,7 @@ function CreateReadableStreamErrorFunction(stream) {
     stream._state = 'errored';
 
     if (IsReadableStreamLocked(stream) === true) {
-      stream._reader._closedPromise_reject(e);
-
-      for (const { _reject } of stream._reader._readRequests) {
-        _reject(e);
-      }
-      stream._reader._readRequests = [];
+      return ReleaseReadableStreamReader(stream._reader);
     }
   };
 }
@@ -432,14 +428,30 @@ function IsReadableStreamReader(x) {
 }
 
 function ReleaseReadableStreamReader(reader) {
-  for (const { _resolve } of reader._readRequests) {
-    _resolve(CreateIterResultObject(undefined, true));
+  assert(reader._ownerReadableStream !== undefined);
+
+  if (reader._ownerReadableStream._state === 'errored') {
+    reader._state = 'errored';
+
+    const e = reader._ownerReadableStream._storedError;
+    reader._storedError = e;
+    reader._closedPromise_reject(e);
+
+    for (const { _reject } of reader._readRequests) {
+      _reject(e);
+    }
+  } else {
+    reader._state = 'closed';
+    reader._closedPromise_resolve(undefined);
+
+    for (const { _resolve } of reader._readRequests) {
+      _resolve(CreateIterResultObject(undefined, true));
+    }
   }
-  reader._readRequests = [];
 
+  reader._readRequests = [];
   reader._ownerReadableStream._reader = undefined;
   reader._ownerReadableStream = undefined;
-  reader._closedPromise_resolve(undefined);
 }
 
 function ShouldReadableStreamApplyBackpressure(stream) {

reference-implementation/test/readable-stream-reader.js

@@ -198,3 +198,37 @@ test('cancel() on a released reader is a no-op and does not pass through', t =>
 
   setTimeout(() => t.end(), 50);
 });
+
+test('Getting a second reader after erroring the stream should succeed', t => {
+  t.plan(5);
+
+  let doError;
+  const theError = new Error('bad');
+  const rs = new ReadableStream({
+    start(enqueue, close, error) {
+      doError = error;
+    }
+  });
+
+  const reader1 = rs.getReader();
+
+  reader1.closed.catch(e => {
+    t.equal(e, theError, 'the first reader closed getter should be rejected with the error');
+  });
+
+  reader1.read().catch(e => {
+    t.equal(e, theError, 'the first reader read() should be rejected with the error');
+  });
+
+  t.throws(() => rs.getReader(), /TypeError/, 'trying to get another reader before erroring should throw');
+
+  doError(theError);
+
+  rs.getReader().closed.catch(e => {
+    t.equal(e, theError, 'the second reader closed getter should be rejected with the error');
+  });
+
+  rs.getReader().read().catch(e => {
+    t.equal(e, theError, 'the third reader read() should be rejected with the error');
+  });
+});

reference-implementation/test/templated/readable-stream-closed.js

@@ -47,10 +47,21 @@ export default (label, factory) => {
     startPromise.then(() => {
       t.equal(ws.state, 'writable', 'writable stream should start in writable state');
 
-      rs.pipeTo(ws).then(() => {
+      return rs.pipeTo(ws).then(() => {
         t.pass('pipeTo promise should be fulfilled');
         t.equal(ws.state, 'closed', 'writable stream should become closed');
       });
-    });
+    })
+    .catch(e => t.error(e));
+  });
+
+  test('should be able to acquire multiple readers, since they are all auto-released', t => {
+    const rs = factory();
+
+    rs.getReader();
+
+    t.doesNotThrow(() => rs.getReader(), 'getting a second reader should not throw');
+    t.doesNotThrow(() => rs.getReader(), 'getting a third reader should not throw');
+    t.end();
   });
 };

reference-implementation/test/templated/readable-stream-errored-sync-only.js

@@ -16,4 +16,14 @@ export default (label, factory, error) => {
     cancelPromise2.catch(e => t.equal(e, error, 'second cancel() call should reject with the error'));
     t.notEqual(cancelPromise1, cancelPromise2, 'cancel() calls should return distinct promises');
   });
+
+  test('should be able to acquire multiple readers, since they are all auto-released', t => {
+    const rs = factory();
+
+    rs.getReader();
+
+    t.doesNotThrow(() => rs.getReader(), 'getting a second reader should not throw');
+    t.doesNotThrow(() => rs.getReader(), 'getting a third reader should not throw');
+    t.end();
+  });
 };