--no-git-tag-version option disables creation of a commit

[JakubRimal]

Bug description

It says that it disables creation of a git tag but in fact it disables the whole commit. There should probably be another option to disable the whole commit (e.g. --no-git-commit) and this option should disable only creation of a tag.

Command

yarn version --no-git-tag-version --patch

What is the current behavior?
It only increases the patch number in package.json.

What is the expected behavior?
It should increase the patch number in package.json and create a commit (without adding a tag).

Steps to Reproduce

1. run yarn version --no-git-tag-version --patch
2. check git log

Environment

• Node Version: v10.20.1
• Yarn v1 Version: 1.22.4
• OS and version: Linux Mint 19.3 Cinnamon

[dparker2]

👍 I spent much of yesterday wondering why our CI was not pushing the updated package.json, when in fact nothing was being committed at all! I needed the --no-git-tag-version flag because the GitHub release had already made the tag, but I didn't expect all git interactions to be disabled because of that flag.

[tony]

What's the command to disable this permanently in the repo? Isn't there a command to set the .yarn config in the project so it doesn't clobber the git tags? This instantly breaks most monorepos.

[lvndry]

Any follow up on this ?

[zeabdelkhalek]

+1

[sarkstephan]

+1

[ilfa]

+1

[Marvbudd]

Somewhat related: What is the proper workflow for updating version in an electron-build two package.json setup as described here https://www.electron.build/tutorials/two-package-structure. Should yarn automatically update the versions of all package.json files, or should the first one be updated by yarn without commit, then the manual update of the second one, and a final commit with the proper version message? Kinda complicated.