Roma (Roma2, at least) fails to generate Schematron properly

[sydb]

1. Roma still gives users the opportunity to download “Schematron” as opposed to “ISO Schematron”. But we have not supported Schematron 1.x for years; the Schematron 1.5 extracted from the Guidelines by Roma is an empty file. (Well, it has an <sch:title>, but no rules.)

2. Roma2, our “temporary” replacement for the standard Roma install, is not correctly generating ISO Schematron from a customization file, whether that customization is uploaded or one of the pre-loads. The output looks like a Java error, and is not even well-formed XML. (Due to 2 XML declarations; the 2nd one gets interpreted as a PI that is not allowed to start with “xml”.) I have no idea whether this problem is part of the ADHO server failure issue set (see TEI Website's not working #1855), or would occur with any installation of Roma or not. The error file is attached as tei_drama_schematron_error.txt. This error brought to my attention by Melanie Demmer.

3. Roma does not list tei_simplePrint or tei_customization as possible starting points.

tei_drama_schematron_error.txt

[peterstadler]

Hi @sydb, that's several issues not necessarily connected, right?

Second, 1) and 3) are Roma issues and should be moved there -- but, since they are more or less cosmetic I think I'd label them as "wont fix" as RomaJS is about to take over.

issue 2) is probably a Stylesheets issue or an OxGarage issue, since Roma delegates the processing of all output formats to OxGarage.

[peterstadler]

NB, there are also schematron related issues at TEIC/Stylesheets#368 and TEIC/TEIGarage#28

[sydb]

Note: leaving this ticket unassigned, because @peterstadler is correct, it should at least be moved elswhere (and assigned there), if not split up, too.

[raffazizzi]

@sydb would you be able to recreate the issues as @peterstadler described in the respective repositories? Then we can close this issue

[sydb]

(1) and (3) re-created in Roma repo; (2) is no longer a problem.