Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 31 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
Block category icons are distracting #14180
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
#10651 added support for category icons in the Block Inserter. For example:
When I'm searching for a block, my eye is instantly drawn away from the names of all the block categories, and to the green Jetpack logo, because it stands out far more than anything else. This pulls my eye away from the information that I need in order to complete my task, and towards information that is not useful.
At best, it makes things look a little nicer without any functional benefit to users.
At worst, it creates a race-to-the-bottom where every plugin competes for the user's attention by adding their own brightly-colored logos. At that point, the Inserter will look cluttered, garish, and visually inconsistent.
Describe the solution you'd like
I think the ideal solution is to remove support for these icons, because they hurt UX and serve no functional purpose.
Describe alternatives you've considered
As a compromise, forcing the icons to be black-and-white would remove the worst parts while preserving the ability to have icons.
We had a discussion about this in today's ticket triage on the design channel. I do agree that adding coloured icons distract and can end up in a competition of brands. This can lead to cognitive overload for users. Therefore I endorse removing support for these icons.
I agree I think the ideal solution is to remove support for these icons, because they hurt UX and serve no functional purpose.
The use of colour often means these icons are the most prominent item on the page. This isn't necessarily helpful unless that panel is what the user is looking for at the time, which won't always be the case. (I'd also agree with @boemedia that we might want to consider how colour is used in branded icons elsewhere, but that's probably worth discussing as a separate ticket.)
Since there won't always be icons for every panel, it also creates a mismatch in the overall weight of these headings, making it harder to parse them as equal elements.
The potential value here in making the distinction between panels more clear isn't sufficient to warrant the additional noise and cognitive load created by adding the icons. I'd be on board with removing them entirely.