Missing confirmation message after posting comment

[swissspidy]

According to #1029 / #936 confirmation messages should be displayed when posting a comment. However, that doesn't seem to be the case (anymore).

To reproduce:

1. Install AMP plugin
2. Activate Twenty Nineteen or any other theme that works well in native or paired mode
3. Enable comment moderation.
4. Write and submit a comment.
5. Note that the name & email fields are filled out, the textarea is emptied, and there is no confirmation message at all.
6. See comment held for moderation in the admin

Screenshot:

[westonruter]

@swissspidy The message in question for #1029 / #936 only applies to when using <amp-live-list> for comments. That is, enabling the comments_live_list argument for amp theme support.

I believe that the issue you are noticing here would be reproducible without AMP entirely. I just tried in Twenty Seventeen in a non-AMP page and I saw the same thing.

I believe you are noticing a core bug, namely: https://core.trac.wordpress.org/ticket/43857

If you enable this setting in Discussion then you should see the classic moderation messages:

[swissspidy]

🤦‍♂️ Thank you! I'll close this then.