Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

CMP / Funding Choices for AMP #30999

Open
greghuet opened this issue Nov 4, 2020 · 23 comments
Open

CMP / Funding Choices for AMP #30999

greghuet opened this issue Nov 4, 2020 · 23 comments
Assignees
@micajuine-ho
Labels
Component: amp-consent Stale Inactive for one year or more Type: Feature Request WG: components

Comments

@greghuet
Copy link

greghuet commented Nov 4, 2020

Hi, we are working on converting all our sites to AMP responsive tech, for desktop / mobile users. We are using Adsense and Ad Manager, and we have some issues with the update of the rules regarding consent for advertising. As we still have some desktop sites in standard HTML, our Google Account Manager suggested that we use the Funding Choices CMP script. This solution is great as really simple to implement.

On the other hand, we have been searching for a simple CMP solution for AMP. Right now, there are only some CMP for AMP commercial solutions (expensive). How come Google is working so hard on pushing AMP and does not provide a turnkey solution for AMP CMP based on Funding Choices. When could we expect such AMP CMP solution ? Indeed, we adopted your AMP solution really early (2017) and this situation with CMP is like a brick wall for us.
@gilbertococchi
Copy link

@jeffjose FYI

@archon810
Copy link

+1. We're also adding Funding Choices and need a solution for AMP.

@archon810
Copy link

Related? #26229 - if TCFv2 support isn't even ready for AMP, I don't see how Funding Choices can be. Google is about to stop serving ads in the EEA on sites that don't support TCFv2 on Nov 15, but don't have an official solution for AMP?

@citynews
Copy link

Hello!
Google Choices should absolutely support AMP.
It should be "a must", as AMP is also sponsored by Google.

@thinkdifferent
Copy link

Hello,
also for us it is very important .
+1. We're also adding Funding Choices and need a solution for AMP.

@micajuine-ho micajuine-ho assigned micajuine-ho and unassigned zhouyx Nov 11, 2020
@micajuine-ho
Copy link
Contributor

Related? #26229 - if TCFv2 support isn't even ready for AMP, I don't see how Funding Choices can be. Google is about to stop serving ads in the EEA on sites that don't support TCFv2 on Nov 15, but don't have an official solution for AMP?

Hi @archon810, while Funding Choices has not integrated into AMP yet, we do support TCFv2 with other CMPs (or through your own implementation): https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/blob/master/extensions/amp-consent/amp-consent.md#does-amp-support-the-iab-tcf

Please let me know if you need any more clarification around this subject.

@greghuet
Copy link
Author

Related? #26229 - if TCFv2 support isn't even ready for AMP, I don't see how Funding Choices can be. Google is about to stop serving ads in the EEA on sites that don't support TCFv2 on Nov 15, but don't have an official solution for AMP?

Hi @archon810, while Funding Choices has not integrated into AMP yet, we do support TCFv2 with other CMPs (or through your own implementation): https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/blob/master/extensions/amp-consent/amp-consent.md#does-amp-support-the-iab-tcf

Please let me know if you need any more clarification around this subject.

Hi, thank you for your reply. To tell you the truth, we need a plug and play CMP solution for AMP not a pain in the neck nightmare to develop (meaning countless hours to dev / test and no guaranties it'll work at the end...). AMP is supposed to be a simple solution ;) Funding Choices for AMP is a must have features for all people like us here who are deeply involved in pushing this tech on ours sites. Thank you in advance ;)

@maciejmackowiak
Copy link

Hi @micajuine-ho do you have any example of custom amp consent implementation that supports TCFv2?

@sankalpsans
Copy link

@maciejmackowiak It's hacky, but works and is compliant https://community.cookiepro.com/s/article/UUID-94cf9b13-1998-d989-a5e0-d01a73a2e0a7

@micajuine-ho
Copy link
Contributor

Hi @maciejmackowiak I assume by 'custom implementation' you mean that you are not working with a CMP. Is that correct?

@maciejmackowiak
Copy link

Thanks @sankalpsans I will take a look into it.

@micajuine-ho yes and no - for AMP currently we have basic <amp-consent> implementation without CMP, and for non-AMP we are using google funding choice.

This raises two questions:

  1. Is there a way to have custom AMP implementation without CMP that will support TCFv2?
  2. Maybe the solution @sankalpsans mentiond is possible to implement with google funding choice using an <iframe> and then pass the cookies?

@micajuine-ho
Copy link
Contributor

Is there a way to have custom AMP implementation without CMP that will support TCFv2?

If you are able to create a TC String, you can pass that along through amp-consent (via checkConsentHref) to be passed along to vendors (who will decode it and decide what to do with the request).

The amp-consent config will loosely look like this:

{
   consentRequired: 'remote',
   checkConsentHref: "your-endpoint-that-returns-a-tc-string",
   promptUi: "inline-prompt-ui-id"
}

More information on the checkHrefResponse can be found here.

Maybe the solution @sankalpsans mentiond is possible to implement with google funding choice using an <iframe> and then pass the cookies?

Yes that seems like that could work. For that solution, instead of using promptUI, you would use promptUISrc and the value would be the iframe.

@Irene-Sky
Copy link

Hi, we have already added and used the Funding Choices solution for all our sites, but we need support for the AMP version.
Thank you!

@greghuet
Copy link
Author

Happy new year everyone. I come here to check if there was any update on this topic, apparently not. For info, if you really need a CMP for AMP, Quantcast is providing one in Beta at the moment (I was in touch with their tech team, pretty reactive too). Now, we wait for Google to get its version ready. Thanks.

@micajuine-ho
Copy link
Contributor

The Funding Choices team has told me that they will be prioritizing the AMP integration in Q3.

@estereofonico
Copy link

The Google News Initiative promotes AMP Pages, and we're using an AMP Theme to get more visitor. Is a must that the project supports AMP pages

@greghuet
Copy link
Author

Does anyone have any updates regarding Funding Choices CMP for AMP ? Most solutions are expensive (the free ones are limited and share users' data...), therefore, we are looking forward to getting ready to get it implemented on our sites. Thanks you in advance.

@MathiasLerche
Copy link

Amen! Please, please, please make Funding Choices available for AMP!

@MathiasLerche
Copy link

Now Funding Choices is moving into Ad Manager. Thanks for that, but what is that good for? My traffic is 70% AMP!

@estereofonico
Copy link

Funding Choices are still not available for AMP for implementation. When will this happen?

@bonny
Copy link

bonny commented Dec 25, 2021 •
edited
Loading

I also need this so I occasionally browse this repo to see if there is any news. Today I saw the following pull so I guess progress is slowly made: #36144 Add Google FC as a CMP.

The doc for Google Funding Choices says:

The amp-consent configuration for Funding Choices is in a closed Beta, and usage of this feature has been limited to a small batch of publishers. However, Funding Choices is looking to open up access for general availability in the near future!

The near future is something like "a few weeks/months into the future" according to Google, so that's great news I guess :).

@estereofonico
Copy link

estereofonico commented Dec 27, 2021 via email

@stale
Copy link

stale bot commented Dec 24, 2022

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed in 7 days if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

@stale stale bot added the Stale Inactive for one year or more label Dec 24, 2022
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@micajuine-ho micajuine-ho

Labels
Component: amp-consent Stale Inactive for one year or more Type: Feature Request WG: components
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests