PWM command not publishing

[netomx]

As title. Use PWM, send cmnd/sonoff/PWM 1000

It will not get back the value from the mqtt broker, but anything else works

[curzon01]

What you mean is that PWM command returns an empty JSON object:

RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command PWM, Data 1000
MQT: dev/stat/tasmota/phesp03/RESULT = {"PWM":{}}

[arendst]

OK. Got it. When no PWM channel is configured and you execute the PWM command then this is the result.

I will check for any PMW configured and if none I will return

RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command PWM, Data 1000
MQT: stat/wemos6/RESULT = {"Command":"Unknown"}

[netomx]

I have pwm1 configured, nd still no output. El 5 feb. 2018 03:18, "Theo Arends" <notifications@github.com> escribió:

…

OK. Got it. When no PWM channel is configured and you execute the PWM command then this is the result. I will check for any PMW configured and if none I will return RSL: Group 0, Index 1, Command PWM, Data 1000 MQT: stat/wemos6/RESULT = {"Command":"Unknown"} — You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1783 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AChyDcMY29CNMG0SPm5hmhLneSW3DVZFks5tRsd_gaJpZM4R4iY7> .

[curzon01]

@netomx: Be aware to configure one of the GPIOx as PWM(i), otherwise PWM is unconfigured - using cmnd PWMx is not enough to have PWM configured.

And - what is the output of "Status 2"? Do you using 5.11.1i?

[netomx]

Version: Sonoff-Tasmota 5.11.1 by Theo Arends
GPIO5 = 33 PWM1
I can send commands, and the PWM is working, but it doesn't return the value.

Example 1 (another sonoff with RELAY):
mosquitto_sub -h IP -u user -P pass -t stat/sonoff1/POWER
ON
OFF

Example 2 (this NodeMCU v3 (nodemcu v2 clone) configured ad wemos d1 mini, only GPIO configured):
mosquitto_sub -h IP -u user -P password -t stat/sonoff2/PWM1 (tried with PWM too)
--no output when sending command--

Status 2:
18:50:55 CMD: STATUS 2
18:50:55 MQT: stat/led1/STATUS2 = {"StatusFWR":{"Version":"5.11.1","BuildDateTime":"2018-01-07T21:51:09","Boot":31,"Core":"2_3_0","SDK":"1.5.3(aec24ac9)"}}

PWM just sends RESULT, instead of PWM

[netomx]

More exmaples:

22:10:40 CMD: POWER 22:10:40 MQT: stat/cuarto/RESULT = {"POWER":"OFF"} 22:10:40 MQT: stat/cuarto/POWER = OFF

22:11:12 CMD: PWM 1000 22:11:12 MQT: stat/led1/RESULT = {"PWM":{"PWM1":1000}}

[arendst]

@netomx I see you are still using the old version 5.11.1 while I reported above that your problem is fixed in 5.11.1i.

Install that one and report your findings agian.

[netomx]

Forgot to say, I upgraded it before the "more examples" post:

22:08:39 CMD: status 2 22:08:39 MQT: stat/led1/STATUS2 = {"StatusFWR":{"Version":"5.11.1i","BuildDateTime":"2018-02-06T14:12:30","Boot":31,"Core":"2_4_0","SDK":"2.1.0(deb1901)"}}

[arendst]

Right. So what's the issue here. I see nothing wrong in your latest entries.

[netomx]

I will try to be as simple and clear as possible, language is barrier here:

When I send a command to the device, it replies with 2 lines:

RESULT
COMMAND (for example, POWER)

but if I send PWM command, it just replies with:

RESULT

That is my issue

[arendst]

As designed. Only power command returns both JSON and for legacy reasons also plain results.

To switch naming of result to command you can select one of the SetOptions. See wiki.

[netomx]

F*ck. Thanks, pal. I will close it as a unrelated bug was fixed and "my bug" was not.