fix(aws-autoscaling): allow minSize to be set to 0 #1015
Merged
Conversation
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
skinny85
reviewed
Oct 25, 2018
| ], | ||
|
|
||
| "MaxSize": "1", | ||
| "MinSize": "0", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Isn't it a bit overkill to copy&paste this entire template for this one property ? :) We have partial matching support as well.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sure -- mostly just lazy copy pasting bc I wasn't sure how the assert library worked. So I can change it to:
expect(stack).to(haveResource("AWS::AutoScaling::AutoScalingGroup", {
MinSize: "0",
MaxSize: "1",
DesiredCapacity: "1",
LaunchConfigurationName: {
Ref: "MyFleetLaunchConfig5D7F9801"
},
Tags: [
{
Key: "Name",
PropagateAtLaunch: true,
Value: "MyFleet"
}
],
VPCZoneIdentifier: [
"pri1"
],
}
));
test.done();
}
but not sure if there's a way to only assert against the one property (MinSize) that I care about?
rix0rrr
reviewed
Oct 26, 2018
| @@ -212,7 +212,7 @@ export class AutoScalingGroup extends cdk.Construct implements cdk.ITaggable, el | |||
|
|
|||
| launchConfig.addDependency(this.role); | |||
|
|
|||
| const minSize = props.minSize || 1; | |||
| const minSize = props.minSize !== undefined ? props.minSize : 1; | |||
| const maxSize = props.maxSize || 1; | |||
| const desiredCapacity = props.desiredCapacity || 1; | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same change in other lines?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sure -- realistically thought wasn't sure if maxSize or desiredCapacity would ever be 0 though, but happy to include the same change.
Previously, minSize was being set to `props.minSize || 1`. Since 0 is falsey in javascript, this would mean 0 passed in through the ASG props evaluate to false and the field would always be set to the default value of 1. This change uses strict equality comparison to allow 0 to be set.
SoManyHs
force-pushed
the
fix-asg-minsize
branch
2 times, most recently
from
c738832
to
ab85873
Compare
SoManyHs
force-pushed
the
fix-asg-minsize
branch
from
ab85873
to
e1ec138
Compare
rix0rrr
approved these changes
Oct 26, 2018
rix0rrr
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 6, 2018
Bug Fixes ========= * **aws-autoscaling:** allow minSize to be set to 0 ([#1015](#1015)) ([67f7fa1](67f7fa1)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly pass the timeout property to CFN when creating a Project. ([#1071](#1071)) ([b1322bb](b1322bb)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly set S3 path when using it as artifact. ([#1072](#1072)) ([f32cba9](f32cba9)) * **aws-kms:** add output value when exporting an encryption key ([#1036](#1036)) ([cb490be](cb490be)) * Switch from `js-yaml` to `yaml` ([#1092](#1092)) ([0b132b5](0b132b5)) Features ========= * **applets:** integrate into toolkit ([#1039](#1039)) ([fdabe95](fdabe95)), closes [#849](#849) [#342](#342) [#291](#291) * **aws-codecommit:** use CloudWatch Events instead of polling by default in the CodePipeline Action. ([#1026](#1026)) ([d09d30c](d09d30c)) * **aws-dynamodb:** allow specifying partition/sort keys in props ([#1054](#1054)) ([ec87331](ec87331)), closes [#1051](#1051) * **aws-ec2:** AmazonLinuxImage supports AL2 ([#1081](#1081)) ([97b57a5](97b57a5)), closes [#1062](#1062) * **aws-lambda:** high level API for event sources ([#1063](#1063)) ([1be3442](1be3442)) * **aws-sqs:** improvements to IAM grants API ([#1052](#1052)) ([6f2475e](6f2475e)) * don't upload the same asset multiple times ([#1011](#1011)) ([35937b6](35937b6)), closes [#989](#989) * **codepipeline/cfn:** Use fewer statements for pipeline permissions ([#1009](#1009)) ([8f4c2ab](8f4c2ab)) * add a new construct library for ECS ([#1058](#1058)) ([ae03ddb](ae03ddb)) * **pkglint:** Make sure .snk files are ignored ([#1049](#1049)) ([53c8d76](53c8d76)), closes [#643](#643) * **toolkit:** deployment ui improvements ([#1067](#1067)) ([c832eaf](c832eaf)) BREAKING CHANGES ========= * The ec2.Connections object has been changed to be able to manage multiple security groups. The relevant property has been changed from `securityGroup` to `securityGroups` (an array of security group objects). * **aws-codecommit:** This modifies the default behavior of the CodeCommit Action. It also changes the internal API contract between the aws-codepipeline-api module and the CodePipeline Actions in the service packages. * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow Multiple applets can be define in one file by structuring the files like this: * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow definition of multiple applets in the same file. The schema now looks like this: applets: MyApplet: type: ./my-applet-file properties: property1: value ... By starting an applet specifier with npm://, applet modules can directly be referenced in NPM. You can include a version specifier (@1.2.3) to reference specific versions. * **aws-sqs:** `queue.grantReceiveMessages` has been removed. It is unlikely that this would be sufficient to interact with a queue. Alternatively you can use `queue.grantConsumeMessages` or `queue.grant('sqs:ReceiveMessage')` if there's a need to only grant this action.
Merged
rix0rrr
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 6, 2018
Bug Fixes ======== * **aws-autoscaling:** allow minSize to be set to 0 ([#1015](#1015)) ([67f7fa1](67f7fa1)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly pass the timeout property to CFN when creating a Project. ([#1071](#1071)) ([b1322bb](b1322bb)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly set S3 path when using it as artifact. ([#1072](#1072)) ([f32cba9](f32cba9)) * **aws-kms:** add output value when exporting an encryption key ([#1036](#1036)) ([cb490be](cb490be)) * Switch from `js-yaml` to `yaml` ([#1092](#1092)) ([0b132b5](0b132b5)) Features ======== * don't upload the same asset multiple times ([#1011](#1011)) ([35937b6](35937b6)), closes [#989](#989) * **app-delivery:** CI/CD for CDK Stacks ([#1022](#1022)) ([f2fe4e9](f2fe4e9)) * add a new construct library for ECS ([#1058](#1058)) ([ae03ddb](ae03ddb)) * **applets:** integrate into toolkit ([#1039](#1039)) ([fdabe95](fdabe95)), closes [#849](#849) [#342](#342) [#291](#291) * **aws-codecommit:** use CloudWatch Events instead of polling by default in the CodePipeline Action. ([#1026](#1026)) ([d09d30c](d09d30c)) * **aws-dynamodb:** allow specifying partition/sort keys in props ([#1054](#1054)) ([ec87331](ec87331)), closes [#1051](#1051) * **aws-ec2:** AmazonLinuxImage supports AL2 ([#1081](#1081)) ([97b57a5](97b57a5)), closes [#1062](#1062) * **aws-lambda:** high level API for event sources ([#1063](#1063)) ([1be3442](1be3442)) * **aws-sqs:** improvements to IAM grants API ([#1052](#1052)) ([6f2475e](6f2475e)) * **codepipeline/cfn:** Use fewer statements for pipeline permissions ([#1009](#1009)) ([8f4c2ab](8f4c2ab)) * **pkglint:** Make sure .snk files are ignored ([#1049](#1049)) ([53c8d76](53c8d76)), closes [#643](#643) * **toolkit:** deployment ui improvements ([#1067](#1067)) ([c832eaf](c832eaf)) * Update to CloudFormation resource specification v2.11.0 BREAKING CHANGES ======== * The ec2.Connections object has been changed to be able to manage multiple security groups. The relevant property has been changed from `securityGroup` to `securityGroups` (an array of security group objects). * **aws-codecommit:** this modifies the default behavior of the CodeCommit Action. It also changes the internal API contract between the aws-codepipeline-api module and the CodePipeline Actions in the service packages. * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow Multiple applets can be define in one file by structuring the files like this: * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow definition of multiple applets in the same file. The schema now looks like this: applets: MyApplet: type: ./my-applet-file properties: property1: value ... By starting an applet specifier with npm://, applet modules can directly be referenced in NPM. You can include a version specifier (@1.2.3) to reference specific versions. * **aws-sqs:** `queue.grantReceiveMessages` has been removed. It is unlikely that this would be sufficient to interact with a queue. Alternatively you can use `queue.grantConsumeMessages` or `queue.grant('sqs:ReceiveMessage')` if there's a need to only grant this action.
rix0rrr
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 6, 2018
Bug Fixes ======== * **aws-autoscaling:** allow minSize to be set to 0 ([#1015](#1015)) ([67f7fa1](67f7fa1)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly pass the timeout property to CFN when creating a Project. ([#1071](#1071)) ([b1322bb](b1322bb)) * **aws-codebuild:** correctly set S3 path when using it as artifact. ([#1072](#1072)) ([f32cba9](f32cba9)) * **aws-kms:** add output value when exporting an encryption key ([#1036](#1036)) ([cb490be](cb490be)) * Switch from `js-yaml` to `yaml` ([#1092](#1092)) ([0b132b5](0b132b5)) Features ======== * don't upload the same asset multiple times ([#1011](#1011)) ([35937b6](35937b6)), closes [#989](#989) * **app-delivery:** CI/CD for CDK Stacks ([#1022](#1022)) ([f2fe4e9](f2fe4e9)) * add a new construct library for ECS ([#1058](#1058)) ([ae03ddb](ae03ddb)) * **applets:** integrate into toolkit ([#1039](#1039)) ([fdabe95](fdabe95)), closes [#849](#849) [#342](#342) [#291](#291) * **aws-codecommit:** use CloudWatch Events instead of polling by default in the CodePipeline Action. ([#1026](#1026)) ([d09d30c](d09d30c)) * **aws-dynamodb:** allow specifying partition/sort keys in props ([#1054](#1054)) ([ec87331](ec87331)), closes [#1051](#1051) * **aws-ec2:** AmazonLinuxImage supports AL2 ([#1081](#1081)) ([97b57a5](97b57a5)), closes [#1062](#1062) * **aws-lambda:** high level API for event sources ([#1063](#1063)) ([1be3442](1be3442)) * **aws-sqs:** improvements to IAM grants API ([#1052](#1052)) ([6f2475e](6f2475e)) * **codepipeline/cfn:** Use fewer statements for pipeline permissions ([#1009](#1009)) ([8f4c2ab](8f4c2ab)) * **pkglint:** Make sure .snk files are ignored ([#1049](#1049)) ([53c8d76](53c8d76)), closes [#643](#643) * **toolkit:** deployment ui improvements ([#1067](#1067)) ([c832eaf](c832eaf)) * Update to CloudFormation resource specification v2.11.0 BREAKING CHANGES ======== * The ec2.Connections object has been changed to be able to manage multiple security groups. The relevant property has been changed from `securityGroup` to `securityGroups` (an array of security group objects). * **aws-codecommit:** this modifies the default behavior of the CodeCommit Action. It also changes the internal API contract between the aws-codepipeline-api module and the CodePipeline Actions in the service packages. * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow Multiple applets can be define in one file by structuring the files like this: * **applets:** The applet schema has changed to allow definition of multiple applets in the same file. The schema now looks like this: applets: MyApplet: type: ./my-applet-file properties: property1: value ... By starting an applet specifier with npm://, applet modules can directly be referenced in NPM. You can include a version specifier (@1.2.3) to reference specific versions. * **aws-sqs:** `queue.grantReceiveMessages` has been removed. It is unlikely that this would be sufficient to interact with a queue. Alternatively you can use `queue.grantConsumeMessages` or `queue.grant('sqs:ReceiveMessage')` if there's a need to only grant this action.
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Previously, minSize was being set to
props.minSize || 1. Since 0 isfalsey in javascript, this would mean 0 passed in through the ASG props
evaluate to false and the field would always be set to the default value
of 1. This change uses strict equality comparison to allow 0 to be set.
By submitting this pull request, I confirm that my contribution is made under the terms of the Apache-2.0 license.