You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Hello, I am working on an optimization problem with a complex formulation and although the problem is easy to solve (<1 sec once Rglpk::Rglpk_solve_LP is called), the DCP check (CVXR::is_dcp) within CVXR::solve is very, very slow (minutes).
Here is a small reproducible example. Though unrelated to my optimization problem, it shows the kind of slow DCP check I am experiencing:
library(CVXR) n <- 5L; m <- 3L X <- Variable(n, m) y <- runif(n) cumX <- cumsum_axis(X, axis = 2) # %*% diag(m) cumE <- sum_entries(cumX, axis = 1) - y posE <- sum_entries(pos(cumE)) negE <- sum_entries(neg(cumE)) # * 1 objective <- Minimize(posE + negE) problem <- Problem(objective) system.time({ result <- is_dcp(problem) }) ## user system elapsed ## 3.234 0.021 3.447
If you then run the same code but uncomment the * 1 multiplication, it runs in
## user system elapsed ## 12.278 0.104 14.546
If you then run the same code but uncomment the %*% diag(m), it runs in
## user system elapsed ## 52.452 0.646 69.411
I hope you will be able to find the problem and speed up is_dcp. If not or if it looks like it will take some time to implement, would you please consider making the ignore_dcp option skip completely the DCP check? Or provide a separate option?
Thank you.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hello, I am working on an optimization problem with a complex formulation and although the problem is easy to solve (<1 sec once
Rglpk::Rglpk_solve_LP
is called), the DCP check (CVXR::is_dcp
) withinCVXR::solve
is very, very slow (minutes).Here is a small reproducible example. Though unrelated to my optimization problem, it shows the kind of slow DCP check I am experiencing:
library(CVXR)
n <- 5L; m <- 3L
X <- Variable(n, m)
y <- runif(n)
cumX <- cumsum_axis(X, axis = 2) # %*% diag(m)
cumE <- sum_entries(cumX, axis = 1) - y
posE <- sum_entries(pos(cumE))
negE <- sum_entries(neg(cumE)) # * 1
objective <- Minimize(posE + negE)
problem <- Problem(objective)
system.time({ result <- is_dcp(problem) })
## user system elapsed
## 3.234 0.021 3.447
If you then run the same code but uncomment the
* 1
multiplication, it runs in## user system elapsed
## 12.278 0.104 14.546
If you then run the same code but uncomment the
%*% diag(m)
, it runs in## user system elapsed
## 52.452 0.646 69.411
I hope you will be able to find the problem and speed up
is_dcp
. If not or if it looks like it will take some time to implement, would you please consider making theignore_dcp
option skip completely the DCP check? Or provide a separate option?Thank you.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: