Shell Tab is still visible after set Tab.IsVisible to false

[SamShanWang]

Description

In the beginning, there is one tab visible ( tab 1 ) and two tabs hidden ( tab 2 and tab 3 ) on a TabBar. Then I want to display tab 2 and tab 3. Meanwhile, hide tab 1.

1. Here is the code to do it.

Tab2.IsVisible = true;
Tab3.IsVisible = true;
Tab1.IsVisible = false;

Run in Android platform, the result is:

If you tap 'Tab 3' tab header, the app will crash.

When run in Windows platform, the result is correct.

2. If I use the code below.

Tab1.IsVisible = false;
Tab2.IsVisible = true;
Tab3.IsVisible = true;

Then run in Android platform, the result is correct.

But run in Windows platform, the app will crash.

A repro project is provided: https://github.com/SamShanWang/maui-shell-tab-hide-bug.git

Steps to Reproduce

1. Load repro project in VS and run on Android platform.
2. Click the menu item 'Tap me to reproduce bug on android' on flyout.
3. Notice the view of TabBar.
4. Tap 'Tab 3' tab header, the app crashes.
5. Then run on Windows platform.
6. Click the menu item 'Tap me to reproduce bug on windows' on flyout. Then the app crashes.

Version with bug

9.0.408 (current)

Last version that worked well

Unknown/Other

Affected platforms

Android, Windows, I was not able test on other platforms

Affected platform versions

Android 7.1, Android 9.0, Windows 10 version 19044.1826, I was not able test on other platform versions

Did you find any workaround?

No response

Relevant log output

No response

[rmarinho]

On Windows and iOS seems to work fine, but on Android i can reproduce the crash.

[SamShanWang]

@rmarinho It doesn't work fine on Windows.

1. Please pull the newest repro project.
2. Then run on Windows platform.
3. Click the menu item 'Tap me to reproduce bug on windows' on flyout. Then the app crashes.

[shawyunz]

After encountering the same issue, I ran a series of tests and found that the problem only occurs when the "IsVisible" property is bound to the first tab.

[XamlTest]

Verified this on Visual Studio Enterprise 17.7.0 Preview 1.0. This issue can be reproduced on Windows 11 and Android 13.0 with below project:
MauiAppShellTabHideBug.zip

Windows11: App crash after clicking 'Tap me to reproduce bug on windows' on flyout.

Android: App crash after clicking 'Tap me to reproduce bug on android' on flyout -> Tap 3.

[CusYaBasic]

Any update on this? I appear to be having a similar issue, however it's android crashing and not windows

[vibollee]

any update on this? im having the same issue. Simple navigation issue shouldnt take this long to fix.