A11y_.NET Core_WinForms_Print_Preference_Keyboard: Keyboard focus is incorrect/illogical after pressing ENTER key on "Cancel" button which is present in "Print Preference" pop up.

[HindujaArugula]

.NET version

.NET-SDK-8.0.100-preview.4.23260.5

Did it work in .NET Framework?

No

Did it work in any of the earlier releases of .NET Core or .NET 5+?

No response

Issue description

GitHubTags:

#A11yMAS;#A11yTCS;#WCAG2.4.3;#BM_.NET Core[Winforms]-Win32-May2023;#.NET Core;#A11ySev2;#DesktopApp;#Win11;#NonBenchmark;#Keyboard

Actual:

Keyboard focus is incorrect/illogical after pressing ENTER key on "Cancel" button present in the "Print Preference" pop up where keyboard focus is shifting to "Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox after pressing ENTER key.

Expected:

Keyboard focus is incorrect/illogical after pressing ENTER key on "Cancel" button present in the "Print Preference" pop up where keyboard focus should not move "Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox after pressing ENTER key and it should remain on the "More Setting" button.

User Impact:

Keyboard users will not be able to understand focus order after activating the "Cancel" button and it will be confusing if focus shifts to "Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox.

Attachments:

Steps to reproduce

1. Install and Open "Winforms" App.
2. "Main Form" screen would appear.
3. TAB to "Printing_Controls:Testing" the controls under Printing Tab and press ENTER key.
4. Now 'Printing Testing" screen appears.
5. TAB to "Print" button and click on it.
6. Now "Print from Win 32 application- Print" appears
7. TAB to "More Settings" button and press ENTER key.
   8."Printing Preference" Screen appears.
8. Now observe that after pressing ENTER key on "Cancel" button keyboard focus shifts to "Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox which is illogical/incorrect.

[12-shweta]

#BM_.NET Core[Winforms]-Win32-May2023;

[MelonWang1]

This issue also repro in .NET 8.0/7.0/6.0/5.0/3.1 and .NET Framework on win11 22H2. When click "More settings", the keyboard already focus on"Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox, so when cancel the "Printing Preference" Screen, keyboard focus on"Let the app change my printing preferences" checkbox.

NVDA/Inspect/Narrtor/Accessibility Insights also have same behavior.

This issue similar to 1505993, In comments, @merriemcgaw said this is a legacy UI dialog and owned by Windows. Bug Exception 94484: WinForms OpenFileDialog calls an inaccessible Win32 API - Boards (visualstudio.com)

[merriemcgaw]

Thanks @MelonWang1 I'm going to see if this can be under the exception you linked here!

[merriemcgaw]

The exception for legacy printing dialogs has been approved. @HindujaArugula can you please close this out?

[merriemcgaw]

#Closed

based on approved exception.

[12-shweta]

#Closed;