bookmark syncs move all separators towards the end of the folder

[raslop]

Which version of floccus are you using?

4.14.0

Sync method

{"label"=>"WebDAV"}

Which browser are you using? In case you are using the Android App, specify the Android version please.

Firefox 100.0.1

Which version of Nextcloud Bookmarks are you using? (if relevant)

No response

Which version of Nextcloud? (if relevant)

No response

What kind of WebDAV server are you using? (if relevant)

home-brewed server

Describe the Bug

After the automatic upgrade to 4.14.0 this week I noticed that similar to #1043 all bookmark separators were moved to the end of the folder again. It worked fine the last couple of weeks, but 4.14.0 seems to break it again, somehow.

Expected Behavior

Bookmark separators stay, were they are.

To Reproduce

Don't know.
The provided anonymized debug log is from the last sync, but maybe the "move to end end" happened in an earlier sync already.

Debug log provided

• I have provided a debug log file

[raslop]

2022-05-19T20:10:40.530Z Starting sync process for account user@domain
2022-05-19T20:10:40.542Z onSyncStart: begin
2022-05-19T20:10:40.552Z onSyncStart: completed
2022-05-19T20:10:40.555Z Using "merge slave" strategy (no cache available)
2022-05-19T20:10:41.050Z { localDiff: 
   [ { type: 'REORDER',
       payload: 
        + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
        - #cY3R6M79oLnu[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #TAmVKfMBM8lk[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #RerEOADPgLcd[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #TZcncfDkgUS2[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD,
       order: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0] } ],
  serverDiff: 
   [ { type: 'REORDER',
       payload: 
        + #1undefined parentId: 0, hash: undefined
        - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
        - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
        - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
        - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
       order: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0] } ] }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.052Z { localTreeRoot: 
     + #G4C0ZLWaX_Q7[eb045d78d273107348b0300c01d29b7552d622abbc6faf81b3ec55359aa9950c] parentId: undefined, hash: undefined
       + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
         - #cY3R6M79oLnu[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #TAmVKfMBM8lk[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #RerEOADPgLcd[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #TZcncfDkgUS2[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD,
  serverTreeRoot: 
     + #0[4813494d137e1631bba301d5acab6e7bb7aa74ce1185d456565ef51d737677b2] parentId: undefined, hash: undefined
       + #1undefined parentId: 0, hash: undefined
         - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
         - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
         - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
         - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
  cacheTreeRoot: 
     + #G4C0ZLWaX_Q7[eb045d78d273107348b0300c01d29b7552d622abbc6faf81b3ec55359aa9950c] parentId: undefined, hash: undefined
       + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
         - #cY3R6M79oLnu[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #TAmVKfMBM8lk[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #RerEOADPgLcd[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
         - #TZcncfDkgUS2[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.053Z { revertPlan: 
   [ { type: 'REORDER',
       payload: 
        + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
        - #cY3R6M79oLnu[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #TAmVKfMBM8lk[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #RerEOADPgLcd[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD
        - #TZcncfDkgUS2[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: qdWNbSkQsRRD,
       order: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0] } ] }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.053Z Checking failsafe: 0/4=0
2022-05-19T20:10:41.054Z { revertOrderings: 
   [ { type: 'REORDER',
       payload: 
        + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
        - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
        - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
        - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
        - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
       order: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0],
       oldItem: 
        + #1undefined parentId: 0, hash: undefined
        - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
        - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
        - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
        - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
       oldOrder: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0] } ] }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.054Z { reorderings: 
   [ { type: 'REORDER',
       payload: 
        + #qdWNbSkQsRRDundefined parentId: G4C0ZLWaX_Q7, hash: undefined
        - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
        - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
        - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
        - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
       order: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0],
       oldItem: 
        + #1undefined parentId: 0, hash: undefined
        - #53[f7e26f7122bd990bb0112d17b9fe6179b3555d739c99cc2f05252f1163c75bac](b621cba8e74d22ceb585b4d96ca1b6461e72d3f358d1affe3fb16919ccd6894a) parentId: 1
        - #54[f167853b936f439b173ab76df0fdfdac3c75c6c303be31b2d617d58862c0cafd](a37de75fec38d7553cecb4c547f70c501732495590b333b439695668a6273c72) parentId: 1
        - #55[caf7d37cdfb4ecd1ba0d6db9b910878c82498cf7b80250fd2bea18ed3f684772](f6f7567692cd9e9d5c8cc53a446c5719541b314a9d28a17fbfce334bc1e39790) parentId: 1
        - #56[51305ed54a6411f009afe66fc56ce8b7e1dbfd5beb07cce3ef353dc2723be0ea](add312a79412103418c7154f7dcee15796d009071ba183fe27ccd76361a829b9) parentId: 1,
       oldOrder: [62a6da8735c18e2d66fe5de3dc5440252a1da49e3cbaa7c1d2d5068ad73ffba0] } ] }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.055Z (local)ORDERFOLDER { id: 'qdWNbSkQsRRD',
  order: 
   [ { type: 'bookmark', id: 'cY3R6M79oLnu' },
     { type: 'bookmark', id: 'TAmVKfMBM8lk' },
     { type: 'bookmark', id: 'RerEOADPgLcd' },
     { type: 'bookmark', id: 'TZcncfDkgUS2' } ] }
2022-05-19T20:10:41.624Z onSyncComplete
2022-05-19T20:10:41.628Z No changes to the server version necessary
2022-05-19T20:10:41.633Z Successfully ended sync process for account user@domain

[marcelklehr]

I cannot reproduce this with Firefox 100 at the moment. It might work if you let floccus add the separators upstream once, since floccus supports syncing separators now.

[raslop]

Well, it seems that this was a one time event after the upgrade from floccus 4.13 to 4.14.
After reorganizing the separators in some folders, the correct position was synced again to other devices.
So I spent some time again to restore the position of more separators, which were also correctly synced again.
I agree to close this issue and hope that such glitches don't occur with future updates, as re-positioning the separators takes a lot of time.

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.