Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

the big 'gitcoin quests' feedback thread. #5298

Closed
owocki opened this issue Oct 3, 2019 · 166 comments
Closed

the big 'gitcoin quests' feedback thread. #5298

owocki opened this issue Oct 3, 2019 · 166 comments
Assignees

Comments

@owocki
Copy link
Member

@owocki owocki commented Oct 3, 2019

Other Quests Threads

  • Round 1 Winners Congrats Thread #5337
  • Round 2 Winnerse #5435
  • Decnetralized Quest Roadmap #5436
  • Feedback thread #5298
  • Request Topic Thread #5334
  • Create Topic Thread/Bounty - #5338
  • Create Game Mechanic Thread/Bounty - #5339

This Topic

This Topic

we wil be releasing Gitcoin Quests at Devcon V this year. this is the big [Gitcoin Quests](gitcoin quests) feedback thread.

check the link here => https://gitcoin.co/quests -- then ..
found bugs? got a ux feedback? post it below:

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 8, 2019

Getting logged on into the UX of quests your pop overs for news is hidden (white on white)
image
image

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 8, 2019

My name is definitly not too long for this:
image

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 8, 2019

During "Pitch your eth killer" I'm stuck on the page for "Quest Rules"
image

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 8, 2019

Same with the others, seems to be MIDIjs is missing?
image

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 8, 2019

the midijs.net certificate went dead a couple of days ago, that's why.
image

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 9, 2019

midijs.net folks renewed their certificate! We're green here!

More bugs:
During the FOSS - White on White reads like shite.
grafik
Give the text some outline (black or so)

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 9, 2019

Is... battle-bottoshi using Secret of Mana Battle music? Or some other (S)NES game? Sounding very similar to me...

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 9, 2019

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 9, 2019

By clicking on that link you can re-solve the quest as many times as you like - you cannot redeem the kudos again tho.
grafik

@kuhnchris
Copy link
Contributor

@kuhnchris kuhnchris commented Oct 9, 2019

Use a loading screen - half of the time the music kicks in if i'm on the 2nd or 3rd question.

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented Oct 11, 2019

just put in a few fixes for the above

@KevinSmall
Copy link

@KevinSmall KevinSmall commented Oct 11, 2019

The first quest "pitch to a VC" I found it hard to understand what was going on. I think I got that I was supposed to be pitching an Ethereum Killer (EOS) to a VC, but the questions were not really questions (was that the VC asking me questions?). It just looked like lots of statements that looked to be quite random.

The second quest seems to be much clearer, it is structured as proper questions and answers.

@ligi
Copy link

@ligi ligi commented Oct 12, 2019

0.5 mins is not really how you say this. Should state 30 seconds ..-)

image

@ligi
Copy link

@ligi ligi commented Oct 12, 2019

Also I was in the cooldown period because IMHO the expected answers are wrong multiple times. Starting with the first question.
image

expected is (1) (3) (4) - but where does https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Open_Source_Definition state (3) and (4) ?

and here:

image

the expected answer is 400 Billion here - but this was 2008 - and @owocki himself stated in the talk it must be much higher today

image

I stopped there ..

@Webmoss
Copy link

@Webmoss Webmoss commented Oct 15, 2019

Completed all 7 quests but there is one Kudos for 2 quests, is this correct, I'm missing the Narwhal Bot?
Snip20191015_12

Besides that, a fun experience and a great job @owocki

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented Oct 19, 2019

just put in a few fixes for the above

@sudeepb02
Copy link

@sudeepb02 sudeepb02 commented Oct 20, 2019

I created a new quest here, pending approval - https://gitcoin.co/quests/13/journey-to-eth-20
After creating this new quest, I completed the Pitch your Ethereum Killer to the VC-Bro quest.
However, in the redeem kudos page, I saw the message which I created for my quest

Congrats on beating the 'Journey to ETH 2.0' Gitcoin Quest

The kudos transaction also failed with an error here

Fail with error 'The number of Kudos clones requested exceeds the number of clones allowed.'

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented Oct 21, 2019

thanks for letting me know @sudeepb02 ; i just put in a fix for this (by making the kudos reward a new kudos; we were out of evil genius bots!)

@DistributedDoge
Copy link

@DistributedDoge DistributedDoge commented Oct 21, 2019

As I mentioned in the email, scoring logic seems to be less than perfect, I have noticed the following entry in my feed after beating a quest:

"@DistributedDoge just beat 'Journey to ETH 2.0'. You earned 0.25 quest points & kudos for referring them."

This looks level 2 referral reward that could be possible thanks to following the referral scheme in this order:
@DistributedDoge => @ solexplorer => @DistributedDoge

I think having an (unintentional) referral loop (I referred @ sol, @ sol referred me) between two participants can lead to unexpected behavior.

EDIT: Apologies if I called someone by using @ username.

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented Oct 21, 2019

thanks @DistributedDoge ; maybe the fix should be :

  • allow people to remove their referrer
  • dont follow circular referral paths when rewarding points

@connortest1
Copy link

@connortest1 connortest1 commented Oct 21, 2019

Issue with negative points for referrals:
Screen Shot 2019-10-21 at 2 45 12 PM

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented Oct 21, 2019

thx; just put in a fix for this!

@owocki
Copy link
Member Author

@owocki owocki commented May 31, 2021

@zhjj80
Copy link

@zhjj80 zhjj80 commented May 31, 2021

looks like it reverted with a "The number of Kudos clones requested exceeds the number of clones allowed." error

On Mon, May 31, 2021 at 10:45 AM zhjj80 @.***> wrote: FYI all we are seeing 500% increase in quests usage, and as a result some quests are out of kudos rewards (kudos are limited edition). we are working on a fix hey master O, I saw you solved kind of issue like mine in another post. I finished today about 10 quests and redeemed also. But I get only 1 transfered to my wallet, the others have no valid hash as following. feel really upset, pls help. thx 1. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x34a94472b6c548a19c2bf88b4f85223e475a511e3e6d7f8ecab3b588a35207e5 2. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x3414e403ae5a04476b20d90a4e5711f967cc5b6625a4ce99c48f8bd38cd7c4ee 3. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x101d8b628d3a6da44d4c86abf2cf3a38c007414ddff4501aa5f9e7e8b02b9cce 4. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xfe5187ec6a4f00b35883e74d72bc851cbbb954f5f223533a2c11108a61fea584 5. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x76ab79f8915d941304976c08df417a67214871e764f25b877b5b7e4fae2d8378 6. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x999d8e2da1af430b869408e00c30a2d5c4cc4a3b5d88ac7e0851b9caa460b2da 7. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xcaa2d28b6ea00fb0fe748f2c6b2a21d5fa17a16f4ecdb0366482197584389d33 8. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xbeba3e986149ae7758c8857578451830acceb9046f9169634c75062a937164bf 9. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x5a80b365e9af01d8408d4466022e94131a7f9ec8f0d3e535275c6e888b3eeea7 10. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0x6d2dfcf852ac29c8457b691ab7d837eef012ff6702af246e31df4971968f0bc5 11. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xf70a1bf480625f781446701d6fa133001d6e795e651d432a87c4b0273f692f86 12. https://blockscout.com/xdai/mainnet/tx/0xd4784b9112ded2ddd5951277d9ac5c080a27c0dcd6918d0d9b9ee63ac80fdf9d — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#5298 (comment)>, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAD5PCM6LOZY3XXJ7GRPHFDTQO4JVANCNFSM4I45GELQ .
-- @owocki http://www.twitter.com/owocki
_________________________________________ gitcoin is live and has generated over $20mm for Open Source Software - see our results https://gitcoin.co/results

thx for your reply.
FYI: As I checked, most of these issued kudos seem still available in the martketplace.

@srtemis
Copy link

@srtemis srtemis commented Jun 1, 2021

It often appears 403
Uploading 微信图片_20210527122433.png…

@sonshine518
Copy link

@sonshine518 sonshine518 commented Jun 2, 2021

I am using the Brave Browser. There is a bug where you press back when you answer a question wrong and you are allowed to start the timer and question over from first attempt without a cooldown. Also the music for me clicks instead of plays and the characters shake and flash after getting a question wrong or defeating a character.

@ElBinBit
Copy link

@ElBinBit ElBinBit commented Jun 3, 2021

It seems you can do most quests twice if you wanted to.
I guess you should only be able to do a quest once. Although at least it seems like you are limited to only getting the reward from the same quest once, so even if you did it twice and tried to claim the reward twice you would only receive the reward once.

you can request kudos 2 times! From your referral, and for the completed quest itself

@ElBinBit
Copy link

@ElBinBit ElBinBit commented Jun 3, 2021

And! Where is justice?
Beat 43 quest https://prnt.sc/13tq08z = 1st place
Beat 342 quest https://prnt.sc/13tq6hk = 2nd place

@courzhao333
Copy link

@courzhao333 courzhao333 commented Jun 5, 2021

Hi, I m new here, how can I do that?

@swi15697
Copy link

@swi15697 swi15697 commented Jun 10, 2021

I win but when I click the claim buttton it showed error, and I can't claim any kudos.

@dowa20202020
Copy link

@dowa20202020 dowa20202020 commented Jun 17, 2021

I am using the Brave Browser. There is a bug where you press back when you answer a question wrong and you are allowed to start the timer and question over from first attempt without a cooldown. Also the music for me clicks instead of plays and the characters shake and flash after getting a question wrong or defeating a character.

@srtemis
Copy link

@srtemis srtemis commented Jun 17, 2021

@gjramayya
Copy link

@gjramayya gjramayya commented Jun 21, 2021

Can additional points (to owners) be given to quests with higher attempts ? Like every 1000 attempt adds 3 extra points to the owner also in addition to 3 points for creating the quest (to encourage creating quests of high user attempts).

@gjramayya
Copy link

@gjramayya gjramayya commented Jun 29, 2021

I had released edited my quest called Ethereum Whitepaper - part10 last week, and then today I did Part11. I see part11 is created, and so I had gone in to re-edit part10 to see if I had missed any part in the process. Hope to see it approved too.

@gjramayya
Copy link

@gjramayya gjramayya commented Jun 29, 2021

Wrong headlines in leaderboard header: For the Quests the leader board still shows as Round5. In index.html file, needs to be updated to capture as Round 6, and also with the end date as 7/30/21.
Source code reference:

Round 5 Challenge ended on 7/30!

@joincc
Copy link

@joincc joincc commented Jul 19, 2021

Do we have "multi-language quests format"? i.e. If it is Chinese version, writer must provide both English and Chinese in questions and options.

I already submited one "multi-language quests" with both English and Chinese in questions and options.

reason: When players use Google Translate in quest, it doesn't work well, so they always fail to pass quest.

@CarpeCryptum
Copy link

@CarpeCryptum CarpeCryptum commented Sep 16, 2021

When I start a quest with the sound "on" it runs as if I have a really slow internet connection. The music does not play properly, the countdown (the time you have to answer the question) is running much slower than it should be, I click the "submit answer" but it takes too long to actually submit it and I am running out of time. When the sound is "off" everything is spot on. I am using Brave on Mac Pro.

@wxf19890711
Copy link

@wxf19890711 wxf19890711 commented Sep 23, 2021

太难了

@Elias-95
Copy link

@Elias-95 Elias-95 commented Sep 29, 2021

image
Got the following message out of 2 quests.
Not sure if this is normal functionality.

@Tanvlog
Copy link

@Tanvlog Tanvlog commented Oct 12, 2021

Ok

@rude69
Copy link

@rude69 rude69 commented Oct 20, 2021

thanks @DistributedDoge ; maybe the fix should be :

allow people to remove their referrer
dont follow circular referral paths when rewarding points

@Sirlupinwatson1
Copy link

@Sirlupinwatson1 Sirlupinwatson1 commented Oct 20, 2021

image Got the following message out of 2 quests. Not sure if this is normal functionality.

Yeah this is when a "Quest" is not live, basically it's at the "Beta" testing phase.

@Muhammad997
Copy link

@Muhammad997 Muhammad997 commented Oct 22, 2021

Getting logged on into the UX of quests your pop overs for news is hidden (white on white) image image

Nice

@Muhammad997
Copy link

@Muhammad997 Muhammad997 commented Oct 22, 2021

Other Quests Threads

This Topic

This Topic

we wil be releasing Gitcoin Quests at Devcon V this year. this is the big [Gitcoin Quests](gitcoin quests) feedback thread.

check the link here => https://gitcoin.co/quests -- then .. found bugs? got a ux feedback? post it below:

Nice

@Muhammad997
Copy link

@Muhammad997 Muhammad997 commented Oct 22, 2021

Nice

@pollo123poll
Copy link

@pollo123poll pollo123poll commented Dec 4, 2021

Bonito

@dahan8888
Copy link

@dahan8888 dahan8888 commented Dec 5, 2021

@skypey
Copy link

@skypey skypey commented Dec 16, 2021

不太理解这个页面的使用

@TuaTime
Copy link

@TuaTime TuaTime commented Dec 26, 2021

lets grow

@tianbiandeyun12332
Copy link

@tianbiandeyun12332 tianbiandeyun12332 commented Jan 5, 2022

yes

@soumyajitsamanta
Copy link

@soumyajitsamanta soumyajitsamanta commented Jan 8, 2022

Sometimes during initial start of quest the Kudo preview takes full height of screen on widescreen monitor. It covers the continue button.

@luciferqn91
Copy link

@luciferqn91 luciferqn91 commented Jan 10, 2022

hãy phát triển

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Linked pull requests

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

None yet