"Unsubscribe from thread" button doesn't unsubscribe

[y-nk]

🔍 Is there already an issue for your problem?

• I have checked older issues, open and closed

📝 Description

I've used the bell icon (unsubscribe from thread) to silence notifications of some PRs, but going to the github notification panel i can see that those PRs are still subscribed to notifications. i wonder if it's expected behavior or bug ; if the PAT can't do this, there should be some log somewhere to reflect the failure imho.

🪜 Steps To Reproduce

1. click the bell icon next to a PR
2. click the bell icon under the Gitify logo to go to the Github notification panel
3. witness that the PR you silenced is still subscribed for notifications

Gitify Version

5.13.1

Operating System

macOS

GitHub Account

GitHub Cloud

📸 Screenshots

No response

[setchy]

Thanks for reporting @y-nk - is there any errors within your console logs or system logs that you can share?

[y-nk]

i just checked the faq, found the network panel. the call fires well with a { ignored: true } payload

in gitify, click on the bell somewhere:

payload:

response:

i dont know if it's supposed to be, but { ignored: true } is sent and { ignored: false, subscribed: false } is received.

also, when clicking on the github notification panel, PR still shows in the list

and only disappear after selecting the PR in the list + clicking the "unsubscribe" button. said button fires a request to an internal github payload which seems to also call "unsubscribe"

[setchy]

@y-nk - I spent some time this morning trying to reproduce the above issue, but unfortunately could not.

I'm using v5.13.1 with GitHub Cloud. I was able to repeatedly unsubscribe from notifications via the Gitify interface (mixture of issues and discussions) and see the corresponding changes in the GitHub UI (both on the specific items page, and the notifications inbox).

[y-nk]

@setchy thanks for spending the time in testing. i will look further again, reinstall and make sure all is well. i'm also using GitHub Cloud. I will close this as, since you can't reproduce, it's most likely that the problem is on my side.

[setchy]

No worries - always happy to reopen this ticket if you are still having issues and we can continue to triage 🕵️

[y-nk]

@setchy i think if i had to reopen it'd be to ask for a feature which is a button doing the 3 calls (mark as read, unsubscribe and silence mark as done) in one click 😬

[setchy]

@setchy i think if i had to reopen it'd be to ask for a feature which is a button doing the 3 calls (mark as read, unsubscribe and silence) in one click 😬

Maybe I'm missing something, but isn't this what happens today when you click the Unsubscribe from Thread notification icon in Gitify 🤔

[y-nk]

@setchy my bad for bad english: clicking the bell (unsubscribe) doesn't "mark as done" in a batch (but i worked the habit of 2 clicks)