Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Nov 15, 2017. It is now read-only.

Comparative benchmarks against widely used blockers: Most recent results on one page

Raymond Hill edited this page Feb 28, 2014 · 9 revisions

The results emphasize 3rd-party requests, as these are, I believe, a key statistics when it comes to gauge privacy matters. The rationale being that the more a user pushes data to more 3rd parties (a mere net request is pushing data) -- typically without the user being aware -- the larger the footprint of leaked metadata. It is difficult for a user to appreciate how much metadata is leaked to 3rd parties when visiting a web page, as requests to 3rd-party agents are not easy to see, let alone easy to act upon. This is where HTTP Switchboard will help you the most.

The values are averages of aggregated results of the 15 web page visited over 5 runs. In the table, a result reported as "x / n" means "3rd-party count / total count".

The most important figure in my opinion with regard to privacy is the 3rd-party Domain count, hence the ordering from left-to-right using the 3rd-party domain count figures.

Click on the links in the table for more details about a specific benchmark.

 
Top 15 Most Popular
News Websites
HTTPSBOOB Ghostery Adblock+ HTTPSBAA/BX Disconnect No blocker
Domains 24 / 25 54 / 55 59 / 60 69 / 70 91 / 92 476 / 477
Hosts 55 / 82 109 / 183 107 / 169 126 / 200 157 / 240 693 / 785
Scripts 0 / 0 176 / 307 173 / 293 187 / 327 235 / 391 534 / 698
Cookies 0 / 0 4 / 54 1 / 44 10 / 73 12 / 86 299 / 389
Net requests 651 / 1,232 1,064 / 1,921 1,019 / 1,815 1,087 / 1,934 1,103 / 2,091 2,300 / 3,236
Bandwidth 14,935,325 25,128,116 25,150,853 25,785,433 26,007,184 28,855,067
 
Top 15 Most Popular
Business Websites
HTTPSBOOB Ghostery Adblock+ HTTPSBAA/BX Disconnect No blocker
Domains 18 / 19 52 / 53 60 / 61 82 / 83 105 / 106 430 / 431
Hosts 51 / 87 98 / 172 106 / 177 137 / 215 171 / 260 643 / 743
Scripts 0 / 0 159 / 201 163 / 208 196 / 259 226 / 296 495 / 575
Cookies 0 / 0 9 / 50 7 / 48 18 / 78 17 / 87 224 / 313
Net requests 418 / 750 663 /1,287 615 / 1,224 740 / 1,390 804 / 1,510 1,757 / 2,505
Bandwidth 9,846,856 18,016,101 17,645,598 19,989,297 18,944,959 23,437,021
 
Top 15 Most Popular
Tech & Gadget Websites
HTTPSBOOB Ghostery Adblock+ HTTPSBAA/BX Disconnect No blocker
Domains 26 / 27 59 / 60 66 / 67 76 / 77 85 / 86 398 / 399
Hosts 37 / 69 91 / 140 97 / 146 115 / 173 145 / 203 580 / 646
Scripts 0 / 0 146 / 204 151 / 208 155 / 240 194 / 262 489 / 578
Cookies 0 / 0 9 / 38 6 / 25 16 / 60 17 / 58 233 / 304
Net requests 309 / 710 583 / 1,252 583 / 1,233 655 / 1,390 671 / 1,370 1,737 / 2,494
Bandwidth 19,801,676 30,769,246 30,340,281 31,174,355 30,895,419 33,826,528
 
Top 15 Most Popular
Blogs
HTTPSBOOB Ghostery Adblock+ HTTPSBAA/BX Disconnect No blocker
Domains 32 / 33 56 / 57 72 / 73 89 / 90 89 / 90 381 / 382
Hosts 36 / 71 74 / 116 91 / 142 122 / 177 144 / 188 578 / 635
Scripts 0 / 0 101 / 180 129 / 200 149 / 240 163 / 231 476 / 572
Cookies 0 / 0 20 / 47 17 / 41 37 / 74 32 / 58 224 / 275
Net requests 369 / 711 540 / 1,138 588 / 1,168 639 / 1,282 647 / 1,234 1,573 / 2,236
Bandwidth 30,365,916 37,611,873 38,043,172 38,366,098 37,856,378 42,021,162
Clone this wiki locally