Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Not compatible to Thunderbird 91.0 #194

Closed
Horst12 opened this issue Aug 12, 2021 · 58 comments
Closed

Not compatible to Thunderbird 91.0 #194

Horst12 opened this issue Aug 12, 2021 · 58 comments

Comments

@Horst12
Copy link

Horst12 commented Aug 12, 2021

After upgrading to TB 91.0 all calendars are offiline and can't be enabled.
It was working fine with previous version TB 78.13

@chupsy80
Copy link

chupsy80 commented Aug 12, 2021

The calendar section works fine with me, after using the new calendar (+) button again and insert the proper google e-mail adress. The task-section is the one actually not working, unfortunately. See https://github.com/kewisch/gdata-provider/issues/189

@thebertster
Copy link

thebertster commented Aug 13, 2021

Thunderbird 91.0 seems to support read/write access to Google Calendar natively (but also not working with Tasks) - I have now uninstalled this add-on and everything is working (so far, very well). There are some mentions in the release notes of "Calendar: Remote calendar auto-detection now supported" but no specific mention of Google. It also works natively with Google contacts now!

If you add a Google account afresh, it will automatically discover Google calendars and contacts and import them.

As I upgraded, I had the same issue that my existing calendars were not working, but I removed those calendars and re-added as follows:

Add calendar, choose "On the network", enter Google e-mail address for "User name", enter "calendar.google.com" in "Location". I then get prompted to log in to Google and authorize Thunderbird to access my calendars. I'm then presented with the full list of my Google calendars (including calendars others have shared).

The calendar address once this is done is https://apidata.googleusercontent.com/caldav/v2/... rather than the googleapi:// URI that this extension used.

Only thing I did after that was go into each added calendar's properties and checked the appropriate e-mail address for invitation management (or None if not using invitations).

Similarly, Google Contacts can be added without having to remove and re-add the whole Google account, by going to Address Book, New -> CardDAV, enter Google e-mail address as "Username" and "https://www.googleapis.com/carddav/v1/principals/<google e-mail>/lists/default/" as "Location".

@racofer
Copy link

racofer commented Aug 15, 2021

Thunderbird 91.0 seems to support read/write access to Google Calendar natively (but also not working with Tasks) - I have now uninstalled this add-on and everything is working (so far, very well). There are some mentions in the release notes of "Calendar: Remote calendar auto-detection now supported" but no specific mention of Google. It also works natively with Google contacts now!

The main issue I'm facing with the native implementation of TB91 is that it doesn't allow me to add more than one calendar with the same name from different accounts, that is:

  • Gmail Account 1 - Contacts Calendar (added fine)
  • Gmail Account 2 - Contacts Calendar (grayed out, cannot add)
  • Gmail Account n - Contacts Calendar (grayed out, cannot add)

This also happens with any other calendar that shares a name with a previously added calendar from another account.

I never had this issue with the Provider for Google Calendar extension in TB 78 or 68, so I still need this extension.

@gumby-man
Copy link

Add calendar, choose "On the network", enter Google e-mail address for "User name", enter "calendar.google.com" in "Location". I then get prompted to log in to Google and authorize Thunderbird to access my calendars. I'm then presented with the full list of my Google calendars (including calendars others have shared).

This does not work for me, „please wait“ message sticks forever. Any way to find problem? Or a way to get a working add-on? This really sucks.

@Dtrieb
Copy link

Dtrieb commented Aug 18, 2021

@gumby-man :

Add calendar, choose "On the network", enter Google e-mail address without "@gmail.com" for User name, enter https://apidata.googleusercontent.com/caldav/v2/ in "Location".

That's it!

@djkraven
Copy link

djkraven commented Aug 19, 2021

UPDATE: without the add-on in place I was able to manually add the calendar by using the location below and my user without @gmail.com

https://apidata.googleusercontent.com/caldav/v2/USER%40gmail.com/events/

I have a google calendar under other calendars in the Google listing that is not showing as an option to select. The calendar permissions are: Anyone can - See nothing, You can - See all event details. I tried @Dtrieb suggestion without success. It has a public URL of
https://calendar.google.com/calendar/embed?src=USER%40gmail.com&ctz=America%2FNew_York
All the other calendars are showing as options to select using the TB 91 native and the user names only and location. It was in TB 78 using the add-on. Any suggestions on how to get this calendar to show again?

@Dtrieb
Copy link

Dtrieb commented Aug 19, 2021

@djkraven so did it work for you now?

@gumby-man
Copy link

For me I was able (big thanx to your hint @Dtrieb) to add all calendars I have full rights to. Means my own, and others where I have right to "Make changes & manage sharing". Calendars, where I only have "Make changes to events" access were not available.

@djkraven
Copy link

@Dtrieb I removed the Provider addon and yes all my calendars now display. I just had to manually add the one that wasn't showing using the location example.

The next thing to try is Google Reminders and Tasks. I have not used them in the past but would like to try. TB has a message to select a calendar that supports tasks. I have my calendar selected that I added a task to in the Google webpage defined but the message is still there.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

JPRuehmann commented Aug 21, 2021

Tried to uninstall The AddOn, delete the Callendars and reinstall them but it wont work.
After entering my Name and the Link above I get the Google Authentication (Username, Password, Code via Handy) but then I only get an Error That the Site (https://localhost/...) can´t be connected. If I close that Window I get asked the Password and eveerything begins anew. There is no Change with or without AddOn.
I am now blocked by Google because of to many Failed tries.

How can I reenable mi Callendars?
Thanks.

@sba
Copy link

sba commented Aug 21, 2021

for me with calendar.google.com in location and the gmail-address as username it works perfect without the addon. with https://apidata.googleusercontent.com/caldav/v2/ it does not work.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

This Site can´t be found.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

Will there be a working version for Thunderbird again?

@sba
Copy link

sba commented Aug 23, 2021

Will there be a working version for Thunderbird again?

It works like a charm with the newly built-in google calendar-provide in Thunderbird 91. I think the add-on is no longer needed. i don't see any benefits with the add-on - Maybe you have to start with a new profile if there are problems with the calendar link...

@mrwensveen
Copy link

Will there be a working version for Thunderbird again?

It works like a charm with the newly built-in google calendar-provide in Thunderbird 91. I think the add-on is no longer needed. i don't see any benefits with the add-on - Maybe you have to start with a new profile if there are problems with the calendar link...

If this is true, it's not mentioned anywhere.

@Horst12
Copy link
Author

Horst12 commented Aug 23, 2021

Will there be a working version for Thunderbird again?

It works like a charm with the newly built-in google calendar-provide in Thunderbird 91. I think the add-on is no longer needed. i don't see any benefits with the add-on - Maybe you have to start with a new profile if there are problems with the calendar link...

You still need the Add-on for getting Tasks

@sba
Copy link

sba commented Aug 23, 2021

Will there be a working version for Thunderbird again?

It works like a charm with the newly built-in google calendar-provide in Thunderbird 91. I think the add-on is no longer needed. i don't see any benefits with the add-on - Maybe you have to start with a new profile if there are problems with the calendar link...

You still need the Add-on for getting Tasks

Yes, this is true - tasks are not supported with built-in functionality. Never used, not noticed...

@racofer
Copy link

racofer commented Aug 23, 2021

It works like a charm with the newly built-in google calendar-provide in Thunderbird 91. I think the add-on is no longer needed. i don't see any benefits with the add-on - Maybe you have to start with a new profile if there are problems with the calendar link...

I'm unable to add some calendars from multiple Google accounts, like Holidays, Contacts (for birthdays), and others. If they share the same name on the remote server, even if they come from different Google accounts, I can add only one at a time. And even then, the imported calendars won't allow me to dismiss or snooze notifications. Clean installed TB 91 with the same results.

In the end I installed TbSync and now everything works.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

JPRuehmann commented Aug 23, 2021

No it is completely impossible to add Google callendars with Thunderbirds Build in function
After the Login it trys to display a Site from Localhost which it cannot access..

@Horst12
Copy link
Author

Horst12 commented Aug 23, 2021

No it is completely impossible to add Google callendars with Thunderbirds Build in function
After the Login it trys to display a Site from Localhost which it cannot access..

Then you selcted the wrong entry for adding a calendar.
It very easy to add your Google calendars uising your gmail address.

@Dtrieb
Copy link

Dtrieb commented Aug 23, 2021

🛑 Please stop writing now. 🛑

The plugin actually didn't work so Google Tasks, didn't work at the moment.
But if you only want use your calendar 🗓️ then it works without the plugin.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

No it is not.
I get the =Auth Autentication,
Then it asks for the Callendar rights to permit and then it goes to a localhost page that is not working.

@CheariX
Copy link

CheariX commented Aug 24, 2021

I ran into the issue that the new thunderbird 91 does not show all shared calenders.
I then stumbled upon this link where you can select which calender show up in thunderbird.

@rsiuta
Copy link

rsiuta commented Aug 25, 2021

Is there any way to run Google calendars on Thunderbird 78+ to work as before?
Once again ...
Currently, in Lighting, I can create events in all calendars, but it is not possible to invite participants to them. It is also not Google's fault, because in another e-mail program everything has been working without any problems for over a year.
I can see that not only I have such a problem and there is no solution.
Via CalDav, I can only subscribe to one (first calendar) in my account, but I would like all of them to be visible. Access to other calendars is done.

@kewisch
Copy link
Owner

kewisch commented Aug 28, 2021

Hey folks, please give this one a try: gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

Authentication is not working (blank Screen)
Screenshot_20210829_090126

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

Disabled UBlock Origin, now it works.
Thanks.

@Horst12
Copy link
Author

Horst12 commented Aug 29, 2021

Authentication is not working (blank Screen)
Worked after using another google address.
I only need it for tasks as the other calendars can be accessed with native TB 91

@Reuzenman
Copy link

After installing "gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1" my calendar is working again.

@FabriceC01
Copy link

Hello,
I've downloaded the gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip but how can I install it. it's not an xpi.
Can someone build it ?
thanks for all.

@mrwensveen
Copy link

Hello,
I've downloaded the gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip but how can I install it. it's not an xpi.
Can someone build it ?
thanks for all.

You can rename the .zip file to a .xpi (zippy) file.

@Horst12
Copy link
Author

Horst12 commented Aug 31, 2021

Hello,
I've downloaded the gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip but how can I install it. it's not an xpi.
Can someone build it ?
thanks for all.
Install Add-on from file accepts the zip file without any problem.
No need to do anything else.

@mattmiller747
Copy link

Hey folks, please give this one a try: gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip

THANK YOU - Worked like a charm ! PS a M Bugzilla Moderator Gent said " That is not yet released and has a serious bug. Please remove it to. It has not even passed review!"

@field210
Copy link

will it work with google task in v91?

@jobisoft
Copy link

PS a M Bugzilla Moderator Gent said " That is not yet released and has a serious bug. Please remove it to. It has not even passed review!"

That was me. The developer (kewisch) asked me to abort review of that version, as it has a bug. That is why it is still not available on addons.thunderbird.net.

@Reuzenman
Copy link

will it work with google task in v91?

Yes, my calendar and task working in 91.

@mattmiller747
Copy link

mattmiller747 commented Aug 31, 2021 via email

@chilidad
Copy link

chilidad commented Aug 31, 2021

Sync Google Tasks in Thunderbird 91...

Very glad to see kewisch working to give TB ability to sync tasks with Google Calendar. This will finally get us past the "Please select a calendar that supports tasks" message showing in the TB's Task Tab!

I've installed the abovementioned gdata-provider-91.0.0pre1.zip, and now see the "Google Calendar" option added to the Create New Calendar dialog box (Now shows "On My Computer" "On the Network" and "Google Calendar"). Unfortunately, I can't then get past the authentication login, which has a black screen as JPRuehmann and Horst12 mentioned above.

I'll definitely monitor this thread for further solutions. Thanks again!

@jobisoft
Copy link

jobisoft commented Sep 2, 2021

The update for TB91 has landed! Thanks @kewisch
https://addons.thunderbird.net/addon/provider-for-google-calendar/versions/

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

And with this it won´t work anymore.

@jobisoft
Copy link

jobisoft commented Sep 2, 2021

Could be that you cannot upgrade from the unofficial version. Remove calendars and add them anew.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

JPRuehmann commented Sep 2, 2021

I tyed to remove Callendars, remove the provider, reboot, install the new provider.
Won´t work.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

JPRuehmann commented Sep 2, 2021

Tried to remove the new and reinstall the old wont work to.
Empty window (only Add-On activated is the Google Provider.
Screenshot_20210902_121241

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

But I think thats because iam locked because of to much failed attempts.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

Screenshot_20210902_150526

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

to which destination it should point?

@mattmiller747
Copy link

Hi John et al
As a precaution, I removed the Prior 'bug' version, and then installed the new one and it worked just fine and dandy ! :-)
THANK YOU !!!

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

for me that won´t work , see above Screenshots.

@chilidad
Copy link

chilidad commented Sep 2, 2021

THANK YOU JOHN!!

Note: I've successfully installed Provider_for_google_calendar-91.0.1, and have confirmed up/down syncing with my Google Calendar. FWIW, I've listed below my install log steps that worked for ME. Also listed a few minor bugs below.

Bugs
(See "MINORBUG1" below) In Calendars Tab, when adding, sometimes the "Google Calendar" option shows, sometimes it doesn't.
(See "MINORBUG2" below) In Task List properties, the refresh time should allow refreshing less than 30 minutes.
(See "MINORBUG3" below) Should be able to display tasks on Calendar grid. This is a preference rather than a bug, and it's probably TB core and not related to this Add-on.

Syncing Google Tasks with TB
image

@jobisoft
Copy link

jobisoft commented Sep 2, 2021

I only did the review after @kewisch submitted the add-on to addons.thunderbird.net. He is the one who did the work!

@chilidad
Copy link

chilidad commented Sep 2, 2021

Of course... my bad... ALSO THANKYOU PHILIPP KEWISCH!!!

@Horst12
Copy link
Author

Horst12 commented Sep 2, 2021

Thunderbird updated the Add-on from the pre version successfully to the 91.0.1
I had to allow access to the google data after the first restart.
No problems so far.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

why it did not work for me? the last version before worked?

@rsiuta
Copy link

rsiuta commented Sep 3, 2021

OK I have gdata-provider unzipped. How I can install this in TB?

@jobisoft
Copy link

jobisoft commented Sep 3, 2021

Just search for google in the add-on manager to get the latest version of the povider. No need to manually install something.

@JPRuehmann
Copy link

go to the HamburgerMenue, AddOns, Klick on the Gear Symbol, select Install from File, select the .zip File and open.
If the zip File is not shown rename it to .xpi.

@rsiuta
Copy link

rsiuta commented Sep 3, 2021

Ok, I have all callendars, but I'm still can't invite anybody to meeting for example. I inviting by email adress -> save and exit and ... nothing. When I enter again on meeting - there is nobody ... only main (google email),

@kewisch
Copy link
Owner

kewisch commented Sep 4, 2021

Hey Folks, I'm going to go ahead and close this issue since support for 91 is released. A few random comments I've caught:

@JPRuehmann I'm not sure why the localhost thing shows, the window should be closing by then and the Provider picking out the code. I think you filed a new issues on this, please do if you haven't. Error console messages appreciated!

@chilidad MINORBUG1 -> This doesn't sound great. Can you file a new issue with steps to reproduce, and error console messages for the case where it doesn't show? MINORBUG2 -> This is on purpose to manage the quota I have available for Google Calendar. Refreshing more often can cause some trouble. MINORBU3 -> There is an option for this (View -> Calendar -> Current View -> Tasks in Calendar)

If anyone else is experiencing issues please open a new one.

@kewisch kewisch closed this as completed Sep 4, 2021
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests