Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Sorted Container List #1866

Open
BasicBaer opened this issue Sep 16, 2020 · 23 comments
Open

Sorted Container List #1866

BasicBaer opened this issue Sep 16, 2020 · 23 comments
Assignees
Labels
👍 Feature Request Feature requests users would like to see in this addon

Comments

@BasicBaer
Copy link

If the list of containers becomes longer than a few entries it gets quite annoying to search for the one container you want to use.

Therefore, I would suggest sorting the entries alphabetically.

@BasicBaer BasicBaer changed the title Feature Request / Suggestion: Sorted Conatiner List Feature Request / Suggestion: Sorted Container List Sep 16, 2020
@laggingreflex
Copy link

I'd request an option to sort by "icon".

I'd also request the sort order be customizable.

@mikhey
Copy link

mikhey commented Dec 29, 2020

It would be nice to be able to sort them in a custom order using handles, by name. In addition, it would be an added plus have a search above the list. Grouping would be nice as well, as for example I have several google accounts that I keep in separate tab containers.

Maybe this is all a sign that I'm "abusing" the original design? :-/

@211217613
Copy link

I think a first good step would be to have an option in about:config or somewhere that lets you toggle new containers being opened in a sorted order.

So if I open a new banking container it will open to the right of the current banking container.

@bircher
Copy link

bircher commented Jan 13, 2021

I just synced the containers to a new browser and the original order is totally messed up and there is no way to manually re-order them.
Maybe there is a secret hidden config somewhere I didn't find where the container list config can be edited?

@groovecoder
Copy link
Member

This issue seems to overlap heavily with #330 which was fixed in #1608 and 7.3.0 release is pushed to AMO waiting for review and publish. Are people here happy with that fix for this issue, or should we keep this open?

@grahamperrin
Copy link

@groovecoder thanks for asking, there was overlap but I do think that there's value in retaining this as an enhancement request.

My list of containers is not particularly long, but I would have preferred the option of an immediate sort (not a succession of single moves).

This is not lack of gratitude for #1608 :-) – it's a subtle but important enhancement that may be greatly appreciated by users whose lists are longer than mine.

Whilst alphabetical makes most sense (to me), I recognise the other use cases.

@grahamperrin
Copy link

#1866 (comment)

… synced the containers …

I sync preferences but not add-ons.

Does excluding add-ons also exclude preferences for add-ons?

(The containers that I added to my everyday profile are missing from a test profile, which I synchronised this morning. This surprised me because whilst use of the add-on is commonplace, containers are – essentially – a feature of Firefox.)

@keitalbame
Copy link

Please add alphabetical sorting of containers. I use containers for every site I need to login.
The ability to manually sort the list(thanks for that 👍 ) but I prefer to have it alphabetically sorted.

@zpcol
Copy link

zpcol commented Mar 10, 2021

It is a pain if the container names are not automatically sorted, adding a folder will also be helpful.

@grahamperrin
Copy link

#1866 (comment)

alphabetically

#1673

@frnk01
Copy link

frnk01 commented Jul 2, 2021

Why isnt the alphabetically ordering being implemented? Anyone on the team that can comment?

@enixnetworks
Copy link

Hi, just want to add my name to the list. I have a pile of containers and the right click context menu is almost useless. The add-on icon menu is sorted and much easier to use from a functionality standpoint, but the right click option would be faster if this issue was sorted. No pun intended, of course. Great app.

snip1
snip2

@VerisZG
Copy link

VerisZG commented Jan 29, 2022

BUMP - please ADD SORTING the list in the RIGHT CLICK TAB MENU (open with) according to the sorted list in container list management.

@dannycolin dannycolin added 👍 Feature Request Feature requests users would like to see in this addon and removed enhancement labels May 20, 2022
@dannycolin
Copy link
Collaborator

BUMP - please ADD SORTING the list in the RIGHT CLICK TAB MENU (open with) according to the sorted list in container list management.

This can't be done in Multi-Account Container. It needs to be fixed in Firefox itself.

@dannycolin dannycolin changed the title Feature Request / Suggestion: Sorted Container List Sorted Container List Jul 19, 2022
@dannycolin dannycolin self-assigned this Jul 19, 2022
@TetraAsh
Copy link

Just wanted to support this idea..... i have over 100 containers, and alphabetical sorting would be amazing!

@TechRavingMad
Copy link

I want to add my support for this too. At least alphabetical as a default, specifically the right-click "Open in..." menu.

Best option would be that whenever the list is displayed display it in whatever sort order is in the extension drop-down.

@R4RD0
Copy link

R4RD0 commented Jan 5, 2023

I just moved to a new device and lost my manually sorted list in the process. :(
I had 160 odd listed in there and really didn't want to be dragging and scrolling again.

So went to PowerShell to create a workaround for this and added an option to sort alphabetically by name, icon(name), colour and the default sorting for anyone wanting to sort them while we wait for a more official solution.
https://github.com/R4RD0/Sort-Firefox-Containers

@xanoni
Copy link

xanoni commented Jan 9, 2023

Someone posted a workaround here: #2318 (comment)

@VerisZG
Copy link

VerisZG commented Jan 9, 2023

I just moved to a new device and lost my manually sorted list in the process. :( I had 160 odd listed in there and really didn't want to be dragging and scrolling again.

So went to PowerShell to create a workaround for this and added an option to sort alphabetically by name, icon(name), colour and the default sorting for anyone wanting to sort them while we wait for a more official solution. https://github.com/R4RD0/Sort-Firefox-Containers

Great script!
I modified it a bit to sort by color ascending, then icon descending, then name ascending. For me it makes most sense. If anyone wanted similar functionality just change one line in the script to something like this:

$sortedIdentities = $json.identities | Sort-Object -Property @{Expression = "color"; Descending = $false}, @{Expression = "icon"; Descending = $true}, @{Expression = "name"; Descending = $false}

@xanoni
Copy link

xanoni commented Jan 9, 2023

I had 160 odd listed in there

I think this is the main issue. The extension was designed for folks with just a handful of containers, while you can get much better isolation/privacy with 50+ containers. The UI should be revisited with that in mind.

EDIT: Some way to group/classify containers would be cool. Basically, a folder structure for containers. Two levels should be sufficient.

@VerisZG
Copy link

VerisZG commented Jan 9, 2023

I had 160 odd listed in there

I think this is the main issue. The extension was designed for folks with just a handful of containers, while you can get much better isolation/privacy with 50+ containers. The UI should be revisited with that in mind.

Nested menu might solve many problems or an option after how many items the list should be wrapped to another column. If someone created such an addon, it shouldn't be too hard to add some options to it. My list is growing bigger because I use 1 containter per client (i mean real client like a company). So the list might grow maybe to even 200 items someday.

@MarcusWolschon
Copy link

I sorted my containers using the "manage container"+"drag&drop" mechanism
but the sorting was not applied to the "open existing tab in new container" menu.

@xanoni
Copy link

xanoni commented May 11, 2023

but the sorting was not applied to the "open existing tab in new container" menu.

yep, here is the workaround until it gets fixed: #2318 (comment)

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
👍 Feature Request Feature requests users would like to see in this addon
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests