Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

SimpleChannelPool/FixedChannelPool: Don't put unhealthy channel back to the pool on release #4077

Closed
ioanbsu opened this issue Aug 12, 2015 · 7 comments
Closed

SimpleChannelPool/FixedChannelPool: Don't put unhealthy channel back to the pool on release #4077

ioanbsu opened this issue Aug 12, 2015 · 7 comments
Assignees
@Scottmitch
Labels
feature
Milestone
4.0.31.Final

Comments

@ioanbsu
Copy link

ioanbsu commented Aug 12, 2015

Currently it is required to release channel to the channel pool for FixedChannelPool.
Failure to release a channel may cause that FixedChannelPool.acquiredChannelCount becomes equal or bigger then FixedChannelPool.maxConnections. So basically it means that we have to release back all the channels even those ones that are not healthy, and when channel is released it simply put back into a CimpleChannelPool.deque regardless if it's healthy or not.
Now, on acquire SimpelChannelPool will check if channel is healthy before returning it. If it turns out to be unhealthy then it will discard it and poll the next one from the pool(if there any left in pool) and will continue doing so until it gets healthy channel or until the deque is empty(in which case it will just create a new channel). Though this sort of lazy-discard approach works, I think there is a room for improvement, such as we can filter out unhealthy channels at the time when we release them.

Here is example where such improvement may help:

  1. Client application requested bunch of channels
  2. Before releasing them back to pool all channels become closed cause remote tier closed them
  3. We end up having channelPool full of unhealthy channels.
  4. Next time we will try to acquire new channel we will have to cleanup/discard all unhealthy channels first which may take some time depending on number of unhealthy channels.

It also make sense to filter our unhealthy channels on release because in most cases when someone releases a channel he normally doesn't care about release performance. The more critical in my opinion is acquire performance.
@ioanbsu ioanbsu changed the title FixedChannelPool: Don't put unhealthy channel back to the pool on release SimpleChannelPool/FixedChannelPool: Don't put unhealthy channel back to the pool on release Aug 12, 2015
@ioanbsu ioanbsu mentioned this issue Aug 12, 2015
Closed
@Scottmitch
Copy link
Member

@normanmaurer - I recall discussing this when we originally reviewed the pool. I think your rational was since we have to check the health anyways when we pull out of the pool, and the health check may be expensive (may include RTT), we wanted to minimize the number of health checks done. WDYT?

@normanmaurer
Copy link
Member

@Scottmitch yep that was my argument, I may been wrong here and we should kind of make this configurable. WDYT ?

@Scottmitch
Copy link
Member

@normanmaurer yes. As this issue describes I think there is value in having the option to check up front too.

ioanbsu pushed a commit to ioanbsu/netty that referenced this issue Aug 17, 2015
@ibahdanau
Unhealthy channel is not offered back to the pool.
db9f402 
Motivation:
When releasing unhealthy channel back to a pool we don't have to offer it since on acquire it will be discarded anyways.
 Also checking healthiness at release is a good idea so we don't end up having tons of unhealthy channels in the pool(unless they became unhealthy after being offered)

Modifications:
private SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() method added that is called from SimpleChannelPool.doReleaseChannel(). SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() offers channel back to pool only if channel is healthy.
Otherwise it throws setFailure exception to the promise.

 Result:
The pool is now much cleaner and not spammed with unhealthy channels.

Added ability to choose if channel health has to be validated on release by passing boolean flag.

Motivation:
Depending on performance preferences and individual use cases sometimes we would like to be able force health check of a channel at release time and do not offer it back to the pool. Other times we would want to just release channel and offer it back to the pool and check health only when we try to acquire that channel from the pool. See more details here: netty#4077 (comment)

Modifications:
Future<Void> release(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise, boolean offerHealthyOnly);
The offerHealthyOnly boolean flag allows developers to choose whether to do channel validation before offering it back to pool or not.
Appropriate modifications made to hierarchy of implementations of ChannelPool. offerHealthyOnly=true will force channel health to be checked before offering back to pool. offerHealthyOnly=false  will ignore channel health check and will just try just offer it back to the pool
 offerHealthyOnly=true by default.

Result:
Channel health check before offer back to pool is controlled by a flag now.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:279 line split to be less then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:280:31 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPool.java:282:17 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPoolTest.java:198 - extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

 offerHealthyOnly is passed as a constructor parameter now.

Motivation:
Instead of passing offerHealthyOnly as a method parameter it is better to pass it in as SimpleChannelPool or FixedChannelPool constructor.

Modifications:
 Redundant release method that takes offerHealthyOnly removed from ChannelPool.
 offerHealthyOnly parameter added to constructor for FixedChannelPool and SimpleChannelPool.

Result:
SimpleChannelPool and FixedChannelPool are now take offerHealthyOnly as a constructor parameter. Default behavior is: offerHealthyOnly=true.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:84: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:237: extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Tests do not need to be too  copled to the code. Exception message should not be validated

Motivation:
We don't need our tests to be too coupled to the code. Exception type validation in tests is just good enough.

Modifications:
Exception validation message removed from SimpleChannelPoolTest.testUnhealthyChannelIsNotOffered() test.

Result:
The SimpleChannelPoolTest test is less coupled to the code now.

Stack trace set to empty for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Motivation:
We don't need stack trace for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Modifications:
Added  UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.setStackTrace(EmptyArrays.EMPTY_STACK_TRACE) to static init block.

Result:
UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL's stack trace set to empty.

Minor code re-factorings.

Motivation:
For better code readability we need to apply several minor code re-factorings.

Modifications:
javadocs true -> {@code true}
offerHealthyOnly variable name changed to releaseHeathCheck
<p/> -> <p> in javadocs
offerHealthyOnly removed from doReleaseChannel as it not needed there.

Result:
Code quality is improved.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
SimpleChannelPool.java:87: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Pull request needs to contain only necessary changes

Motivation:
The pull request should not contain unnecessary changes that are not needed as part of required functionality of pull request.

Modifications:
private void doReleaseChannel(final Channel channel, final Promise<Void> promise) - >  private void doReleaseChannel(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise)

Result:
Pull request contains less unnecessary modifications.
Scottmitch pushed a commit that referenced this issue Aug 17, 2015
@ibahdanau @Scottmitch
Unhealthy channel is not offered back to the pool.
b46e070 
Motivation:
When releasing unhealthy channel back to a pool we don't have to offer it since on acquire it will be discarded anyways.
 Also checking healthiness at release is a good idea so we don't end up having tons of unhealthy channels in the pool(unless they became unhealthy after being offered)

Modifications:
private SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() method added that is called from SimpleChannelPool.doReleaseChannel(). SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() offers channel back to pool only if channel is healthy.
Otherwise it throws setFailure exception to the promise.

 Result:
The pool is now much cleaner and not spammed with unhealthy channels.

Added ability to choose if channel health has to be validated on release by passing boolean flag.

Motivation:
Depending on performance preferences and individual use cases sometimes we would like to be able force health check of a channel at release time and do not offer it back to the pool. Other times we would want to just release channel and offer it back to the pool and check health only when we try to acquire that channel from the pool. See more details here: #4077 (comment)

Modifications:
Future<Void> release(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise, boolean offerHealthyOnly);
The offerHealthyOnly boolean flag allows developers to choose whether to do channel validation before offering it back to pool or not.
Appropriate modifications made to hierarchy of implementations of ChannelPool. offerHealthyOnly=true will force channel health to be checked before offering back to pool. offerHealthyOnly=false  will ignore channel health check and will just try just offer it back to the pool
 offerHealthyOnly=true by default.

Result:
Channel health check before offer back to pool is controlled by a flag now.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:279 line split to be less then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:280:31 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPool.java:282:17 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPoolTest.java:198 - extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

 offerHealthyOnly is passed as a constructor parameter now.

Motivation:
Instead of passing offerHealthyOnly as a method parameter it is better to pass it in as SimpleChannelPool or FixedChannelPool constructor.

Modifications:
 Redundant release method that takes offerHealthyOnly removed from ChannelPool.
 offerHealthyOnly parameter added to constructor for FixedChannelPool and SimpleChannelPool.

Result:
SimpleChannelPool and FixedChannelPool are now take offerHealthyOnly as a constructor parameter. Default behavior is: offerHealthyOnly=true.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:84: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:237: extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Tests do not need to be too  copled to the code. Exception message should not be validated

Motivation:
We don't need our tests to be too coupled to the code. Exception type validation in tests is just good enough.

Modifications:
Exception validation message removed from SimpleChannelPoolTest.testUnhealthyChannelIsNotOffered() test.

Result:
The SimpleChannelPoolTest test is less coupled to the code now.

Stack trace set to empty for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Motivation:
We don't need stack trace for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Modifications:
Added  UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.setStackTrace(EmptyArrays.EMPTY_STACK_TRACE) to static init block.

Result:
UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL's stack trace set to empty.

Minor code re-factorings.

Motivation:
For better code readability we need to apply several minor code re-factorings.

Modifications:
javadocs true -> {@code true}
offerHealthyOnly variable name changed to releaseHeathCheck
<p/> -> <p> in javadocs
offerHealthyOnly removed from doReleaseChannel as it not needed there.

Result:
Code quality is improved.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
SimpleChannelPool.java:87: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Pull request needs to contain only necessary changes

Motivation:
The pull request should not contain unnecessary changes that are not needed as part of required functionality of pull request.

Modifications:
private void doReleaseChannel(final Channel channel, final Promise<Void> promise) - >  private void doReleaseChannel(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise)

Result:
Pull request contains less unnecessary modifications.
Scottmitch pushed a commit that referenced this issue Aug 17, 2015
@ibahdanau @Scottmitch
Unhealthy channel is not offered back to the pool.
08b73bf 
Motivation:
When releasing unhealthy channel back to a pool we don't have to offer it since on acquire it will be discarded anyways.
 Also checking healthiness at release is a good idea so we don't end up having tons of unhealthy channels in the pool(unless they became unhealthy after being offered)

Modifications:
private SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() method added that is called from SimpleChannelPool.doReleaseChannel(). SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() offers channel back to pool only if channel is healthy.
Otherwise it throws setFailure exception to the promise.

 Result:
The pool is now much cleaner and not spammed with unhealthy channels.

Added ability to choose if channel health has to be validated on release by passing boolean flag.

Motivation:
Depending on performance preferences and individual use cases sometimes we would like to be able force health check of a channel at release time and do not offer it back to the pool. Other times we would want to just release channel and offer it back to the pool and check health only when we try to acquire that channel from the pool. See more details here: #4077 (comment)

Modifications:
Future<Void> release(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise, boolean offerHealthyOnly);
The offerHealthyOnly boolean flag allows developers to choose whether to do channel validation before offering it back to pool or not.
Appropriate modifications made to hierarchy of implementations of ChannelPool. offerHealthyOnly=true will force channel health to be checked before offering back to pool. offerHealthyOnly=false  will ignore channel health check and will just try just offer it back to the pool
 offerHealthyOnly=true by default.

Result:
Channel health check before offer back to pool is controlled by a flag now.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:279 line split to be less then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:280:31 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPool.java:282:17 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPoolTest.java:198 - extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

 offerHealthyOnly is passed as a constructor parameter now.

Motivation:
Instead of passing offerHealthyOnly as a method parameter it is better to pass it in as SimpleChannelPool or FixedChannelPool constructor.

Modifications:
 Redundant release method that takes offerHealthyOnly removed from ChannelPool.
 offerHealthyOnly parameter added to constructor for FixedChannelPool and SimpleChannelPool.

Result:
SimpleChannelPool and FixedChannelPool are now take offerHealthyOnly as a constructor parameter. Default behavior is: offerHealthyOnly=true.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:84: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:237: extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Tests do not need to be too  copled to the code. Exception message should not be validated

Motivation:
We don't need our tests to be too coupled to the code. Exception type validation in tests is just good enough.

Modifications:
Exception validation message removed from SimpleChannelPoolTest.testUnhealthyChannelIsNotOffered() test.

Result:
The SimpleChannelPoolTest test is less coupled to the code now.

Stack trace set to empty for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Motivation:
We don't need stack trace for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Modifications:
Added  UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.setStackTrace(EmptyArrays.EMPTY_STACK_TRACE) to static init block.

Result:
UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL's stack trace set to empty.

Minor code re-factorings.

Motivation:
For better code readability we need to apply several minor code re-factorings.

Modifications:
javadocs true -> {@code true}
offerHealthyOnly variable name changed to releaseHeathCheck
<p/> -> <p> in javadocs
offerHealthyOnly removed from doReleaseChannel as it not needed there.

Result:
Code quality is improved.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
SimpleChannelPool.java:87: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Pull request needs to contain only necessary changes

Motivation:
The pull request should not contain unnecessary changes that are not needed as part of required functionality of pull request.

Modifications:
private void doReleaseChannel(final Channel channel, final Promise<Void> promise) - >  private void doReleaseChannel(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise)

Result:
Pull request contains less unnecessary modifications.
Scottmitch pushed a commit that referenced this issue Aug 17, 2015
@ibahdanau @Scottmitch
Unhealthy channel is not offered back to the pool.
144f3ec 
Motivation:
When releasing unhealthy channel back to a pool we don't have to offer it since on acquire it will be discarded anyways.
 Also checking healthiness at release is a good idea so we don't end up having tons of unhealthy channels in the pool(unless they became unhealthy after being offered)

Modifications:
private SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() method added that is called from SimpleChannelPool.doReleaseChannel(). SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() offers channel back to pool only if channel is healthy.
Otherwise it throws setFailure exception to the promise.

 Result:
The pool is now much cleaner and not spammed with unhealthy channels.

Added ability to choose if channel health has to be validated on release by passing boolean flag.

Motivation:
Depending on performance preferences and individual use cases sometimes we would like to be able force health check of a channel at release time and do not offer it back to the pool. Other times we would want to just release channel and offer it back to the pool and check health only when we try to acquire that channel from the pool. See more details here: #4077 (comment)

Modifications:
Future<Void> release(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise, boolean offerHealthyOnly);
The offerHealthyOnly boolean flag allows developers to choose whether to do channel validation before offering it back to pool or not.
Appropriate modifications made to hierarchy of implementations of ChannelPool. offerHealthyOnly=true will force channel health to be checked before offering back to pool. offerHealthyOnly=false  will ignore channel health check and will just try just offer it back to the pool
 offerHealthyOnly=true by default.

Result:
Channel health check before offer back to pool is controlled by a flag now.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:279 line split to be less then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:280:31 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPool.java:282:17 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPoolTest.java:198 - extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

 offerHealthyOnly is passed as a constructor parameter now.

Motivation:
Instead of passing offerHealthyOnly as a method parameter it is better to pass it in as SimpleChannelPool or FixedChannelPool constructor.

Modifications:
 Redundant release method that takes offerHealthyOnly removed from ChannelPool.
 offerHealthyOnly parameter added to constructor for FixedChannelPool and SimpleChannelPool.

Result:
SimpleChannelPool and FixedChannelPool are now take offerHealthyOnly as a constructor parameter. Default behavior is: offerHealthyOnly=true.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:84: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:237: extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Tests do not need to be too  copled to the code. Exception message should not be validated

Motivation:
We don't need our tests to be too coupled to the code. Exception type validation in tests is just good enough.

Modifications:
Exception validation message removed from SimpleChannelPoolTest.testUnhealthyChannelIsNotOffered() test.

Result:
The SimpleChannelPoolTest test is less coupled to the code now.

Stack trace set to empty for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Motivation:
We don't need stack trace for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Modifications:
Added  UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.setStackTrace(EmptyArrays.EMPTY_STACK_TRACE) to static init block.

Result:
UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL's stack trace set to empty.

Minor code re-factorings.

Motivation:
For better code readability we need to apply several minor code re-factorings.

Modifications:
javadocs true -> {@code true}
offerHealthyOnly variable name changed to releaseHeathCheck
<p/> -> <p> in javadocs
offerHealthyOnly removed from doReleaseChannel as it not needed there.

Result:
Code quality is improved.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
SimpleChannelPool.java:87: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Pull request needs to contain only necessary changes

Motivation:
The pull request should not contain unnecessary changes that are not needed as part of required functionality of pull request.

Modifications:
private void doReleaseChannel(final Channel channel, final Promise<Void> promise) - >  private void doReleaseChannel(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise)

Result:
Pull request contains less unnecessary modifications.
@Scottmitch
Copy link
Member

Fixed by #4078

@Scottmitch Scottmitch added this to the 4.0.31.Final milestone Aug 17, 2015
@Scottmitch Scottmitch self-assigned this Aug 17, 2015
@trustin
Copy link
Member

trustin commented Aug 18, 2015

@Scottmitch Please make sure not to introduce a build breakage when you cherry-pick into 4.0 and 4.1

@Scottmitch
Copy link
Member

@trustin - I'm sorry. Will be more careful in the future. Thanks for cleaning up after my mess.

@trustin
Copy link
Member

trustin commented Aug 18, 2015

@Scottmitch No worries. I make the same mistake over and over. :-)

pulllock pushed a commit to pulllock/netty that referenced this issue Oct 19, 2023
@ibahdanau @Scottmitch
Unhealthy channel is not offered back to the pool.
d615773 
Motivation:
When releasing unhealthy channel back to a pool we don't have to offer it since on acquire it will be discarded anyways.
 Also checking healthiness at release is a good idea so we don't end up having tons of unhealthy channels in the pool(unless they became unhealthy after being offered)

Modifications:
private SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() method added that is called from SimpleChannelPool.doReleaseChannel(). SimpleChannelPool.offerIfHealthy() offers channel back to pool only if channel is healthy.
Otherwise it throws setFailure exception to the promise.

 Result:
The pool is now much cleaner and not spammed with unhealthy channels.

Added ability to choose if channel health has to be validated on release by passing boolean flag.

Motivation:
Depending on performance preferences and individual use cases sometimes we would like to be able force health check of a channel at release time and do not offer it back to the pool. Other times we would want to just release channel and offer it back to the pool and check health only when we try to acquire that channel from the pool. See more details here: netty#4077 (comment)

Modifications:
Future<Void> release(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise, boolean offerHealthyOnly);
The offerHealthyOnly boolean flag allows developers to choose whether to do channel validation before offering it back to pool or not.
Appropriate modifications made to hierarchy of implementations of ChannelPool. offerHealthyOnly=true will force channel health to be checked before offering back to pool. offerHealthyOnly=false  will ignore channel health check and will just try just offer it back to the pool
 offerHealthyOnly=true by default.

Result:
Channel health check before offer back to pool is controlled by a flag now.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:279 line split to be less then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:280:31 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPool.java:282:17 space added after '{'
 SimpleChannelPoolTest.java:198 - extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

 offerHealthyOnly is passed as a constructor parameter now.

Motivation:
Instead of passing offerHealthyOnly as a method parameter it is better to pass it in as SimpleChannelPool or FixedChannelPool constructor.

Modifications:
 Redundant release method that takes offerHealthyOnly removed from ChannelPool.
 offerHealthyOnly parameter added to constructor for FixedChannelPool and SimpleChannelPool.

Result:
SimpleChannelPool and FixedChannelPool are now take offerHealthyOnly as a constructor parameter. Default behavior is: offerHealthyOnly=true.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
 SimpleChannelPool.java:84: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.
 SimpleChannelPool.java:237: extra white space line removed.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Tests do not need to be too  copled to the code. Exception message should not be validated

Motivation:
We don't need our tests to be too coupled to the code. Exception type validation in tests is just good enough.

Modifications:
Exception validation message removed from SimpleChannelPoolTest.testUnhealthyChannelIsNotOffered() test.

Result:
The SimpleChannelPoolTest test is less coupled to the code now.

Stack trace set to empty for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Motivation:
We don't need stack trace for UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.

Modifications:
Added  UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL.setStackTrace(EmptyArrays.EMPTY_STACK_TRACE) to static init block.

Result:
UNHEALTHY_NON_OFFERED_TO_POOL's stack trace set to empty.

Minor code re-factorings.

Motivation:
For better code readability we need to apply several minor code re-factorings.

Modifications:
javadocs true -> {@code true}
offerHealthyOnly variable name changed to releaseHeathCheck
<p/> -> <p> in javadocs
offerHealthyOnly removed from doReleaseChannel as it not needed there.

Result:
Code quality is improved.

Code changed to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Motivation:
Code needs to satisfy checkstyle requirements.

Modifications:
SimpleChannelPool.java:87: line made to be no longer then 120 characters.

Result:
Code satisfies checkstyle requirements.

Pull request needs to contain only necessary changes

Motivation:
The pull request should not contain unnecessary changes that are not needed as part of required functionality of pull request.

Modifications:
private void doReleaseChannel(final Channel channel, final Promise<Void> promise) - >  private void doReleaseChannel(Channel channel, Promise<Void> promise)

Result:
Pull request contains less unnecessary modifications.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@Scottmitch Scottmitch

Labels
feature
Projects
None yet
Milestone
4.0.31.Final
Development

No branches or pull requests
4 participants
@trustin @normanmaurer @ioanbsu @Scottmitch