lxc-attach: waydroid: ../src/lxc/attach.c: lxc_attach_run_command: 1841 No such file or directory - Failed to exec "service"

[just-a-pony]

Describe the bug
A clear and concise description of what the bug is.

systemctl start waydroid-container.service

sudo waydroid_magisk.py install

[16:51:41] - INFO - Downloading Magisk Delta: canary-80855189-delta
[16:51:42] - INFO - Extracting Magisk Delta
[16:51:42] - INFO - Installing Magisk Delta
[16:51:42] - INFO - Backing up bootanim.rc
[16:51:42] - INFO - Patching bootanim.rc
[16:51:42] - INFO - Finishing installation
[16:51:42] - INFO - Done
[16:51:42] - INFO - Run waydroid_magisk setup after waydroid starts again or install Magisk Delta Manager

waydroid show-full-ui
sudo waydroid_magisk.py setup

[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
[16:53:08] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 5 (press ^C to cancel)
[16:53:09] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 4 (press ^C to cancel)
[16:53:10] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 3 (press ^C to cancel)
[16:53:11] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 2 (press ^C to cancel)
[16:53:12] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 1 (press ^C to cancel)
[16:53:13] - INFO - Stopping waydroid
lxc-attach: waydroid: ../src/lxc/attach.c: lxc_attach_run_command: 1841 No such file or directory - Failed to exec "service"
[16:53:13] - INFO - Starting Waydroid

Now,if i install nagisk delta manually from apk in the waydroid,it will show

If i ckick "ok", "dirct install into system partition",

if i ctrl+c waydroid show-full-ui ,and rerun sudo waydroid_magisk.py install,

[17:04:43] - ERROR - Magisk Delta already installed!

Logs
From sudo waydroid_magisk log --save
No,it will show [17:04:14] - ERROR - Magisk Delta is not installed
Desktop (please complete the following information):

• OS: [e.g. iOS] Arch Linux with linux-xanmod-anbox
• Waydroid Version: [e.g. 1.4.0] 1.3.4

Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.

[just-a-pony]

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1IzjPT9Q9XrGycC-C3ow-NaUHjLmccexG/view?usp=sharing
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SZHD8O-q3gPvn4JNIT11H19bG2jfSgca/view?usp=sharing
/usr/share/waydroid-extra/images/

[nitanmarcel]

Are the images used clean? Meaning no other modifications applied to it.

Also a cleanup with rm -rf /var/lib/waydroid and sudo waydroid init should probably fix it, as it seems something went wrong when installing Magisk

[nitanmarcel]

Oh sorry.

The last two commits should fix it. Instead of cleaning the images you can do (after updating waydroid-magisk)

sudo waydroid_magisk remove

Then start everything based by the instructions.

[nitanmarcel]

And about the Magisk Delta Manager error. I've moved the FAQ related to it from the Ubuntu Touch section to a section of it's own.

https://github.com/nitanmarcel/waydroid-magisk#magisk-delta-fails-to-patch-selinux-policy (Note that you can still use Magisk Delta Manager, but just don't update, do the additional setup from the manager"

[just-a-pony]

Oh sorry.

The last two commits should fix it. Instead of cleaning the images you can do (after updating waydroid-magisk)

sudo waydroid_magisk remove

Then start everything based by the instructions.

Thanks! it works!

[21:19:59] - INFO - Daemon: Running
[21:19:59] - INFO - Magisk Version: 80855189-delta:MAGISKSU

But there's still a lxc-attach: waydroid: ../src/lxc/attach.c: lxc_attach_run_command: 1841 No such file or directory - Failed to exec "service" during the waydroid_magisk.py setup

[21:19:08] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 5 (press ^C to cancel)
[21:19:09] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 4 (press ^C to cancel)
[21:19:10] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 3 (press ^C to cancel)
[21:19:11] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 2 (press ^C to cancel)
[21:19:12] - INFO - Stopping Waydroid in 1 (press ^C to cancel)
[21:19:13] - INFO - Stopping waydroid
lxc-attach: waydroid: ../src/lxc/attach.c: lxc_attach_run_command: 1841 No such file or directory - Failed to exec "service"
[21:19:13] - INFO - Starting Waydroid

[nitanmarcel]

Ignore that. I should probably silence it. Or probably see why it's broken on some distros.

Anyway, closing this issue :) glad we got it working

[nitanmarcel]

Actually @just-a-pony in sudo waydroid shell can you do which service and send me the output?

Thanks

[just-a-pony]

Actually @just-a-pony in sudo waydroid shell can you do which service and send me the output?

Thanks

/system/bin/service
And if I run service call waydroidhardware 4manually in the waydroid,It seams work properly which restart the waydroid

[just-a-pony]

I found this in archwiki :

5.3 Error: unknown command
The error may happen when a basic command (ls, cat, etc.) on an attached container is typed hen a different Linux distribution is containerized relative to the host system (e.g. Debian container in Arch Linux host system). Upon attaching, use the argument --clear-env:
lxc-attach -n container_name --clear-env

[nitanmarcel]

I found this in archwiki :

5.3 Error: unknown command
The error may happen when a basic command (ls, cat, etc.) on an attached container is typed hen a different Linux distribution is containerized relative to the host system (e.g. Debian container in Arch Linux host system). Upon attaching, use the argument --clear-env:
lxc-attach -n container_name --clear-env

Oh. My bad there. It seems I forgot to pass the env argument in subprocess.run

[nitanmarcel]

I found this in archwiki :

5.3 Error: unknown command
The error may happen when a basic command (ls, cat, etc.) on an attached container is typed hen a different Linux distribution is containerized relative to the host system (e.g. Debian container in Arch Linux host system). Upon attaching, use the argument --clear-env:
lxc-attach -n container_name --clear-env

this should be also fixed now