Linux window position saving

[oakmac]

I'm noticing a bug on Linux (Xubuntu 14.04) where the window position adjusts between application closing / opening.

Here is window.json opening and closing 4 times:

{"maximized":false,"position":[258,136],"size":[1000,850]}
{"maximized":false,"position":[259,160],"size":[1000,850]}
{"maximized":false,"position":[260,184],"size":[1000,850]}
{"maximized":false,"position":[261,208],"size":[1000,850]}

Every time the window is closed it adjusts x by x + 1 and y by y + 24.

Not seeing this behavior on Windows. Wonder if this is an xfce thing, an atom-shell thing, all Linux? Who knows.

Might also have to do with the way we're closing the window right now using destroy() instead of following normal window close lifecycle.

[oakmac]

Would be great if someone could reproduce this on Linux using a different window manager.

[comamitc]

Happening on ubuntu too. Eventually stops moving on y coordinates.

[oakmac]

Is it adjusting in the same way? ie: x+1, y+24?
Which version of Ubuntu? Window manager? etc
You can check this in the window.json file located in ~/.config/Cuttle/window.json
It should be updated everytime the application is closed.

[comamitc]

no x movement and different y movement on ubuntu 14.04; window manager is Unity.

comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,80],"size":[1000,850]}
comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,108],"size":[1000,850]}

[oakmac]

Can we see a few more iterations of that just to confirm a pattern?

[comamitc]

comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,80],"size":[1000,850]}
comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,108],"size":[1000,850]}
comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,128],"size":[1000,850]}
comamitc@ubuntu:~/.config/Cuttle$ cat window.json 
{"maximized":false,"position":[253,128],"size":[1000,850]}

Appears to move to the bounds on the UI and then stops.

[comamitc]

I believe this might be worthy of an Atom-Shell bug. If they feel the need to escalate to the various UNIX window managers due to inconsistency, I believe the maintainers should be responsible for that.

[oakmac]

Yeah - this feels like an atom-shell (or deeper, chromium?) bug to me. I will open an issue there and see what they say.