Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Obj definition #44

Closed
downFast opened this issue May 10, 2020 · 9 comments
Closed

Obj definition #44

downFast opened this issue May 10, 2020 · 9 comments
Labels
docs Improvements or additions to documentation

Comments

@downFast
Copy link

downFast commented May 10, 2020

Hi
thanks for the work, could you help on defining your keys?

An example:

"iso_code": "ITA",
"location": "Italy",
"date": "2020-01-05",
"total_cases": 0,
"new_cases": 0,
"total_deaths": 0,
"new_deaths": 0,
"total_cases_per_million": 0,
"new_cases_per_million": 0,
"total_deaths_per_million": 0,
"new_deaths_per_million": 0,
"total_tests": null,
"new_tests": null,
"total_tests_per_thousand": null,
"new_tests_per_thousand": null,
"tests_units": "",
"population": 60461828,
"population_density": 205.859,
"median_age": 47.9,
"aged_65_older": 23.021,
"aged_70_older": 16.24,
"gdp_per_capita": 35220.084,
"extreme_poverty": 2,
"cvd_death_rate": 113.15100000000001,
"diabetes_prevalence": 4.78,
"female_smokers": 19.8,
"male_smokers": 27.8,
"handwashing_facilities": null,
"hospital_beds_per_100k": 3.18

What do the following means?

tests_units

"extreme_poverty": 2, (what is 2?)

"handwashing_facilities": null, What is it? What do you mean?

"hospital_beds_per_100k": 3.18 This can be dangerous data if we don't say what beds for what hospital division

"gdp_per_capita": 35220.084, what is the value, million, thousand?

"cvd_death_rate": 113.15100000000001, what value is this rate?

Basically we'd need some definition on all the keys to better understand and work with this data

Thanks a lot

@edomt
Copy link
Collaborator

edomt commented May 10, 2020

Hi @downFast

A full codebook is made available (owid-covid-data-codebook.md), with a description and source for each variable in the dataset.

As for "null", I assume that this value is added by the software you're using to download the data. Those cells are empty in our dataset, which means we don't have a value for that location/date/variable.

Edouard

@edomt edomt closed this as completed May 10, 2020
@edomt edomt added the docs Improvements or additions to documentation label May 10, 2020
@downFast
Copy link
Author

Oh ok, missed that. Thanks

in regards of null, I meant what handwashing_facilities was but I guess it's in the codebook, null is what I get once i convert csv to json.

Any plan to add long and lat for each location btw?

thanks

@edomt
Copy link
Collaborator

edomt commented May 10, 2020

@downFast We don't have plans to add lat/lon for now, but you can probably merge our dataset with this one for example.

@downFast
Copy link
Author

downFast commented May 10, 2020

this one

yes exactly what I was looking at. Thanks

@downFast
Copy link
Author

downFast commented May 10, 2020

Hi
I am wondering about some of your data:

extreme_poverty shows 2.0 for Italy, is it in % and then it means the 2%?

And are we sure is correct?

Look at this https://www.istat.it/it/files//2011/07/poverta_15_7_2011_inglese.pdf

Also you say, for Italy: recovered: 0 on 9/5/20, but actually there are 103.031 recovered, data is provided here https://github.com/pcm-dpc/COVID-19/tree/master/dati-json

I mean, how rialable is your data? I appreciate your work and I would like to implement it but I need to be sure of the data.

Thank you

--

@edomt
Copy link
Collaborator

edomt commented May 10, 2020

Hi @downFast

  • Regarding extreme poverty, yes, 2.0 means 2%. I don't see any contradiction between the link you pointed to and our data. Note that the variable in the dataset is extreme poverty. As noted in the codebook, the data on extreme poverty comes directly from the World Bank. You can find more information on this metric on our website, including a very detailed explanation of the "extreme poverty" measure in the "Sources" tab of the graph.

  • Our dataset doesn't include any data on COVID-19 recoveries, so I'm not sure where you're getting this "0" from. Could you please point to the specific file and row?

Edouard

@downFast
Copy link
Author

downFast commented May 10, 2020

Hi @downFast

  • Regarding extreme poverty, yes, 2.0 means 2%. I don't see any contradiction between the link you pointed to and our data. Note that the variable in the dataset is extreme poverty. As noted in the codebook, the data on extreme poverty comes directly from the World Bank. You can find more information on this metric on our website, including a very detailed explanation of the "extreme poverty" measure in the "Sources" tab of the graph.
  • Our dataset doesn't include any data on COVID-19 recoveries, so I'm not sure where you're getting this "0" from. Could you please point to the specific file and row?

Edouard

Ouch, my apologies, I was merging more data into it and got confused about recovered.

My fault :)

In terms of extreme_poverty, thanks a lot, I have read the source. Just that I know if you don't mind, how would you say the link I've posted doesn't contradicts your data?

I'm not arguing, I'm genuinely asking as i'd like to better understand it, my plan is to try to explain in plain words some of thoese keys to users, but I first need to understand it myself. So how would I check it against the link I've sent?

Thanks a lot

@downFast
Copy link
Author

I mean where should I look at to compare data regarding the poverty level?

@edomt
Copy link
Collaborator

edomt commented May 10, 2020

I don't have good knowledge of poverty levels in Italy, but given this sentence in the document:
"In 2010 the relative poverty incidence was equal to 11%, whereas the absolute poverty to 4.6%."
it seems plausible that the level of extreme poverty would be around 2%.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
docs Improvements or additions to documentation
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants