New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[Wishlist] Availability Column #1632
Comments
From: http://libtorrent.org/manual.html If we are a seed, the piece picker is deallocated as an optimization, and piece availability is no longer tracked. In this case the distributed copies members are set to -1. This means this column would display meaningful data when not seeding, when the information is available in the "General" tab. |
@Nemo-qB as pmzqla said this will not display a value when seeding. So is this meaningful to have only for downloading torrents? |
The idea behind was that when you are seeding a new torrent (or any other seeding task) you could see the swarms availability so you would knew how far everyone is and how the piece distribution is shared. Its the same as the General tab but instead it shows the availability from the peers in swarm while seeding that are connected to you. An example: As you can see its 100% and seeding. The availability bar shows 1.250 and 13 peers connected. The 1.000 is you, and the other 250 (25%) is the total pieces available shared over 13 peers. There is also an availability column top right showing the same number. Or a scenario when it could be handy is when you're downloading a few torrents at the same time; instead clicking each of them one by one to see their availability at the General tab you can see it all right away at the column. I hope I explained it right, if not im open to go more in depth details if needed or correct myself if I made a mistake somewhere. So is this meaningful to have only for downloading torrents? Its not necessary needed, nothing high prio. Its just an extra column showing the same information as the General tab availability bar in short. If it only shows for downloading thats also fine by me. Im completely okay with it if you drop it from the milestone of v3.2.0 if you think the same :). |
I would like the availability column as implemented in uTorrent. For all torrents, not just actively downloading ones. It is helpful to see, at a glance, which torrents have high vs. low availablity. |
Apologies if this isn't constructive but I second the request for availability as a column, |
Why Availability for seeding torrents is always 1 Seeding peers DO NOT connect to other seeding peers so any one seeding peer cannot 'know' how many seeds there are 'on line'. Just because uTorrent lies and provides totally useless information is no justification for qbittorrent to also do so. |
Fair enough, and in retrospect, I guess all the times I've looked to µTorrent's availability column in order to make a decision it's never concerned seeding torrents anyway. Still would be cool, convenient, and sometimes necessary to have an availability column. Might even be motivation enough to try and teach myself enough C++ to do it myself. Anyway, thank you chrishirst for your prompt and helpful response |
What about getting the swarm information from the trackers? |
The problem is that libtorrent doesn't allow us to get the availability of seeding torrents (unless something changed recently, see my reply here above), so there's not much we can do. |
It is old, out of date (cached by trackers), inaccurate information that provides nothing useful about the current state of 'health' of a torrent or it's swarm. |
We could make a "hack". Just don't display a value for seeding torrents. Especially after #4675 is merged. |
+1 for me as i was just about to submit a duplicate. i used it in my utorrent days and would like to have it in qbittorrent as I find it important when downloading a torrent as a leecher, so that i know how likely and fast it will complete, especially when i'm downloading 2 or more versions of the same content. |
@sledgehammer999 Don't want to bother you directly on such a small request, it just popped up on the forums and the hide feature has been merged. Not saying it must be done, just bringing it up so you can put a milestone on it or something - if you wish. |
Dunno if anyone from @qbittorrent/qbittorrent-frequent-contributors was to implement it. Also, IIRC, libtorrent doesn't report availability when seeding because it disconnects from seeds. |
Read that above, yes, but it is said that it would be false information anyhow. So that's okay. Thank you for pinging the others. |
I would also like this. Very much. I sort my torrents by availability. |
One of the things I used a lot in BitTorrent that is missing from qBittorrent is the availability column. When you have hundreds of items in your queue it is very useful to quickly glance at the availability. I would also like to see this feature added. |
@Chocobo1, please take a look at this long-standing feature request. What do you say? |
I submitted PR #10954. |
A simple availability column just like Name, Status etc. which also gets updated continuesly when seeding to see the shared data of the leechers.
See here for more information: http://qbforums.shiki.hu/index.php/topic,2552.msg10800.html#new
Regards, Nemo.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: