Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feeds with <source:blogroll> elements in their RSS feeds #308

Open
scripting opened this issue May 26, 2024 · 9 comments
Open

Feeds with <source:blogroll> elements in their RSS feeds #308

scripting opened this issue May 26, 2024 · 9 comments

Comments

@scripting
Copy link
Owner

scripting commented May 26, 2024

I'm working on a bit of demo software and need a few blogroll-supporting feeds that have a <source:blogroll> element.

You can see an example in the feed for my blog.

http://scripting.com/rss.xml

If you have one, please post a link here or send me an email.

Hopefully we have enough of them now to start a bootstrap. :-)

To get started I only need two or three, a few more would be nice to have.

Extra points if your blogroll links to another site that also has a blogroll.

@ralexander-phi
Copy link

If I can include RSS feeds which <link> to a web page which has the <link rel=blogroll ... element, I think the is the longest chain I've discovered is eight feeds:

There's a loop between jlelse.blog and colinwalker.blog. There's a lot of micro.blog and feedland here, as you'd probably expect.

You can explore those connections here: https://alexsci.com/rss-blogroll-network/discover/feed-fa0b115a98a2db75b61d52ca6e8c7846/ (although I'll caution that there's some missing links I need to fix).

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

Thank you! Now I've got something to play with. :-)

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

scripting commented May 27, 2024

Good morning, @ralexander-phi --

I have Manton in my blogroll, and thought that his feed would have a link but it doesn't appear to.

https://www.manton.org/feed.xml

Maybe that's not the right URL.

For now I need a handful of feeds with links to blogrolls.

I don't mind extending my software to look for <link rel="blogroll">s.

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

I added

https://feedland.social/?feedurl=https%3A%2F%2Fcolinwalker.blog%2Fdailyfeed.xml

Back to my blogroll. I had removed it because he was posting every day with items that said "nothing happened today" or something like that, and I felt that was not good subject matter for my blogroll. ;-)

But he's back to posting, and he has a blogroll link in his feed, so I've got at least one to play with.

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

I added your first feed --

https://feedland.social/?feedurl=https%3A%2F%2Falexsci.com%2Fblog%2Frss.xml

His most recent piece is a gem! These are the kinds of things I never want to miss, yet I did miss it.

https://alexsci.com/blog/blogroll-network/?campaign=rss

That is what we are about to explore with real blogs, feeds and subscription lists.

There are enough bloggers supporting this that we (probably) have a good demo, that's what I am playing with today.

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

scripting commented May 27, 2024

Now here's an example of a feed I want in my blogroll,

https://jlelse.blog/.rss

But -- it doesn't have a source:blogroll element in the feed. Instead he says the link is in his HTML, which I could find by looking at that, but I'd much rather see people put the link in their feed. Makes it a little easier for aggregators.

However...

https://jlelse.blog/blogroll.opml

I did subscrbe to his OPML file as a reading list in FeedLand. It's the one without a title in this list.

https://feedland.social/?readinglists=davewiner

Those are the reading lists I'm subscribed to. (FeedLand allows you to subscribe to OPML files, that's what a reading list is.)

It's realllly important to put titles and creation dates at least in your OPML files.

@colin-walker
Copy link

But he's back to posting...

Now that I've scrapped my live feed and only use the Daily I'm going to remove the "no posts" reference so it will only include those days with something posted.

@ralexander-phi
Copy link

I'd much rather see people put the link in their feed. Makes it a little easier for aggregators.

I like the idea of keeping things XML only, but I think HTML offers an easier on-ramp for users. Not all RSS feed generators support the source:blogroll element yet, so users who want to participate today may need to use the HTML link approach. Looking at FeedLand, I'm not sure if I can currently point my feed at my blogroll, for example. Maybe that should be included by default?

Those are the reading lists I'm subscribed to.

I realize OPML supports the <outline type="include" ...> format. @scripting would it make sense for your OPML blogroll for point to each of the OPML blogrolls in your reading list?

@scripting
Copy link
Owner Author

No one supports any of the blogroll stuff yet. Barely getting started.

For that reason, at this point adding includes anywhere in here is not really a possibility.

I don't have a feel yet for how this is going to work, still puzzling it out.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants