doctrine/annotations dependency tells to require sensio/framework-extra-bundle

[MatTheCat]

When I tried to use make:controller I got

[ERROR] Missing package: to use the make:controller command, run:

    composer require annotations 

which I ran, before realizing it was installing sensio/framework-extra-bundle.

That surprised me because you're no longer supposed to require this bundle to annotate routes. Then I saw

we only need doctrine/annotations

in https://github.com/symfony/maker-bundle/blob/master/src/Maker/MakeController.php#L89

So why does it ask to install sensio/framework-extra-bundle?

This also concerns MakeRegistrationForm.

[MatTheCat]

I just found symfony/symfony-docs#10426

So basically we want the user to install the whole framework-extra-bundle because they may need it??

[weaverryan]

I’d be ok with changing to doctrine-annotations. Though, that change can only be made for makers that don’t rely on the param converter from FwExtraBundle.

[MatTheCat]

These are MakeRegistrationForm and MakeController. I could submit a PR tomorrow.