Creator names vs creator IRIs

[hauschke]

[
a sh:ValidationResult ;
sh:resultSeverity sh:Violation ;
sh:sourceConstraintComponent sh:NodeKindConstraintComponent ;
sh:sourceShape _:n3042 ;
sh:focusNode http://ontology.tib.eu/gesah/ ;
sh:value “Birte Rubach” ;
sh:resultPath _:n3043 ;
sh:resultMessage “The ontology does not state its creator via IRI. We recommend to provide PIDs for individuals (e.g. ORCiD) or organisations (e.g. ROR).”@en ;
] .
[
a sh:ValidationResult ;
sh:resultSeverity sh:Violation ;
sh:sourceConstraintComponent sh:NodeKindConstraintComponent ;
sh:sourceShape _:n3042 ;
sh:focusNode http://ontology.tib.eu/gesah/ ;
sh:value “Tatiana Walther” ;
sh:resultPath _:n3043 ;
sh:resultMessage “The ontology does not state its creator via IRI. We recommend to provide PIDs for individuals (e.g. ORCiD) or organisations (e.g. ROR).”@en ;
] .

Should we swap the labels for the creators (and contributors) with IRIs?

Pro: Machine-readable
Con: not human-readable.

Discussion needed with @SArndt-TIB.

[hauschke]

This was clarified in the new validation, thanks @SArndt-TIB!

[
	a sh:ValidationResult ;
	sh:resultSeverity sh:Info ;
	sh:sourceConstraintComponent sh:NodeKindConstraintComponent ;
	sh:sourceShape _:n14590 ;
	sh:focusNode <http://ontology.tib.eu/gesah/> ;
	sh:value "Simon Paulus" ;
	sh:resultPath _:n14591 ;
	sh:resultMessage "
            The contributor information provided is not an IRI.
            Please make sure to provide identifiers wherever possible.
            Contributors should be referenced via PIDs, e.g. ORCiDs for persons and RORs for organisations.
            Plain name strings should only be provided in addition (for readability).
            If an ontology is developed by a larger group, it is recommended to give the organization or project identifier as the creator and list individual persons as contributors.
            Recommended property: <https://purl.org/dc/terms/contributor>
            Example statement (text/turtle): <https://www.purl.org/SomeOntology> <https://purl.org/dc/terms/contributor> <https://orcid.org/0000-0000-0000-0000>.
        "@en ;
] .

[tawahle]

Done.